The Guardian view on cheap train travel: a lesson from Germany | Editorial

While the British rail industry is subjected to managed decline post-Covid, other countries are taking a more imaginative approach

The decision by one of the country’s main train operators to reduce services on the west coast mainline offers the latest evidence of deep malaise in the rail industry. Citing staff shortages and “the current industrial relations climate”, Avanti West Coast has put an emergency timetable in place, severely restricting the number of inter-city trains serving the north-west and Scotland. Aslef train drivers went on strike on Saturday. This week, the RMT union will resume its strike action over job security, pay and conditions, as the transport secretary, Grant Shapps, seeks to impose cuts of £2bn a year on a sector struggling to return to pre-Covid passenger numbers. It is a bleak picture and, given the vital role of public transport in reducing carbon emissions, a depressing one. But a glance at the rest of Europe suggests it really doesn’t have to be this way.

In Germany, this has been the summer of the train. In June, the SPD-led coalition government introduced a heavily subsidised and wildly popular €9 monthly public transport pass, designed to get people out of cars and, at the same time, ease the cost of living crisis. In June alone, 31 million people bought one. The most recent data indicates a doubling of short-distance train journeys between 30km and 100km, compared with pre-Covid levels. One in five passengers appear to have taken the opportunity to use public transport regularly for the first time.

Similarly bold experiments are taking place elsewhere, driven by the long-term goal of reducing carbon emissions and the short-term need to mitigate the impact of soaring fuel costs. In Spain, another socialist-led coalition administration is introducing free rail travel for commuters from September until the end of the year, and halving many other fares. Last year, Austria launched the Klimaticket, an annual rail pass that costs about €21 a week. In 2020, Luxembourg made all travel on its trains and buses free. Estonia’s capital, Tallinn, has had free public transport since 2013.

Germany’s radical move costs an estimated €2.5bn in state subsidies. Christian Lindner, the ruling coalition’s liberal finance minister, is insisting that funds are not available to continue the €9 ticket beyond the end of August, when the scheme is due to close. There have at times been uncomfortable levels of overcrowding, and it is uncertain to what extent holiday season travel patterns are relevant to the rest of the year. Initial audits also suggest that car usage may have remained constant. But in a nation famous for its love affair with the car, political imagination has opened up the possibilities of rail travel to more people and pointed the way to a cultural shift in tune with net zero targets. Mr Lindner’s green colleagues in government have called for a successor scheme to be partly financed by ending tax breaks on company cars. As a spokesperson for Deutsche Bahn, the national rail company, said: “Holding on to these riders long-term is important for transport and climate policy.”

It would be nice to think that Mr Shapps – whose approach to the RMT strikes has been to pit the public against rail workers and replay the confrontational politics of the 1970s – has noticed that other countries are doing things differently. Sadly, it seems that managed decline is the peak of this government’s ambition for the railways. A trip to Berlin or Madrid might help the transport secretary see this strategic myopia and short-termism for what it is.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fragmented railways will never work, public or private | Simon Jenkins
As long as UK trains and infrastructure are separate, the chaos will continue, says Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins

21, Sep, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Britain’s railways: a system where nobody listens | Editorial
Editorial: Delays and cancellations continue to plague commuter services. Now the prices are being hiked again. There is a human solution to this mess


13, Aug, 2018 @5:49 PM

Article image
Nationalisation isn’t enough. For better transport, you’ve got to go local | John Harris
Behind the Northern Rail crisis is a system that’s staggeringly overcentralised. The power to change transport must be devolved, says John Harris, Guardian staff columnist

John Harris

10, Jun, 2018 @5:17 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on England’s train stations: make them part of a rail renaissance | Editorial
Editorial: The government’s U-turn on closing more than 1,000 ticket offices is a relief. It is time to reject a short-sighted approach of managed decline


05, Nov, 2023 @6:30 PM

Article image
We need a competent transport secretary. We’ve got Chris Grayling | Gaby Hinsliff
He has presided over chaos on the UK’s railways, but the man with the reverse Midas touch steams merrily on, says Guardian columnist Gaby Hinsliff

Gaby Hinsliff

04, Dec, 2018 @12:53 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on HS2: let the train take the strain | Editorial
Editorial: HS2 is well behind schedule and over budget. It can only work as part of an integrated transport plan designed to cut carbon


05, Feb, 2020 @6:57 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on HS2 cancellation: mind the north-south gap | Editorial
Editorial: Rishi Sunak promotes himself as a leader who takes long-term decisions for the national benefit, but this one is the exact opposite


05, Oct, 2023 @6:20 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Chris Grayling: part of the problem, not the solution | Editorial
Editorial: The transport secretary has left a trail of damage wherever he has been in charge. If his career stays on the rails, the government is heading for the buffers


04, Jun, 2018 @5:55 PM

Article image
Open up rail ticket booking to third parties | Letters
Letters: Dave Ashton of Loco2 calls for access to data for comparison sites, while Sheils Cross thinks only nationalisation can create harmonisation of fares


11, May, 2018 @4:01 PM

Article image
Just how bad do Britain’s trains have to get before the Tories act? | Helen Pidd
In the north of England in particular, rail companies such as Avanti are causing misery on a daily basis. This cannot go on, says Guardian North of England editor Helen Pidd

Helen Pidd

24, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM