The Guardian view on LGBT+ Anglicans: finally grounds for hope? | Editorial

A significant intervention by the bishop of Oxford points the way to overdue reform in the Church of England

For more than a decade, the Church of England has engaged in an agonised, divisive and often poisonous debate about the status of same-sex relationships. As attitudes in the wider national culture have transformed beyond recognition since the 1980s, the country’s established church has gradually become an anomalous outlier, steadfastly refusing to countenance same-sex marriages or the blessing of civil unions. Its doctrine continues to conform to the view that homosexual practice is “incompatible with scripture”.

Responding to the hurt and grief that this has caused LGBT+ members of its congregations – apparently equal in the eyes of God but second-class citizens in their own church – the C of E has, at best, wrung its hands sympathetically. To the deep disquiet of many bishops and much of the laity, the goal of maintaining unity, both at home and in the worldwide Anglican communion, seems to have led to the perpetuation of a derided status quo.

Thankfully, a remarkable and high-profile intervention last week by the bishop of Oxford, the Right Rev Steven Croft – the first of its kind by a serving diocesan bishop – suggests that this paralysed state of affairs may not hold much longer. Ahead of a crucial December meeting of the College of Bishops, which is due to discuss reform, Mr Croft has published a groundbreaking 50-page essay in which he disowns his previous opposition to change. While arguing for a freedom of conscience clause for dissenters, the document calls for full recognition of same-sex marriage for gay and lesbian clergy, and for all LGBT+ people who wish to marry in their local Anglican church. Two other bishops have immediately and publicly voiced their support.

The refusal of equal status to same-sex relationships, writes Mr Croft, has created an unsustainable “dislocation” between England’s established church and the society it has a vocation and duty to serve. Church thinking and doctrine, he points out, are not immutable; it has evolved many times in the past – for example, in relation to slavery, apartheid, divorce and, more recently, the ordination of women.

Strikingly, the document also challenges the opportunistic weaponisation of isolated passages from the Old Testament in the traditionalist cause. Mr Croft cites an episode of The West Wing, in which President Bartlet skewers a Leviticus-quoting Christian fundamentalist by asking him for advice on how to sell his daughter into slavery – as sanctioned in Exodus 21:7. An account of Christian truth that is more faithful to the gospels, the bishop writes, understands that “the foundational trajectory of Scripture is of recognising … dignity, worth and equality”, and seeks to extend these values further in a spirit of radical inclusion. Preserving church “unity” is not a good enough reason for avoiding this task.

This is a significant and systematic intervention from a senior member of the church. As such, it is both overdue and profoundly welcome. At the fraught Lambeth conference in the summer, Archbishop Justin Welby rightly acknowledged the extent of division in the worldwide Anglican communion over same-sex relationships. But it is past time for the C of E to recognise that its current state of fearful intransigence is untenable. A meeting of the General Synod early next year is due to establish a new direction of travel for the C of E. The bishop of Oxford’s essay should be used as a map to help guide it.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on Anglicans and gay clergy: stop listening, start leading | Editorial
Editorial: A whole generation of gay and lesbian Christians have been denied their place in the rituals of their faith


12, Feb, 2017 @8:06 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Lambeth conference: don’t make it about sexuality | Editorial
Editorial: A toxic draft text on same-sex unions has needlessly reopened old wounds


25, Jul, 2022 @5:29 PM

Article image
Senior Anglicans call for repentance over sexual discrimination
Signatories of open letter to archbishops say LGBTI members of Church of England have been ‘ignored and vilified for too long’

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

10, Jan, 2016 @11:56 AM

Article image
The Church of England is homophobic, despite Justin Welby's trendy-vicar act | Deborah Orr

Deborah Orr: The archbishop of Canterbury says he opposes both gay marriage and homophobia – but that just doesn't add up

Deborah Orr

17, May, 2014 @5:59 AM

Article image
UK property prices have made us millionaires – but damaged democracy | Deborah Orr

Deborah Orr:One in 10 of UK adults now live in a household worth at least £1m, thanks mostly to soaring house values. The main political parties can't help but cater to property owners, so who will represent the rest?

Deborah Orr

16, May, 2014 @5:17 PM

Article image
The archbishop of Canterbury must follow up on praise for gay relationships | Savitri Hensman
Savitri Hensman: Justin Welby has made the most positive comments about gay people yet, but he must go much further

Savitri Hensman

15, Mar, 2013 @10:01 AM

Article image
Anglicans support same-sex marriage | Letters
Letters: In the Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act 2013, the Tories imposed a ‘quadruple lock’ on the Church of England, banning it from offering same-sex marriage without fresh primary legislation, writes Priscilla Bench-Capon


24, May, 2018 @4:42 PM

Article image
African Christians will be killed if C of E accepts gay marriage, says Justin Welby
Archbishop says he has seen mass grave of Christians killed by neighbours who said they feared being 'made to become gay'

Andrew Brown

04, Apr, 2014 @11:33 AM

Article image
Archbishop of Canterbury: gay marriage bill will undermine family life

Speaking in House of Lords debate, Justin Welby says law will undermine marriage as basis for rearing children

Nicholas Watt, chief political correspondent

03, Jun, 2013 @9:23 PM

Article image
Church of England in turmoil as synod rejects report on same-sex relationships
Clergy vote against report by 100 to 93 in blow to archbishop of Canterbury as he tries to chart course between apparently unreconcilable wings of church

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

15, Feb, 2017 @8:53 PM