Where does an overloaded mental health system leave patients with an ADHD diagnosis? | Nicholas Hudson

As a GP, more and more people are coming to see me about ADHD. But with specialists overwhelmed, where should they turn?

It seems like almost everyone has a friend who has recently been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). As a GP working in suburban Melbourne, what had been an occasional topic patients broached is now a conversation I’m having multiple times a week.

So what has changed, and what does it mean for our health and health system?

ADHD is a developmental condition, present from childhood, broadly involving issues with inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity. There is an increasingly recognised subtype characterised by inattention without the other features. The stereotypical presentation is a child who is restless and a bit chaotic in their behaviour and struggling to meet their potential at school.

Where I’m seeing growth is not so much among children, but rather among adults. The accepted wisdom is that highly functional adults can compensate for their ADHD until something upsets the apple cart. This might be running up against a task that surpasses their organisational strategies; a move from high school to the more self-directed learning of tertiary study; a shift away from the support structures of living with family; or a loss of the environmental cues and structures that had borne them along.

The last three years have seen the classroom, workplace and home amalgamated into one porridgy, ill-defined singularity, with added mental, financial and social stress. It’s no wonder people started looking inwards when they didn’t immediately “bounce back” with the end of lockdowns.

There can also be a snowball effect of symptom recognition. With swathes of algorithmic social media where people relate their experiences, or by talking to friends and hearing their stories, it’s easy to see why people might identify with signs such as reading sentences off a page without absorbing any of it, forgetting a pin number that’s been used for a decade or feeling overwhelmed by the noise, sights and smells returning to the grocery store, school or office.

As with most mental health conditions, the defining factor for diagnosis is the degree of dysfunction the person faces. Is their education faltering? Is it impacting their work? Are their relationships suffering?

Don’t get me wrong: most of the people who come in wanting to explore an ADHD diagnosis meet the criteria and then some. But where does that leave them? And where does it leave a mental health system where wait times to see a psychiatrist were already teetering on untenable, before living through a global pandemic made us all feel that bit more vulnerable?

The conventional wisdom is that the mainstay of management of ADHD is behavioural and psychological strategies, but when patients come in interested in a diagnosis, they’ve often pursued these avenues and are looking at medication options – and that’s where we hit a snag.

Legislative requirements vary between state and territories, but from a Victorian context, medication requires a diagnosis by a psychiatrist (retrospective to before 18 years of age, if scripts are to be subsidised under the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme), and either initiation of medication by the psychiatrist or deputisation of a GP through a written plan, that the GP can then use as supporting evidence to apply for a permit to prescribe. These permits can be held for up to two years.


In the halcyon days, I could provide a referral to a psychiatrist with confidence that it was someone whose opinion I valued and trusted, who I had corresponded with professionally and received that most invaluable of endorsements: positive patient feedback.

Now, if my patients have any hope of being seen, I’ve increasingly needed to refer to someone I haven’t worked with before. The path of least resistance for patients is to pursue a diagnostic review through a Medicare item 291, whereby the psychiatrist provides their diagnosis and a plan of action to allow the GP to treat. To meet this demand, a number of telehealth services have sprung up.

The “going rate” for most of these single-appointment assessments appears to be an out-of-pocket cost of $200-400 – already placing it out of the reach of many patients. Depending on the service, costs can be in excess of $1,100. Some such assessments have provided me not with a clear insight into the patient’s situation and the medication options best suited to them, but rather a list of the medications that are used for ADHD, with a seemingly somewhat cynical view to ticking the box for prescribing requirements.

I’m not confident this always leaves me or my patients any better off.

So what advice can I offer? Firstly, caveat emptor – do your research, and ask your GP or psychologist which services they have confidence in. Second, the feeling of urgency for action in the “I think I might have ADHD” presentation can lead to hasty decisions. I encourage you to consider laying your foundation through work with a psychologist, and consider waiting to see a specialist we can vouch for.

• Dr Nicholas Hudson is a general practitioner working in South Melbourne

Nicholas Hudson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
My patients don’t separate their physical and mental health. Medicare must stop asking us to | Mariam Tokhi
Medicare’s recent warning is a slap in the face for those of us trying to provide quality, whole-person care

Mariam Tokhi

13, Feb, 2020 @1:49 AM

Article image
My vulnerable patients cannot pay large gap fees. Australia’s health system is failing them | Mariam Tokhi
Those who can’t afford quality healthcare often turn up in emergency departments – later and sicker. We are in big trouble

Mariam Tokhi

16, Aug, 2022 @3:08 AM

Article image
Australia needs to decolonise the mental health system and empower more Indigenous psychologists | Vanessa Edwige, Joanna Alexi, Belle Selkirk, Pat Dudgeon
For Aboriginal people, wellbeing is seen as holistic, with mental health inseparable from connections to family, culture and Country

Vanessa Edwige, Joanna Alexi, Belle Selkirk, Pat Dudgeon

02, Jun, 2022 @1:25 AM

Article image
Tuning out the static: It took 40 years before I found out that I have ADHD | Tom Hawking
It’s hard not to wonder how things like jobs and relationships might have turned out differently had I been medicated all along

Tom Hawking

09, Jul, 2019 @6:00 PM

Article image
TikTok accidentally detected my ADHD. For 23 years everyone missed the warning signs | Matilda Boseley
Learning you have ADHD on TikTok is now such a common phenomenon it has become its own meme, but it can be tricky

Matilda Boseley

03, Jun, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Our vulnerable patients trust us but Victoria’s vaccination system is hard to navigate | Mariam Tokhi and Lester Mascarenhas
We must make vaccinations accessible to those from diverse backgrounds with poor English-language skills and limited health literacy

Mariam Tokhi and Lester Mascarenhas

01, Jun, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
'I cried every day at work': mental health among doctors is still taboo
Readers share stories of sleep deprivation, bullying and an institutional lack of support in a high-performing profession. They describe how they suffered and what helped them

Svetlana Stankovic and Guardian readers

04, Jul, 2017 @5:24 AM

Article image
If we allow Covid to overwhelm Australia's health system, medical care will suffer | Stephen Parnis
Wishing the pandemic over does not make it so. Doctors like me are facing the consequences of a Covid wave that is the most severe to date

Stephen Parnis

31, Jul, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
A more caring workplace for health professionals can save lives – of patients and of doctors | Ranjana Srivastava
With doctors twice as likely to die of suicide than the population average, three key changes are urgently needed

Ranjana Srivastava

08, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Mental health is Australians' most common ailment, GPs report
Half of GPs surveyed for new report say patients’ psychological problems the issue causing them most concern for future

Luke Henriques-Gomes

19, Sep, 2018 @2:37 AM