Forget a gimmicky windfall tax. Energy companies should be forced to slash bills instead | Simon Jenkins

Who knows where that extra tax revenue would end up? There is a better way to help people struggling with the cost of living

When all politicians agree on something, it is probably a bad idea. A windfall tax on energy companies is currently in populist vogue and is superficially plausible. Thanks partly to reckless sanctions policies against Russia, British energy users have seen their bills rocket by 70% in the past year, with further hikes promised in October when the official price cap on a bill is forecast to rise to £2,600 a year – or even higher. This is the dominant element in pushing UK inflation to 9%. There is no evidence of energy sanctions altering Russian policy or benefiting Ukraine. There is overwhelming evidence they have hurt poorer Britons – and deeply.

Oil and gas companies such as BP, Exxon and Shell have seen their profits soar, Shell’s tripling to £7.3bn. The reason is simply profiting on the back of sanctions. During Covid, many private firms benefited from government loans and grants to stave off collapse. If taxpayers should come to the aid of private companies in hard times, common equity entitles that aid to be recouped if and when times turn good. YouGov even has seven out of 10 Tory voters saying yes to a windfall tax.

Such one-off taxes are political gimmicks. They were previously adopted only in 1981, 1997 and 2011, when chancellors found themselves in budgetary difficulties and a particular sector seemed a soft target, such as banks and utilities. Introducing his 2011 windfall tax on oil companies, the then chancellor, George Osborne, declared simply that “when oil prices are high … it is fair that companies should contribute more”. Labour is now pressing for a rise in the energy sector’s corporation tax from 40% to 50%. It estimates this would raise just under £2bn. Others want a tax on profiteering care-home owners.

These are blunt instruments. Labour’s £2bn would go to the Treasury, where the question would be what to do with it. That money would buy less than 10 miles of Rishi Sunak’s HS2 out of Euston. Adding it to existing benefits would aid both those worst hit by energy bills and those hardly affected. Fusing a windfall tax into relieving the cost of living surge would become a mere blip.

Like the banks during the 2008 crisis, energy companies are oligopolies that cannot expect to escape public regulation, least of all when blessed with a political bonanza. The answer must be to slash the price cap and demand the companies spend their profits directly on cutting bills. The wimps of Ofgem, the industry regulator, must become tigers. They know that these companies – and their executives – are now wealthy. They know investment is not at issue: they are distributing massive profits and buying back shares. Unless the west goes collectively mad, energy supplies, and profits with them, will return to normal.

For now, the priority is simply to bring the price of energy down, and at the government’s command. Yes, all consumers, rich and poor, would benefit; but it would not cost the exchequer a penny, and it would instantly relieve the cost of living at source.

  • Simon Jenkins is a Guardian columnist


Simon Jenkins

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
EU expects to raise €140bn from windfall tax on energy firms
Cap on outsize revenues will bring solidarity from businesses towards struggling customers, says official

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels and Alex Lawson

14, Sep, 2022 @1:44 PM

Article image
Ed Miliband urges PM to close ‘Swiss cheese’ holes in windfall tax on energy firms
Shadow net zero secretary attacks Sunak’s ‘perverse’ policy as Shell and British Gas report large profits

Aubrey Allegretti Chief political correspondent

27, Jul, 2023 @8:44 AM

Article image
By rejecting a windfall tax, Truss has painted herself into a corner | Polly Toynbee
The ‘handout’ of capped bills is not enough to buy off voters outraged at the excess profits of energy companies, says Guardian columnist Polly Toynbee

Polly Toynbee

09, Sep, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Average UK energy bills could hit £3,000 a year, consumers warned
Petrol and diesel also set to rise after Russian invasion of Ukraine sends wholesale gas and oil prices soaring

Miles Brignall and Jenn Selby

24, Feb, 2022 @5:07 PM

Article image
Shell profits soar to $9.1bn amid calls for windfall tax
Record quarter piles pressure on government to issue one-off levy to curb rising energy bills

Alex Lawson

05, May, 2022 @6:55 AM

Article image
‘An insult’: huge profits at Shell and Centrica cause outrage amid soaring energy bills
News of billion-pound profits comes after UK households warned average annual bill could hit £3,850 by 2023

Rob Davies

28, Jul, 2022 @5:42 PM

Article image
How the UK can cut carbon emissions and reduce household energy bills
The country’s reliance on gas for heating, electricity generation and heavy industry comes at a heavy cost

Jillian Ambrose Energy correspondent

13, Feb, 2022 @5:32 PM

Article image
We must tax profits now, freeze energy price rises - and if necessary bring suppliers into the public sector | Gordon Brown
Without urgent action, families are seeing nothing more than pain now and pain later. There is a way through, says former prime minister Gordon Brown

Gordon Brown

10, Aug, 2022 @6:07 PM

Article image
UK rules out windfall tax on North Sea oil firms to help fund energy bills
Kwasi Kwarteng pledges to turbo-charge investment in solar and wind power amid new energy security plan

Rob Davies and Mark Sweney

29, Mar, 2022 @4:25 PM

Article image
UK ministers row back from extending windfall tax on energy firms
Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng make clear they do not support idea briefed by Treasury sources on Tuesday

Rowena Mason and Peter Walker

10, Aug, 2022 @5:03 PM