The Guardian view on the Tory leadership contenders: not up to the job | Editorial

Like the first round of the contest, the second confirms that Conservative MPs seem incapable of uniting behind a new leader

The second round of the Conservative leadership contest to succeed Boris Johnson has produced more of the same. The result amounts to a slight hardening up of the indecisive first round, not a redrawing of the contest. Tory MPs remain deeply divided and factionalised. They do not know who they want to lead them, largely because they do not agree about what they now stand for. Unable even to unite their own party, the Conservatives are in no position to unite the country either.

Rishi Sunak remains the frontrunner to be one of the two names that will be put to party members at the end of next week, but his 101 votes leave him a long way short of being the majority choice of the 356 Tory MPs who voted in round two. Penny Mordaunt got the biggest number of new votes, 16, and remains a strong second with 83, but she is likely to face much fiercer attacks now. Liz Truss stays in third place, but her 64 votes mean that she is trailing behind Ms Mordaunt and confirm that she is the candidate of a parliamentary faction, and is not likely to be a unifier.

The elimination of Suella Braverman is welcome after she disgraced her post of attorney general by calling for Britain to withdraw from the European convention on human rights. Her mainly rightwing votes may strengthen Ms Truss in Monday’s third round. But Ms Braverman had only 27 supporters in round two, so they will not reshape the contest. Tom Tugendhat, whose vote also declined, remains in the game until next week, as does Kemi Badenoch.

Both will be using the opportunity provided by the debates to raise their profiles, with a view both to surviving round three and establishing a claim to a cabinet post. But the 108 MPs who supported the three weaker candidates represent a wide spectrum of Tory views, not a homogeneous block. The elimination of all three would still leave the field wide open and the leadership unresolved.

The Tory party has demonstrated that it does not know who it wants as leader. The votes next week may show if it knows who it wants to stop. Mr Sunak is fighting against the angry Johnson loyalists, the obsessive tax cutters, and the sceptics who think he is not up to the job. Ms Truss is battling all those Tories who fear she lacks the necessary skills and who do not want a continuity Johnson government. Ms Mordaunt has to prevent all those from different wings of the party who are threatened by a new broom from allying to stop her.

It is possible that the televised debates this weekend will change the momentum. But history does not show much evidence for it. The immediate interest will be in what the candidates say about issues they have avoided so far – like the cost of living crisis and what they really think of Mr Johnson. If the frontrunners land blows on one another, the danger for the Tory party in its current disarray is that the debates will parade the party’s divisions before a much wider audience.

The debates will be an important test and opportunity for Ms Mordaunt. She has succeeded thus far in casting herself as the outsider without baggage, even though she remains part of the Johnson government. Her campaign planning has also been more subtle than those of her rivals. Now she has to say what she will do to get the country through an unprecedented economic crunch that is reshaping millions of households. If she is deemed to have come through these tests, she will be in a strong position when the election moves to the membership, where opinion polls show that her support is already particularly strong. If not, her rocket may fall to earth very quickly, leaving Mr Sunak and Ms Truss to grind out a contest that will do the Tory party no service and the country no good.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on Liz Truss’s new backers: don’t delude yourselves | Editorial
Editorial: More moderate Tories are endorsing the frontrunner in the leadership race in order to be on the winning side. They will not have much influence


04, Aug, 2022 @5:59 PM

Article image
The good news: Johnson’s on the way out. The bad news: look who’s on the way in | Marina Hyde
One ridiculously graceless ‘resignation’ speech later, here are the top Tory gorgons competing to control the sunlit uplands, says Guardian columnist Marina Hyde

Marina Hyde

08, Jul, 2022 @11:55 AM

Article image
Forget the ‘natural party of government’: these Tories are headless chickens | Martin Kettle
The leadership election is revealing a party that has no time for anything as boring as self-reflection, says Guardian columnist Martin Kettle

Martin Kettle

13, Jul, 2022 @5:58 PM

Article image
Tory leadership race: the contenders to replace Boris Johnson
Full spectrum of candidates are likely to come from almost every ideological wing of the party

Heather Stewart Political editor

09, Jul, 2022 @3:05 PM

Article image
The Tory leadership race: a 40C fever dream where 0.2% of the UK decide our next leader | Hannah Jane Parkinson
We’ve had obnoxiousness, bad pitches and even worse graphics … and there’s still seven weeks to go, says Guardian columnist Hannah Jane Parkinson

Hannah Jane Parkinson

18, Jul, 2022 @1:44 PM

Article image
How does the Tory leadership contest work?
The backbench 1922 Committee has set the rules and timetable for picking the next UK prime minister

David Batty

12, Jul, 2022 @1:36 PM

Article image
How Truss beat Sunak: round by round Tory leadership results
Conservative MPs engaged in a series of votes to select two final candidates to be put to the party membership to choose a new leader, and therefore a new prime minister. On Monday Liz Truss was confirmed as the winner and will take the reins of government

Seán Clarke and Anna Leach

05, Sep, 2022 @11:46 AM

Article image
Liz Truss under pressure as rivals steal march in Tory leadership race
Foreign secretary forced to regroup after trailing behind Rishi Sunak and Penny Mordaunt after first round ballot

Heather Stewart and Aubrey Allegretti

13, Jul, 2022 @9:30 PM

Article image
Tory leadership race: who’s still standing, what are they promising and who’s backing them?
And then there were two: members to decide between Truss and Sunak as Penny Mordaunt eliminated

Alexandra Topping , Ben Quinn and Helena Horton

19, Jul, 2022 @2:49 PM

Article image
Penny Mordaunt’s Tory leadership bid boosted as Braverman exits
Trade minister consolidates second place behind Sunak as second vote narrows field to five

Jessica Elgot Chief political correspondent

14, Jul, 2022 @4:29 PM