The Guardian view on Qatar’s World Cup: gestures are not enough | Editorial

World football’s governing body should heed calls to compensate abused migrant workers

There are now less than 50 days to the World Cup in Qatar, which promoters have taken to describing as a tournament “like no other”. For once the PR hype is justified, and not only because the matches will be played during the lead-up to Christmas rather than in summer. The decision to stage the planet’s biggest sporting event in a country with a notoriously poor human rights record is provoking unprecedented queasiness among competing nations.

Last week, in conjunction with the kit manufacturer Hummel, the Danish football federation unveiled a plain all-black third kit for the tournament. It was designed, said Hummel, in memory of the many migrant workers who died during construction work in the years leading up to the finals. The captains of some European teams – including England’s Harry Kane – aim to wear rainbow “One Love” armbands, symbolising opposition to discrimination in a country where homosexual acts are illegal. The German federation invited a gay fan to use its platform at an event to address the Qatari ambassador on the subject of LGBT rights. Abdulla bin Mohammed bin Saud Al Thani reportedly responded that human rights issues were distracting from the tournament.

To the extent that this is true, it is of course a good thing. High-profile gestures by companies such as Hummel are far better than nothing at all. But time is running out for the kind of action that could leave a lasting positive legacy from a World Cup that should never have been awarded to these hosts. Football is a global game and a tournament in the Middle East is desirable in principle, but this is not the way.

With justification, Qatari authorities claim they have responded to pressure to reform brutally exploitative conditions for migrant workers. The hated kafala system, for example – which tied a worker to a single employer – has gone, and attempts have been made to compensate for unpaid wages and introduce minimum pay. But the latest in a series of Guardian investigations, published last month, found that, despite high-level initiatives and reassurances, abusive practices were still rife on the ground. Migrant workers at the Al Bayt stadium, where England will play the USA on 25 November, had been obliged to pay huge illegal recruitment fees and lived for months in unfit, overcrowded accommodation, earning £1 an hour. Elsewhere, labourers spoke of 12-hour shifts, six days a week, without proper overtime pay. A climate of fear inhibited many from speaking out about conditions. Migrant workers who have returned home ahead of the World Cup say they were sent back before finishing their contracts or without receiving all they claim they were owed.

A recent YouGov poll, commissioned by Amnesty International, found huge support for a compensation fund for migrant workers who have been mistreated, and for the relatives of those who died. Amnesty, along with other human rights groups, are campaigning for Fifa, world football’s governing body, to set up such a fund using a fraction of anticipated profits of $7bn. The amount proposed is $440m – equivalent to World Cup prize money on offer. After prolonged hesitation, the English FA has now backed the principle of a fund, as have high-profile figures in football such as the Dutch national team manager, Louis van Gaal, and the Brazil coach, Tite. Fifa has said it is thinking about it. It’s time to stop thinking and act.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on Qatar’s migrant workers: football owes them
Editorial: The FA and the England team should back proposals to safeguard migrant workers’ rights after the World Cup in November


19, Jun, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Qatar’s World Cup: labour rights and wrongs | Editorial
Editorial: Workers are dying, but those in charge of building stadiums in the Gulf state do not seem unduly bothered. A coroner’s inquest highlights the need for change


27, Feb, 2018 @6:32 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Qatar World Cup: great tournament, wrong place | Editorial
Editorial: Much of the football and the spectacle has been wonderful. But much more than sport was at stake


16, Dec, 2022 @6:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Qatar’s World Cup: sportwashing stains football’s image | Editorial
Editorial: The tournament may highlight the Gulf state’s money and power – but it has also further exposed its human rights abuses


13, Nov, 2022 @6:25 PM

Article image
Could the Qatar World Cup be a turning point for ethics in sport? | Letters
Letters: Dr Mike Diboll on our complicity in human rights abuses, Karl Eklund on apartheid South Africa, Antony Barlow on the UK’s own failings, and Stan Labovitch on why he won’t boycott watching the World Cup

25, Nov, 2022 @5:45 PM

Article image
What do Qatar’s World Cup workers now fear most? Being sent home | Pete Pattisson
Migrant workers in labour camps face poor pay and conditions but their fear of losing those jobs underlines their exploitation

Pete Pattisson in Doha

23, Sep, 2022 @10:58 AM

Article image
I hate the very idea of this World Cup in Qatar, but I’ll have to watch: it’s the beautiful game | Mihir Bose
While sport speaks to the best of the human spirit, officials too often degrade it, says author and broadcaster Mihir Bose

Mihir Bose

19, Nov, 2022 @1:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Özil, Arsenal and Liverpool: football with a conscience | Editorial
Editorial: The clubs have taken very different stances on human rights issues this week. Commercial interests do not absolve them of social responsibilities


18, Dec, 2019 @6:25 PM

Article image
Labour: Fifa must insist Qatar improves workers' rights ahead of World Cup

Labour MP Jim Murphy emphasises welfare demands for migrant workers prior to key European parliament hearing

Owen Gibson, chief sports correspondent

12, Feb, 2014 @7:08 PM

Article image
Migrant workers in Qatar left in debt after being ordered home before World Cup starts
Early end to migrants’ contracts leaves many owing large sums to recruiters and unable to support their families

Pete Pattisson in Doha

22, Sep, 2022 @8:00 AM