Cancel culture is rife at newly merged HBO and Warner Bros isn’t immune either | Alex Clark

The bean-counters have axed Batgirl and some other favourite TV shows are disappearing too

There’s a wonderful novel by the Japanese writer Yōko Ogawa called The Memory Police, which portrays an island community living under a strange form of repression: every now and again, something is taken from them – it might be photographs, or rose petals, or hats – and not only do the objects disappear but all references, memories and language associated with them.

I remembered it last week, as reports circulated that the streaming platform HBO Max had been removing titles from its catalogue following a merger with Discovery+. Were we in a beautifully suggestive allegory of cultural authoritarianism, the anguished howls that have greeted the disappearance of shows such as Vinyl, An American Pickle and The Witches would have themselves been silenced; as it is, this is just business and some of them are even now popping up elsewhere.

No such luck for the stars of Batgirl, including Leslie Grace, Michael Keaton and Brendan Fraser, whose endeavours were decisively nixed by Warner Bros, itself merged with Discovery+ in April. The artists v the bean-counters is only ever going to have one winner.

By coincidence, I was reading about the Portuguese dictator António Salazar, who, before his death in 1970, had been severely incapacitated by illness for two years. Rather than tell him he was no longer in charge, his inner circle maintained the fiction that his rule maintained. Would it have killed Warner Bros to do the same?

Feline oppressed

Screenshot of Hector’s House, with cat and dog puppets wearing aprons
Hector’s original house. Photograph: undefined/BBC

I didn’t have a cat until I was over 50 and had gone to live in the countryside and even then it was by accident. A letter left by our house’s previous owner told us a gingery-brown cat called Hector occasionally stopped by and liked a dish left down. Long story short, Hector, a female Norwegian forest cat, has now been living with us for some years.

Not long before the pandemic hit, she was joined by black-and-white ZsaZsa – those of a certain age will recognise names from the antique children’s TV programme Hector’s House, in which a dog, a cat and a frog pottered around a garden together. Being French, and inspired by the films of Jacques Tati, it was quite odd; Kiki the frog, for example, is a meteorologist.

We’ve recently acquired our own Kiki, a tabby kitten, currently thought to be male. Hector, now entirely blind, is unbothered; ZsaZsa, never the most clubbable and currently made more irascible by a torn cruciate ligament, is in a state somewhere between outraged betrayal and unfettered aggression.

Each morning I must wrap blood pressure pills in ham for Hector, persuade ZsaZsa to drink a foul-tasting concoction to ease her juvenile arthritis and prevent the entirely healthy kitten from partaking of either. “I am not a cat person,” I mutter.

Fiddling with my dahlias one afternoon, I looked up to see Kiki balancing precariously on a narrow, first-floor window ledge, having escaped to the forbidden upstairs where he found an open window. “Much more of this and I’ll be joining you,” I said to him as I went to fetch the stepladder.

Fever pitch

Marcelo poses with the Champions League trophy on top of a fountain with confetti falling all around him
Changes to the timing of football’s big championships will leave players less time to work on their tattoos. Above Real Madrid captain Marcelo with the trophy in May 2022. Photograph: Sergio Pérez/EPA

Everyone in my world, it seems from a cascade of out-of-office replies, is on holiday – except the freelancers picking up scraps. And, oddly enough, professional footballers. Because of the Qatar World Cup being injected into the middle of the European season, their schedule starts earlier, with the Champions League hauled into the autumn and new rules for substitutes meaning that more men will get on to the pitch. Result: reduced time for golf tournaments, the launch of new clothing ranges and the inking of elaborate tattoo “sleeves”. Take note, hard-pressed public sector workers: the struggle is not yours alone.

• Alex Clark is a columnist for the Observer and the Guardian

  • Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a letter of up to 250 words to be considered for publication, email it to us at


Alex Clark

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
AT&T agrees deal to combine WarnerMedia with Discovery
New company aims to ‘compete with world’s largest streamers’ such as Netflix and Disney+

Mark Sweney

17, May, 2021 @12:56 PM

Article image
Christopher Nolan leads industry fury over Warner Bros' streaming move
Tenet director says studio’s decision to release its entire 2021 slate in the US simultaneously in cinemas and on HBO Max is ‘not how you treat film-makers’

Andrew Pulver

08, Dec, 2020 @1:10 PM

Article image
Surprise pandemic hit and now talk of a new series, Sopranos is still the boss | Rebecca Nicholson
With writer David Chase apparently in discussions with HBO Max, my inner Tony can’t help but wonder ‘whadayagunnado?’

Rebecca Nicholson

23, Oct, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
The Netflix cash machine needs the kind of hits that money can’t buy
It is worth $166bn and has 150m users. But as it loses the rights to other networks’ best shows, it must create its own classics

Mark Sweney

13, Jul, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
Gone With the Wind dropped from HBO Max over depiction of slavery
Temporary move followed call by 12 Years a Slave scriptwriter John Ridley for streaming services to review content that is ‘blatant in its demonisation’ of race

Andrew Pulver

10, Jun, 2020 @10:28 AM

Article image
Philip Larkin: a canary in the coalmine of cancel culture | Rachel Cooke
Hull University in midwinter provided a perfect backdrop for a centenary lecture series on its most famous librarian

Rachel Cooke

10, Dec, 2022 @4:00 PM

Article image
Laura Kuenssberg’s successor must be immune to likes and follows | Tim Adams
Dullness and a total disinterest in their media profile are desirable traits in the BBC’s next political editor

Tim Adams

23, Oct, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
Warner Bros to launch its 2021 movies simultaneously on HBO Max and in cinemas
The studio’s upcoming 17 releases, including The Matrix 4 and Dune, will premiere in the US for subscribers at no extra charge

Benjamin Lee

03, Dec, 2020 @8:14 PM

Article image
Warner Bros to expand UK studio
Hollywood giant says thousands of jobs will follow expansion of historic Hertfordshire home to blockbusters

Dalya Alberge

19, Sep, 2015 @8:54 PM

Article image
Fox, Time Warner, and Rupert Murdoch's last game of thrones

The old mogul's bid is a bold one. But with such a prize in play, might the new media giants – the tech companies – step in?

Dominic Rushe in New York

19, Jul, 2014 @11:05 PM