Zero-Covid protests are spreading across China – but a violent crackdown will follow | James McMurray

From Xinjiang to Shanghai and Beijing, protests are creating a rare sense of unity that Xi Jinping cannot afford to allow

China’s heavy-handed zero-Covid policy was intended to save lives. Now, it’s having devastating consequences. Last week, a fire killed at least 10 people, including children, in a tower block in Urumqi, the capital of Xinjiang. As ever in China, official numbers are unreliable, and the true number of casualties may be much higher. It’s clear that the citizens now protesting across China blame the tragedy on the lockdown, despite the claims of local officials that fire escapes in the building were not locked. Horrific videos of the fire show emergency services attempting in vain to douse the flames from beyond a roadblock, while victims scream from the windows pleading for somebody to open the doors of their apartments.

For once, the suffering of Xinjiang’s people seems to have evoked widespread empathy among China’s wider populace. When Uyghur demonstrations in Urumqi were crushed by police and security services in 2009, it evoked little sympathy from China’s ethnic Han majority. Instead, the demonstrations precipitated a wave of ethnic violence, accompanied by calls across the Chinese internet for severe punishment for the demonstrators. Similarly, the intense crackdown on Uyghur society that has been going on since 2017 – involving mass incarcerations, forced sterilisations and the destruction of communities – was largely dismissed by the rest of the Chinese populace as a necessary measure to control a defiant and restive minority.

Now, however, zealous agents of the state have rigorously enforced lockdowns across the country that have lasted months at a time. Often, as shown in innumerable videos shared online over the past three years, they have done so by chaining or barring the doors, fire escapes and gates of apartment buildings. Reports of difficulty getting medical supplies and food to families locked in their homes have been common.

Despite the extent of the restrictions across China, it was perhaps inevitable that when this tragedy came about, it would be in a Uyghur neighbourhood in Xinjiang. Lockdowns there have been particularly severe, and seem to have been targeted at minority communities. They have been widely regarded as an extension of the security lockdowns that were already a familiar feature of the region, and locals have reported that the two would sometimes blur together: people told they were being taken to centralised quarantine facilities after being alerted to a close contact with a Covid carrier have said they were instead delivered to re-education camps. The quarantine facilities themselves are no better than the camps; at the former, inmates have told of being regularly hosed down with disinfectant, and forced to swallow unknown medications.

The protests are a particularly difficult problem for the Chinese state. To see protests in Urumqi at all is shocking, given the intense security control of the region and the severe consequences of previous demonstrations. But, more than this, it is remarkable that the protests in Xinjiang comprise largely Han demonstrators. While the state has long seen minorities in Xinjiang as a problem, the region’s Han population – most of whom were moved in from inner China during the 20th century – has historically been regarded as part of the solution, tying the region more closely to the rest of the country and diluting the local Uyghur majority. This has given them comparative licence to complain, and now to protest, while many Uyghurs are understandably too terrified to leave their homes.

But the special treatment of the Han in Xinjiang is unlikely to protect them for long. The demonstrations in Urumqi are a part of a bigger movement that is troubling the streets of major cities including Shanghai and Wuhan. The state will not tolerate such dissent. Some regional protests have occasionally been successful at overturning local policies or drawing attention to corrupt officials, but zero Covid is Xi Jinping’s flagship policy in his effort to eradicate the virus from China. Any climbdown will pose a threat to his authority. The inevitable increase in cases that would follow from abandoning the policy would also undermine the state’s image as the efficient, guiding hand of the Chinese people.

There is no predicting how this will end, but the likelihood of a violent state response is high. Such a response, however, runs the risk of provoking further calls for democracy and equality that have begun to pepper the anti-lockdown protests. Just as people across China have experienced their own lockdowns and can sympathise with the Uyghur families who burned to death in their homes, they may come to further sympathise with the desire to be free of the Communist party’s iron grip.

  • Dr James McMurray is a research associate in anthropology and a member of the Asia Centre at the University of Sussex

Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.


James McMurray

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Zero Covid can't continue in China. Reopening is the only way to quell public anger | Yu Jie
Local officials have doubled down on the severe restrictions that has already caused so much economic damage, says Yu Jie of Chatham House

Yu Jie

30, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Covid restrictions lifted in Guangzhou and Chongqing after China protests
Announcements ordered the removal of ‘control orders’ and to designate areas as low risk

Helen Davidson and agencies

30, Nov, 2022 @9:12 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on China’s protests: zero Covid, maximum frustration | Editorial
Editorial: Harsh coronavirus controls have prompted an extraordinary outpouring of discontent across the country


28, Nov, 2022 @7:03 PM

Article image
Anti-lockdown protests spread in China as anger rises over zero-Covid strategy
Beijing students shout ‘freedom will prevail’, as Urumqi fire prompts levels of disobedience unprecedented in Xi era

Helen Davidson in Taipei and Verna Yu

27, Nov, 2022 @11:20 PM

Article image
China covid protests: authorities call for crackdown on ‘hostile forces’
Streets flooded with police as top security body blames ‘infiltration and sabotage’ for unrest

Emma Graham-Harrison and Helen Davidson in Taipei

29, Nov, 2022 @6:58 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on China’s Covid crisis: zero preparation | Editorial
Editorial: The country’s reckless reopening without adequate planning is claiming lives. It did not have to be this way


03, Jan, 2023 @6:25 PM

Article image
As the west is in lockdown, China is slowly getting back to business | Daniel Falush
Life is returning to normal here – other countries face a much longer wait, says Shanghai-based academic Daniel Falush

Daniel Falush

30, Mar, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Rumours of zero-Covid easing spread in China amid anger at restrictions
Despite relatively low case numbers, there are reportedly about 200 lockdowns across the country

Helen Davidson

04, Nov, 2022 @3:08 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on China’s zero-Covid strategy: no way out? | Editorial
Editorial: The human costs of lockdown in Shanghai have sparked frustration and despair. But leaders have no exit strategy


20, Apr, 2022 @5:39 PM

Article image
Parliament says China is committing a genocide. Why were officials planning to meet one of the perpetrators? | James McMurray
Erkin Tuniyaz’s visit is no longer going ahead, but Britain should never have engaged with this whitewashing of the treatment of Uyghurs and other minorities, says James McMurray of the University of Sussex

James McMurray

15, Feb, 2023 @5:17 PM