The Guardian view on the January 6 committee: Trump’s terrible, no-good year | Editorial

The referral of the former president to the justice department on four criminal charges is largely symbolic, but increases his woes

In its closing months, 2022 is looking like an annus horribilis for Donald Trump – or to put it in the former president’s terms, a terrible, horrible, no-good, very bad year. The January 6 committee’s recommendation on Monday that criminal charges be brought against him over his attempt to subvert the 2020 election results and the deadly storming of the Capitol was unprecedented – the first time that Congress has referred a former president to the Department of Justice. Though largely symbolic, it has set down a marker. And it is the latest in a string of recent setbacks.

His candidates triumphed in Republican primaries, but then tanked in the midterms. His announcement on his 2024 bid was lacklustre and bathetic. A New York jury found his business guilty of tax fraud. On Tuesday, a House committee was set to vote on whether to release six years of his tax returns to the public. And, of course, the list of civil actions and criminal investigations targeting him is growing.

The congressional committee’s referral does not change the legal position, though some of the evidence it turned over to the justice department theoretically could. In its impact on public opinion, however, it may have an indirect effect on whether charges are brought. The evidence the committee amassed and its presentation of the facts are compelling. In televised hearings and presentations, in the executive summary published on Monday, and presumably in the full report to follow this week, it has shone an unflinching light on the brutality of that day and Mr Trump’s culpability.

His own aides have testified that he was repeatedly told he had lost, and that they urged him to tell the crowd to be peaceful. Instead, he pressed Republican officials to overturn the results, then his vice-president to block Congress from approving Joe Biden’s victory. When those attempts failed, he summoned a crowd to Washington, urged it to the Capitol and for hours failed to call off supporters as they rampaged and hunted down elected politicians. Unlike Mr Trump himself, at least some participants have since admitted their responsibility. One described his involvement as “part of an attack on the rule of law”; another conceded that “I guess I was [acting] like a traitor”.

The referral will, if anything, spur on Mr Trump’s fight for the Republican candidacy, further convincing him that power is the best form of protection. Charges, if laid, may reinforce rather than shift the minds of his diehard supporters. More than two-thirds of Republicans still believe that Mr Biden’s victory was illegitimate. Nonetheless, they are turning away from the former president in the polls. A large majority of Republican voters or independents who lean towards the party think someone else should be its candidate in 2024. Mr Trump wanted to clear the field, to run unchallenged. But those who trade on a strongman image cannot afford to look weak. Support for Ron DeSantis, the Florida governor, has surged. Mr Trump’s media cheerleaders, every bit as cynical as the ex-president, have turned on him. Ivanka Trump wants nothing to do with her father’s 2024 bid.

It would be immensely foolish to write off the 45th president. For years he has defied the laws of political gravity, surviving scandals and offences that individually would have sunk any other candidate or office-holder. The Republican elite remain notably silent or mealy-mouthed about him. Even if he cannot recover, others are already using his playbook. Yet the prospect that he will rebound, or another like him take his place, is all the more reason to establish the full record of his actions – whether or not they ultimately lead to legal consequences.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on democracy in America: the threat is real | Editorial
Editorial: Democrats are right to launch impeachment proceedings against Donald Trump for a second time. But he is a symptom as well as a cause of the current crisis


12, Jan, 2021 @6:59 PM

Article image
Cheney hits back as Pence says January 6 committee has ‘no right’ to testimony
Panel vice-chair issues statement with chair Bennie Thompson after Trump vice-president gives interview to CBS

Martin Pengelly in New York

17, Nov, 2022 @12:10 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the January 6 committee hearing: truth v alternative facts | Editorial
Editorial: Establishing what happened on and before that day is essential – but it is not enough


10, Jun, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the storming of the US Capitol: democracy in danger | Editorial
Editorial: The US president created this insurrection, but others have aided his assault on America’s institutions


07, Jan, 2021 @7:08 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Trump’s tactics: calculated brazenness | Editorial
Editorial: The 2020 election is highlighting many of the old weaknesses of America’s electoral system


05, Nov, 2020 @7:06 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Biden and the world: undoing Trump’s damage | Editorial
Editorial: The president-elect will on the whole seek a return to the status quo ante – a relief to US allies


15, Nov, 2020 @6:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Trump’s mob, a year on: threats to democracy grow
Editorial: On the anniversary of the US Capitol riot, the danger is not over. Republicans are stepping up their assault upon voters’ rights and essential institutions


05, Jan, 2022 @7:14 PM

Article image
The Big Lie review: Jonathan Lemire laments what Trump hath wrought
The Politico reporter and MSNBC host’s book is an indictment of the former president but also his Republican party

Lloyd Green

31, Jul, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Trump's strategy: overturn result, cheat democracy | Editorial
Editorial: The US president is seeking to bring down a system that defeated him


03, Jan, 2021 @6:25 PM

Article image
Pence has ‘erect posture but flaccid conscience’, says ex-Trump official
Miles Taylor, author of famous column and book by ‘Anonymous’, says former vice-president cannot stand up to his former boss

Martin Pengelly

27, Jul, 2022 @12:05 PM