Let the horror in Ukraine open our eyes to the suffering of war around the world | Nesrine Malik

Too many frame the invasion as an attack on ‘civilisation’, uniquely awful because it happened in Europe. That approach demeans us all

Vladimir Putin’s bloody invasion of Ukraine has sharpened two terrifying realisations. The first is that Putin does not function within the realm of the usual finely balanced checks and balances, sticks and carrots, that the west hoped would contain him and maintain an uneasy truce in Europe. The second is that decades of work since the second world war to learn from the mistakes of the past and fortify against them in the future have failed. Here again, we have not a civil war, but an invasion of a sovereign state in defiance of the rest of the world. Here again, we have images that are only known to us as historical reels, of frenzy and panic as thousands attempt to flee to safety.

But there is a third realisation that appears to shape the perception of too many western journalists justifiably appalled at the defiling of Europe. From the tone of much coverage, this seems uniquely distressing and more alarming to them because the lives of non-Europeans have less value, and their conflicts are contained, far away from us.

I thought it was just clumsy phrasing from a couple of reporters under pressure, but soon it became clear that it was, in fact, a media-wide tic. From Al Jazeera to CBS News, journalists were appalled that this was not happening in “Iraq or Afghanistan” but in a “relatively civilised European city.” One said: “The unthinkable has happened. This is not a developing, third world nation. This is Europe.” Another reflected: “These are prosperous middle-class people … these are not obviously refugees getting away from the Middle East. To put it bluntly, these are not refugees from Syria, these are refugees from Ukraine … They’re Christian, they’re white, they’re very similar.”

Ukraine’s former deputy chief prosecutor, David Sakvarelidze, told the BBC, unchallenged: “It’s very emotional for me because I see European people with blue eyes and blond hair being killed.”

Daniel Hannan, Telegraph columnist, former MEP, Lord Hannan of Kingsclere; put it more bluntly, writing that those suffering in Ukraine “seem so like us. That is what makes it so shocking … War is no longer something visited upon impoverished and remote populations. It can happen to anyone.” It is, he said: “civilisation in retreat.”

This strange account of a history in which wars, conflict and dispossession mostly happened in “third world” and “remote” countries (remote from whom?) is a fiction that has come about as a result of a political and media climate that has stripped the humanity of those seeking refuge so completely it has become a fact, repeated with no self-awareness or shame.

An extremely generous view of these statements is that it is not, in itself, an unusual impulse to care more about, or be affected more, by events happening closer to home than farther afield. Perhaps what these people are really trying to say is something along the lines of “this has not happened in this patch in generations” in order to highlight the abnormality of this particular conflict. There is that.

But there is also much more to it. There is an acceptance that war is natural in other places but an aberration here. That war happens only to the poor and the uncivilised, not the well-off and stable. That the fates of refuge and uprootedness are the lot of others, and therefore less of an event.

These are beliefs that fall apart under the slightest of scrutiny to reveal a worldview warped by what has for too long been a popular, unchallenged discourse on refugees and asylum seekers. These opinions were shaped, concertedly and over time, in order to justify inhumane and often violent policies passed to block people from entering European lands. For these policies to become accepted, their victims had to be portrayed as threatening and undeserving.

The legacy of that is a western world hostile to all those in need, blue-eyed or not. As ever, when we avert our eyes from the humanity of one group of people, we end up building immigration systems that assail the humanity of all. A border of policies as high as the heavens now meets Ukrainians seeking to enter the UK, even as family members.

As the Ukrainian flag was projected on to Downing Street, the Home Office was hoisting up the drawbridge, posting on its website: “Ukrainian nationals in Ukraine (who aren’t immediate family members of British nationals normally living in Ukraine, or where the British national is living in the UK), are currently unable to make visa applications to visit, work, study or join family in the UK.” After a barrage of criticism, the government promised to ease these visa rules, allowing the grandparents, adult children, siblings and adult parents of Ukrainians who are settled in the UK to apply for visas under the scheme. Even those visa applications that are allowed will have to navigate an obstacle course of paperwork in the middle of war.

Exceptionalism means we are doomed to repeat the complacencies of the past, constantly comforting ourselves that it can’t happen here, because it only happens elsewhere to others whose pain is somehow different from ours.

But their wars are no less unthinkable, their uprootedness no less traumatic, their civilisation no less valid, than the thousands now leaving Ukraine. And in designing a world in which we are sanguine about other people’s war, we have ensured that we cannot anticipate when war will happen on our doorstep – and that when it does, we are appalled, but then find our humanitarian response systems hobbled, calcified in cruelty.

  • Nesrine Malik is a Guardian columnist

  • Guardian Newsroom: the Russian invasion of Ukraine
    Join a panel of journalists, including Michael Safi, Luke Harding, Julian Borger, Juliette Garside and Patrick Wintour on a livestreamed event on the Russia-Ukraine crisis on Thursday 3 March, 8pm GMT | 9pm CET | 12pm PST | 3pm EST. Book tickets here.


Nesrine Malik

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Zelenskiy’s election proves Ukraine is a healthy democracy. Putin hates that | Natalie Nougayrède
The president-elect’s meteoric rise will inspire Russian activists, says Guardian columnist Natalie Nougayrède

Natalie Nougayrède

25, Apr, 2019 @4:06 PM

Article image
Britain should stay well out of Russia’s border dispute with Ukraine | Simon Jenkins
Johnson won’t save his skin by threats of war with another ailing populist, and Putin will not be stopped by the west, says Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins

20, Jan, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
In Ukraine, Russia is trying to freeze us into submission or death. It will fail | Andriy Yermak
Ninety years after the Holodomor, Russia has once more chosen the path of terror, says Andriy Yermak, head of the Ukrainian presidential office

Andriy Yermak

01, Dec, 2022 @4:00 PM

Article image
Has the West fallen for Putin’s tricks in Ukraine? | Keir Giles
Russia wants to see Nato rolled back – and Ukraine is far from its only pawn in the game, says Keir Giles of Chatham House

Keir Giles

25, Jan, 2022 @3:47 PM

Article image
Putin’s attack on Ukraine isn’t just about Europe. We must rally the world against this act of war | David Lammy
Global opposition needs to show aspiring despots that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is a mistake on a historic scale, says shadow foreign secretary David Lammy

David Lammy

24, Feb, 2022 @5:37 PM

Article image
Only total military failure will curb Putin's ambitions in Ukraine | Keir Giles
Any small gains will be spun as victory by the Kremlin. The west needs to support Ukraine to defeat Russian aggression, says Keir Giles of Chatham House’s Russia and Eurasia programme

Keir Giles

31, Mar, 2022 @1:11 PM

Article image
Forget Brexit, war in Ukraine is the biggest threat to Europe | Simon Jenkins
Eastern Europe is a tinderbox, writes Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins

26, Nov, 2018 @11:53 AM

Article image
The west’s focus on imminent invasion in Ukraine may backfire – and bolster Putin | Keir Giles
The US risks embarrassing itself and its intelligence if Russia chooses an option other than invasion, says Chatham House’s Keir Giles

Keir Giles

14, Feb, 2022 @12:11 PM

Article image
There's an easy way to help Ukraine without military escalation: cancel its foreign debt | Owen Jones
A country battered and bruised by Russia’s invading forces needs space to breathe – not demands from hedge funds, says Guardian columnist Owen Jones

Owen Jones

21, Mar, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Putin’s key supporters are now playing a desperate face-saving game in Ukraine | Olga Chyzh
Russia’s humiliated military and intelligence blocs know they have let their leader down, and need the war to go on, says political science expert Olga Chyzh

Olga Chyzh

20, Apr, 2022 @3:36 PM