The Guardian view on Liz Truss’s cabinet: diverse but dogmatic | Editorial

The prime minister has assembled a team based on personal loyalty and narrow ideology. She will soon need to broaden her horizons

Liz Truss first joined the cabinet when David Cameron was prime minister, and has now doggedly pursued her ambitions all the way to the top. It is a feat of tenacity that proves she can outmanoeuvre her peers and win arguments among Tories. Running the country will demand a more varied skill set.

Given the scale of the challenges ahead, the new prime minister would benefit from a cabinet staffed with experienced ministers and proven administrators. Ms Truss appears instead to have recruited on the basis of loyalty and narrow ideology.

It makes sense to give the role of chancellor to a longstanding ally, and Kwasi Kwarteng, an old friend of Ms Truss, has the economic credentials. But his cabinet experience extends to less than two years at the business department. James Cleverly, the new foreign secretary, has only been in cabinet since July. Suella Braverman, the home secretary, has never run a government department.

A positive noteworthy feature of those appointments is the expression they give to diversity on the Tory benches. For the first time in history, none of the great offices of state are occupied by a white man. There is reason to doubt that Ms Truss’s government can serve British society equally, but it would be churlish not to credit advances in representing women and people of colour.

The Tories have now provided Britain with three female prime ministers. Labour has managed none – a record it needs to examine with humility.

Ms Truss’s manner also represents a welcome break from her predecessor’s. She lacks Boris Johnson’s theatrical swagger, but that is no loss. Her first appearance as prime minister at the dispatch box on Wednesday was marked by a serious exchange of opinions on policy. The Tory leader listened to Sir Keir Starmer’s questions on how to fund consumer energy bill subsidies. She responded with more sincere engagement than Mr Johnson ever managed. He set that bar low, but it is still encouraging that Ms Truss clears it.

Less reassuring is the content of her answers, which expressed dogmatic conviction that corporate profits are sacrosanct and that the only legitimate thing to do with taxes is to cut them. In that respect, Ms Truss brings the opposite of intellectual renewal to government. She is pragmatic enough to see that the state must intervene during a cost of living crisis, but her attachment to hand-me-down Thatcherite analysis makes her oblivious to the complex character of the present emergency.

The clearest evidence of that obtuseness is her appointment to the business department of Jacob Rees-Mogg – a man with no discernible record of achievement in government. His reputation is built on media indulgence of cartoonish aristocratic affectations, and his self-appointed status as a grand inquisitor of Eurosceptic purity. That he is now the secretary of state responsible for the energy sector, workers’ rights and climate policy is dispiriting.

The sheer magnitude of the economic challenge requires a government with intellectual agility and managerial skill to avoid turning a crisis into a calamity. Ms Truss has at least demonstrated a different style to her predecessor. That much is welcome, but not enough. She will also have to prove that she is capable of seeing the world through a lens wider than the one she applied when her only focus was rising through the Tory ranks.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Why Liz Truss’s cabinet of loyalists may not bode well for the future
The new PM has rewarded her closest allies with top posts in her government alienating supporters of her main rival

Peter Walker Political correspondent

06, Sep, 2022 @8:39 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Rishi Sunak’s cabinet: rewards for failure | Editorial
Editorial: A long back catalogue of scandal and incompetence in government makes it impossible for the Tories to turn over a new leaf


16, Nov, 2022 @6:35 PM

Article image
Wednesday briefing: Liz Truss has appointed the most diverse cabinet ever. What does that mean?
In today’s newsletter: None of the four most senior jobs in the British government will be held by a white man. How did the Tories get here – and why is it so difficult for Labour?

Archie Bland

07, Sep, 2022 @5:54 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Tory conference: a carnival of shame | Editorial
Editorial: The Conservative party will regret inflicting a prime minister on Britain who has packed so much failure into such a short time


02, Oct, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Conservative party: better off out | Editorial
Editorial: Liz Truss’s project is finished and her MPs know it. The party needs new ideas and time to rebuild in opposition


14, Oct, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Truss, Kwarteng and inequality: out of touch, out of time | Editorial
Editorial: Michael Gove is doing the country a service by resisting a government with no mandate


04, Oct, 2022 @6:12 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the UK’s financial crisis: a lot of blame to go around | Editorial
Editorial: Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng deserve all the criticism coming their way – but spare some flak for the Bank of England


12, Oct, 2022 @5:58 PM

Article image
Liz Truss culls cabinet on first day as loyalists and allies get top jobs
New PM also pledges to urgently tackle energy crisis with plans to freeze bills at about £2,500 a year expected within days

Pippa Crerar Political editor

06, Sep, 2022 @8:39 PM

Article image
Is Sunak’s cabinet representative of the nation it governs?
New PM said he would ‘unite our country’ but do his ministerial appointments reflect population?

Pamela Duncan and Carmen Aguilar García

26, Oct, 2022 @5:16 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on a Tory U-turn: the problem goes beyond tax | Editorial
Editorial: How people feel when facing an economic crisis often decides their choice in elections. That spells doom for Liz Truss


03, Oct, 2022 @6:00 PM