The Guardian view on strikes: Sunak needs a better plan | Editorial

The prime minister lacks the authority and popularity for a long confrontation with public sector workers

To the extent that Rishi Sunak has a plan for dealing with the biggest wave of industrial action in Britain for a generation, it seems to involve waiting for public opinion to turn against the strikes. To hasten that process, ministers cast trade unions as self-serving militants, causing harm to citizens who rely on the services that are being disrupted. The plan isn’t working.

About 500,000 workers took part in industrial action on Wednesday. That was inconvenient for millions of others, but for the time being it is the government that takes the greater portion of blame. Deservedly so, when ministers have responded to legitimate grievances with high-handed disdain.

The teachers’ strike on Wednesday was especially difficult for parents who had to make childcare arrangements or miss work. For many, it stirred stressful memories of home schooling during the pandemic.

That doesn’t mean teachers were wrong to leave the classroom in protest at inadequate pay, nor that parents all blamed them for a decision that most could see was taken as a last resort. As with striking nurses and ambulance drivers, there is a bedrock of public recognition that people who provide essential services do so from vocation, not to get rich. They expect remuneration and working conditions that are adequate, and that allow them to do the job safely.

The degradation of those services over years of budget cuts is evident to those who rely on them. Parents do not want their children to be taught in underfunded schools or to be treated by demoralised nurses in overcrowded wards.

Everyone is feeling the same long-term squeeze on their incomes. Well, almost everyone. A small minority enjoys sufficient wealth to be insulated from pressures that weigh on ordinary people. That lucky social segment happens to be disproportionately represented in Mr Sunak’s cabinet. This might explain some of the political miscalculation around industrial unrest, although a lack of strategic competence also plays its part.

Mr Sunak has an argument against strikes, which he seems to think is the same as a negotiating position. The government view is that pay rises above inflation are unaffordable and that they would stoke inflation further. That is a highly partisan and tendentious account of the underlying economics. Teachers’ pay has been falling in real terms for years, leading up to the present spike in inflation, so their salaries can hardly be the cause. Nurses are not to blame for Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine and the subsequent pinch on energy supplies, nor did they negotiate the Brexit deal that raised import costs, tightened the labour market and snarled up supply chains – the actual drivers of inflation.

In reality, the government is making a political choice not to pay public sector workers enough money, because the prime minister’s fiscal priority is an election war chest of tax cuts for later in the parliament. As a campaigning tactic, that might work, but it relies on voters putting up with prolonged chaos, and on public sector workers losing the will to fight for decent pay. That is not only a political gamble, but also an abdication of responsible government. Mr Sunak is not popular enough, nor does he have the moral authority to stake so much on a confrontation with people whose public service credentials are much better than his own. He needs a new plan.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on NHS strikes: a last resort and a cry of despair | Editorial
Editorial: Conservatives cannot deflect blame for a crisis that has been building for the 12 years they have been in government


30, Nov, 2022 @6:44 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Sunak’s strikes: to be more inflexible than Thatcher is a flaw | Editorial
Editorial: The prime minister should be like his political idol and award inflation-proof pay rises to end industrial strife by key workers


12, Dec, 2022 @7:02 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Sunak and the strikes: misreading the mood of the nation | Editorial
Editorial: The prime minister is seeking confrontation with the unions in the belief he will reap a political reward


07, Dec, 2022 @7:04 PM

Article image
Sunak tries to remain above fray as public sector strikes continue
PM likely to find it increasingly difficult to stay out of debate as industrial action escalates

Heather Stewart

31, Jan, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on public sector pay: Labour needs an answer | Editorial
Editorial: The opposition should be clearer about its own solutions to disputes that the government is shamefully trying to prolong


29, Jul, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Striking is the last thing teachers want to do. But the government has left us no choice | Patrick Roach
A real-terms pay cut will force many to leave the profession, with pupils being the real losers, says Patrick Roach, general secretary of the NASUWT

Patrick Roach

25, Nov, 2022 @4:15 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on strikes in Britain: it’s not a return to the 1970s | Editorial
Editorial: Without decent pay offers Britain risks remaining in trapped a low-wage, low-growth spiral


20, Jun, 2022 @5:49 PM

Article image
Sunak is the ‘too little, too late’ PM. That’s why he’s failing over the NHS and the latest strikes | Gaby Hinsliff
The PM should pay nurses and other striking workers properly. But there’s a pattern emerging: he’s always behind the curve, says Guardian columnist Gaby Hinsliff

Gaby Hinsliff

22, Dec, 2022 @4:55 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the NHS in peril: the risks are multiplying | Editorial
Editorial: Rising pressures on staff could further weaken a depleted workforce. The government’s obduracy over pay is irresponsible


29, Dec, 2022 @6:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on anti-strike laws: bad in practice, wrong in principle | Editorial
Editorial: Attacking fundamental labour rights is a sign of weakness in a prime minister without a strategy


11, Jan, 2023 @6:30 PM