Nadine Dorries’s slip-ups may be funny – but her Channel 4 plans are no joke | Jane Martinson

The culture secretary is getting closer than any of her predecessors to selling off the broadcaster

The slip-ups and car-crash interviews of Nadine Dorries, the secretary of state for culture, such as her reference to “downstreaming” films, provide regular fodder for satirists and social media users alike, but the problem is that these clips are distractions from the real substance of what she is doing – and the privatisation of Channel 4 is no joke.

Privatisation in some form has been mooted about half a dozen times since the channel’s launch in 1982, but no one has managed to get as close as this government, which is pressing ahead with its sale. There are doubts over whether it will have the political backing to pass the legislation required to sell off the broadcaster, but Dorries is defending the plans, not by the brilliance of her argument, but by being less than entirely clear about the facts.

Channel 4, which celebrates its 40th birthday this year, is a strange beast: a state-owned broadcaster funded by private-sector advertising, but with a commitment, or remit, to show the sort of public-service content (the news, the Paralympics, regional voices) that is largely unprofitable and then to reinvest profits into new programming.

On the day the white paper to privatise the channel was published, listeners to Iain Dale’s LBC radio show heard Dorries say that investment in the broadcasting rival Channel 5 increased after it was “privatised … three years ago, five years ago maybe”. Channel 5 has never been publicly owned and therefore could never have been privatised.

When the error was pointed out, Dorries doubled down. She said criticism was “nit-picking” after she “misspoke” the date, suggesting that failing to remember when Channel 5 was sold (2014) was the problem and not the fact she had failed to understand the channel’s ownership model.

Everyone is allowed to make mistakes, but the interview was hardly unusual. She wrote a column for the Mail on Sunday headlined, “Predictably, the Leftie lynch mob refuses to accept what is best for British TV”. In it Dorries trumpets the fact that “Channel 4 decreased the amount it spent on new content by £158m” but downplayed the fact that this decline happened in 2020, an exceptional year for everyone, and that the broadcaster’s spending has been back above 2019 levels ever since.

Dorries opines that Margaret Thatcher wanted to privatise the channel, citing the former prime minister’s 1988 memoir, yet she fails to mention the fact that subsequent meetings dissuaded Thatcher from this view. This was partly economic – with no in-house production, Channel 4 has pump-primed a thriving independent production sector in the UK since the 1980s – but Thatcher was also convinced that the bill was likely to be defeated. Minutes held in the National Archives read: “In both Houses, a proposal to privatise Channel 4 was likely to be vulnerable to defeat.”

Dorries likes to suggest that media luvvies are the ones criticising her plans, yet 96% of the responses to the government’s own consultation paper were against privatisation. Dorries called this “politically motivated organisation” by polling group 38 Degrees, which doesn’t explain why many members of her own party, including Julian Knight, Jeremy Hunt and Damian Green, are against the plans.

So why would the government want to push this privatisation now? It can’t be just because it needs the sale proceeds, because Dorries has promised to reinvest them. Dorries denies that her motivations are political – yet she still derides the Channel 4 “anchor … shouting eff the Tories” at every opportunity.

It’s hard not to believe that Boris Johnson and his team are turning the heat up on Channel 4 in revenge for its political coverage, including replacing him with a melting ice sculpture when he failed to turn up for a climate crisis debate.

The public needs to remember that it can oust the prime minister at the next election, but once Channel 4 is gone, it won’t come back.

  • Jane Martinson is a Guardian columnist


Jane Martinson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A word to the UK's new culture secretary: Nadine Dorries was a toxic disaster. Do better | Jane Martinson
Arts and media were casualties in the ideological war waged by the Johnson government. They deserve a serious champion, says Guardian columnist Jane Martinson

Jane Martinson

08, Sep, 2022 @11:01 AM

Article image
The laughable plan to sell off Channel 4 is over – now it’s time for big ideas | Dorothy Byrne
Now how about some reforms that allow the channel to grow, compete and flourish, writes Dorothy Byrne, former Channel 4 head of news

Dorothy Byrne

05, Jan, 2023 @3:12 PM

Article image
The sell-off of Channel 4 won’t benefit anyone but Boris Johnson | Dorothy Byrne
This is an act of political dogma and score-settling, says former head of C4 news and current affairs Dorothy Byrne

Dorothy Byrne

05, Apr, 2022 @1:43 PM

Article image
We, the public, own Channel 4. And this sell-off isn’t a done deal | Armando Iannucci
Why is the government intent on ruining our world-leading TV industry, asks Royal Television Society vice-president Armando Iannucci

Armando Iannucci

06, Apr, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Channel 4 review contradicts Nadine Dorries’ fake reality show claim
Investigation finds no evidence paid actors appeared on 2010 programme featuring Tory MP who is now culture secretary

Mark Sweney

15, Jul, 2022 @1:31 PM

Article image
Channel 4 privatisation plans face Tory backlash – UK politics as it happened
Latest updates: Tory MPs and former ministers among those criticising government proposal to sell off broadcaster

Nicola Slawson (now) and Kevin Rawlinson (earlier)

05, Apr, 2022 @5:06 PM

Article image
Nadine Dorries admits sharing Netflix account with relatives
Culture secretary says service needs to revise business model, before being told of password-sharing ban

Alex Hern Technology editor

19, May, 2022 @3:02 PM

Article image
Nadine Dorries presses ahead with plan to privatise Channel 4
Ministers hope to raise £1bn from sell-off ending broadcaster’s 40 years in public ownership

Jim Waterson

04, Apr, 2022 @7:20 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Channel 4: don’t sell it | Editorial
Editorial: Even senior Tories think the plan to privatise the broadcaster is madness. It must be stopped


05, Apr, 2022 @6:27 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Channel 4 privatisation: a moment to step back | Editorial
Editorial: The new culture secretary would be wise to abort a move that makes no economic sense and few people want anyway


18, Sep, 2022 @5:25 PM