The Guardian view on tax rises: a necessary change | Editorial

No one likes having to pay more, but hard times and Jeremy Hunt’s autumn statement have put the issue at the centre of politics

Elections hinge on the people in the middle. The same goes for Jeremy Hunt’s autumn economic statement this week. In the space between the statement’s modest increases in personal taxes on the richest on the one hand, and its increased support for the poorest on the other, Thursday’s package was marked by a major revenue-raising squeeze on the living standards of the many millions in the middle. This represents one of the biggest political gambles by any government in modern times, the more so because this is the same government that helped create the very problem it is now struggling to solve.

This large group of taxpayers and voters has gone by many aliases down the years – among them Middle Britain, the squeezed middle and the just-about-managing. Not everyone who falls into any of these categories thinks of themselves in the same ways, and there are certainly many large contrasts of wealth and living standards among them. In personal finance terms, they stretch all the way from anyone who will now miss out on the more targeted cost of living support for their heating costs from April, through to those whose incomes will be dragged into higher tax bands in the coming years as a result of the freezes on allowances.

These freezes add up to a very large tax rise across the whole swathe of middle incomes, and at a very hard time. They will raise, according to the Office for Budget Responsibility, a total of £35bn by 2027-28. They come as the OBR forecasts that living standards will fall by 4.3% in the current financial year, the largest fall since the 1950s, and again by a further 2.8% in the following year. They come, too, at a time when the prices of food and fuel have risen sharply and when year-on-year inflation has reached 11.1%, the highest figure for more than 40 years, ensuring that the public will have less money in real terms to pay for the same goods.

Politically, this is an extremely unusual move. Partly that is because these are such desperate times – especially for the poorest – and desperate remedies are in order. Yet it is also because reasoned public conversation in Britain about raising tax to deal with need, even in less extreme circumstances, has withered on the vine.

For at least 40 years, UK governments of all stripes have been afraid of taxing the middle class more. Labour is almost as wary as the Tories. As a result, not just taxes on income, but taxes on wealth or land have become almost taboo. Now, however, Kwasi Kwarteng’s car crash of tax cuts has put such issues back on the agenda for all political parties.

There is little mystery about why Mr Hunt intends to cut Middle Britain’s living standards in spite of the inevitable unpopularity of his action. There are currently more than 30 million income-tax payers, of whom more than 6 million now pay the higher rate. Middle Britain’s taxes therefore raise a lot of money for the Treasury and do so efficiently. Mr Hunt’s dilemma is that all of these taxpayers also have votes.

The chancellor has in fact got a bit closer than some of his predecessors to coming clean with Middle Britain. But he has ultimately shied away from making a sustained public case for necessary taxation. On Thursday, he talked about compassion and fairness, and then balked at explaining how the tax system is an essential part of delivering them. Admittedly, that’s an uphill task in a party that has been in thrall for so long – and still is – to the doctrine of tax cuts and small government. But it is a conversation that has been thrust on the Conservative party by a combination of Brexit, Covid, energy prices and Liz Truss. It is a conversation that the country has needed for decades.

  • Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Jeremy Hunt says he has not ‘ducked difficult decisions’ as OBR says living standards growth wiped out – as it happened
Chancellor denies postponing financial pain as fiscal watchdog’s figures show eight years of income growth wiped out

Harry Taylor (now); Andrew Sparrow and Graeme Wearden (earlier)

17, Nov, 2022 @8:45 PM

Article image
Hunt unveils tax rises and spending cuts as OBR says eight years of growth to be wiped out
Labour describes autumn statement measures as ‘invoice for the economic carnage’ of disastrous mini-budget under Liz Truss

Peter Walker Political correspondent

17, Nov, 2022 @1:06 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Tory shock therapy: the wrong medicine for the country | Edirorial
Editorial: Liz Truss’s policies have put the Tories behind Labour by 30 points. Without reversing course she will be in office but not in power


30, Sep, 2022 @5:04 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on election economics: there is an alternative | Editorial
Editorial: Economics dominates public debate while being seen as an abstract authority over which people have little control. That must change


22, Nov, 2019 @5:56 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Tory supply-siders: unhelpful in a cost of living crisis | Editorial
Editorial: Imaginative public spending is unlikely to feature in the Conservative leadership race, where tax cuts will be a key dividing line


10, Jul, 2022 @4:48 PM

Article image
George Osborne likely to miss deficit reduction target as UK borrowing rises
Increase fuelled by weak tax receipts means chancellor may have to unveil further cuts or raise taxes to meet targets in time for 2015 election

Angela Monaghan

23, Sep, 2014 @11:26 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on budget 2017: a missed opportunity | Editorial
Editorial: Philip Hammond has admitted that seven years of obsessing about the public sector deficit and shrinking the state has left the economy enfeebled and smaller than before the crisis. But he continues to put ideology above evidence


22, Nov, 2017 @7:47 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Jeremy Hunt’s autumn statement: setting a trap for Labour | Editorial
Editorial: The government wants voters to think the economic question is about reducing debt rather than Tory failure


17, Nov, 2022 @6:53 PM

Article image
Osborne: I will continue to take 'difficult decisions' after tax credits U-turn
Chancellor makes clear he is not abandoning his overall approach to eliminate structural budget deficit two years before 2020 election

Nicholas Watt, Patrick Wintour and Larry Elliott

26, Nov, 2015 @9:34 AM

Article image
George Osborne on offensive over tax abuse but admits deficit target missed
Chancellor highlights plans to clamp down on tax loopholes used by tech firms and will vow to rein in debt faster than Labour

Patrick Wintour and Larry Elliott

02, Dec, 2014 @10:30 PM