Sunak refuses to even utter the word crisis. But how else to describe his first 100 days? | Polly Toynbee

Inertia on the NHS and obstinacy on strikes have left the equivocating PM clinging to a life raft

After the mayhem, after Liz Truss blew up the economy, the only way was up. Things could only get better – or so you would have thought. But Rishi Sunak’s 100 days to steady the ship have left him and his party clinging to a life raft.

Yesterday the half a million public servants out on strike were largely backed by voters unwilling to see the pay of nurses, teachers and the rest fall behind inflation and below the private sector.

Today the Bank of England foolishly raised interest rates to a shocking 4%, steering into the headwinds of recession while the IMF predicts only the UK will fall back while all others grow. With food prices up 17%, and mortgages and rents rising again, the Bank hopes unemployment will rise too: it may be independent, but a strong Keynesian steer from government would have deterred this austerian folly.

Fewer than 100 days remain before Sunak faces the electorate’s verdict in May’s local elections. No one has voted for him. His own party doesn’t like him: Sunak is near the bottom of ConservativeHome’s ranking of cabinet ministers and prominent Tory MPs by party members, at just 2.9% approval: about the same as Dominic Raab. Sunak falls behind Keir Starmer on every polling measure, from best to run the economy to best prime minister.

How bad is this? Only Truss ever fared worse. This will not lead to a repeat of John Major’s 1992 turnaround: politics professor Rob Ford points to Major’s 100th day neck-and-neck with Labour polling, while Sunak is 25% behind.

True, Sunak was dealt a bad hand, but look how badly he plays it. It’s no use proclaiming integrity, then appointing a seedy cabinet of shifty rogues, bullies, tax dodgers and retreads instead of fresh new faces. “Sir” Gavin Williamson? Nadhim Zahawi? Suella Braverman? Grant Shapps? Really? He is held captive by the caucuses and cabals he must balance, and backers he must reward, stymied by contradictory imperatives of his fissiparous backbenches while he dithers over sackings, blown by the winds for lack of direction.

He stands firm only on his greatest blunder, with no exit plan. Obstinately refusing to negotiate, he makes unions the reasonable ones, ready to talk turkey so long as some raise is on the table. This is not economics, not holding down inflation as he claims, but pure politics, which is not his forte. If he thinks he can drive strikers into submission through abject penury, it won’t happen – and if it did, the shame would be on him, and the sympathy with them. Mini-me Thatcher imitation is no route to success 40 years on.

That’s because economic truth is on the unions’ side: Paul Johnson, the director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, says firmly to me that a public sector pay rise “is not in itself inflationary”: there are no prices to rise, unlike in the private sector. What’s more, he says, the sums involved to pay public workers are small from a total pay bill of £240bn. Each extra 1% costs £2.5bn.

He gives a good example of relative costs: if the “temporary” cut in fuel duty is restored, that raises £6bn, “enough to pay NHS staff and teachers a raise around the inflation rate”. If Sunak prefers a £6bn bribe for the fuel lobby, that’s his political choice. That will underline his image as an obtusely wrongheaded, anti-public sector austerian, while nurses and teachers flock away from their professions: where are his extra maths teaching coming from?

Most perplexing is Sunak’s inertia on the NHS perma-crisis. It was unthinkable for previous governments to expect to survive 1,000 people a week dying needlessly (not counting Covid deaths), with up to half of those attributed to A&E delays, according to analysis by LCP Actuaries. Just one case used to cause an uproar: Mavis Skeet’s needless cancer death in 2000 propelled Labour into supercharged NHS investment.

If Sunak relies on Stalin’s maxim that “one death is a tragedy, a million is a statistic”, Rob Ford tells me this will be radiation poisoning of the Tories’ reputation, “a sickness lasting years to come, a folk memory of the time the ambulance never came for Grandad.”

Sunak refuses to say the word “crisis”, when he should have called a national emergency long ago. This would mean organising Cobra meetings every day, giving staff immediate pay rises, getting funds poured into social care, summoning volunteers on deck. Never mind that by doing that he admits to 13 years of cuts – he could have seized the initiative. But that’s what he lacks, in a nothingness that goes far deeper than eager-to-please smiles.

The idea of a vital “first 100 days” came from 1933 and Franklin D Roosevelt’s first 77 laws and project investments to kickstart a dead economy. Sunak can boast only a malevolent anti-strike law, U-turns on windfarms (good) and housing targets (bad).

Looking ahead, he has no vista beyond five bog-standard governances - to calm inflation and attempt to patrol borders and cut NHS waiting times. This week’s Institute for Government report on the civil service is dire. Can he fix the Northern Ireland protocol without a DUP or backbench rebellion?

Only three seats in Britain now have a majority in favour of Brexit, according to a new poll. “Give us something to fight for,” the former Brexit minister David Frost demands, but they’ll be fighting one another as Boris Johnson and Truss gird their loins for God knows what. Sleaze, cronyism and corruption inquiries are in progress, but nothing else progresses, while the US and EU outdo each other in massive green investments, excluding us. Welcome to the dog days, and yet more lost growth to come.

  • Polly Toynbee is a Guardian columnist


Polly Toynbee

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Thatcherites hounding Sunak over strikes forget one thing: she picked her battles | Katy Balls
MPs want the prime minister to win the health and rail disputes. But his options are limited, says Katy Balls, political editor of the Spectator

Katy Balls

09, Jan, 2023 @12:00 PM

Article image
Rishi Sunak is stuck peddling fake solutions – he can’t admit his own party is the problem | Rafael Behr
Anti-strike laws and yet another immigration crackdown are diversions from the task of unpicking 13 years of Tory misrule, says Guardian columnist Rafael Behr

Rafael Behr

11, Jan, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Rishi Sunak’s NHS plans: ramping up private medicine | Editorial
Editorial: The Tories have not reversed pro-market reforms in healthcare but energised them


06, Feb, 2023 @6:50 PM

Article image
A healthy workforce means a healthy economy. Britain can’t afford to be so ill | Devi Sridhar
For all Liz Truss’s talk about growth, there is little attempt to deal with the rising numbers of people with long-term sickness, says Prof Devi Sridhar

Devi Sridhar

18, Oct, 2022 @1:30 PM

Article image
Nurses’ strike is ‘badge of shame’ for ministers, Starmer tells Sunak
Labour leader accuses PM of putting political considerations above patient safety by refusing to discuss pay rises

Peter Walker Political correspondent

14, Dec, 2022 @1:04 PM

Article image
Rishi Sunak signals he is open to discussing this year’s pay with nurses
Prime minister declines to rule out reopening deal after ministers’ previous refusals to do so

Pippa Crerar Political editor

08, Jan, 2023 @10:55 AM

Article image
More NHS staff to strike as Rishi Sunak confirms use of private healthcare – as it happened
Latest updates: physiotherapists the latest group to announce industrial action as PM says he is now registered with an NHS GP

Andrew Sparrow

11, Jan, 2023 @6:05 PM

Article image
The stench coming from this government? It’s the corrupt mixture of private wealth and public squalor | Jonathan Freedland
Johnson, Sunak, Sharp and Zahawi operate in a gilded realm, while the services that keep Britain running are hobbled and broken, says the Guardian columnist Jonathan Freedland

Jonathan Freedland

27, Jan, 2023 @5:29 PM

Article image
The NHS crisis is an existential risk for the government | Robert Ford
The searing memories of this winter crisis will endure and any action ministers take now will come too late to improve their standing at the next election

Robert Ford

22, Jan, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
Rishi Sunak’s proposed anti-strike laws aren’t just insulting – they’re stupid, too | Angela Rayner
The Tories have gone from clapping nurses to threatening to sack them. How will that help fix our broken public services, asks the Labour deputy leader, Angela Rayner

Angela Rayner

16, Jan, 2023 @10:00 AM