Morrison says he can’t make aged care nurses fall from the sky. Sounds like he's not even trying | Sarah Holland-Batt

This week, the Fair Work Commission commenced landmark hearings into whether Australia’s aged care workforce should receive a 25% pay rise, to bring their pay into parity with disability and hospital workers.

Undoubtedly, these hearings will tell us what we already know: the aged care workforce is overwhelmingly female, underpaid and undervalued. Its workers are often asked to work in facilities with unsafe levels of staffing that contribute to neglect and care failures. Rates of burnout are high, with a looming exodus of more workers; a recent survey revealed that one in five workers are contemplating leaving aged care within the next year.

Confronted about his perceived failure to address longstanding workforce issues in the sector during the leaders’ debate last week, the prime minister made a jaw-dropping statement that evoked his infamous phrase about not holding hoses in its sheer disavowal of authority. “We can’t just make nurses fall out of the sky,” Morrison said, implying that the federal government is incapable of exerting any influence over the recruitment or retention of nurses, or improved working conditions in aged care.

This is patently untrue. More than 20 inquiries into the aged care sector over the past decade have handed down a slew of recommendations about how to address aged care workforce issues, including pay rises, staffing minimums, training opportunities, and more nurses. There’s no lack of effective solutions to the problems in aged care – only a lack of political will to enact them.

The royal commission offered several key recommendations to address working conditions in aged care, including mandating the presence of a registered nurse on-site at all times in aged care facilities, and the introduction of minimum staffing minutes per resident per day. The importance of 24/7 RNs in aged care facilities is irrefutable: RNs are highly trained, and because they can dispense pain medication, their presence reduces hospital transfers and enhances the quality of palliative care. Yet in its formal response to the royal commission, the Morrison government postponed the implementation of minimum staffing minutes by over a year, and has only committed to funding RNs for 16 hours per day from October 2023.

In the face of Labor’s commitment to fund 24/7 RNs, the government has mounted the fatalistic argument that there aren’t enough nurses in the workforce, and that regional aged care facilities may have to close if such a standard were introduced due to a dearth of staff. While it’s true that there aren’t presently enough nurses in the aged care system – the Department of Health projects that an additional 14,000 nurses will be required to meet the requirement of RNs 16 hours a day, and an additional 2,500 nurses to enable 24/7 RNs – the real question is why the Morrison government has failed to recruit the workforce it has long known would be needed, and why it has allowed so many regional aged care facilities to close under its watch.

Rather than offering any meaningful solutions to these workforce issues, the Morrison government and its ministers seem intent on relishing the difficult task they will hand Labor if it wins government. Bafflingly, the health and aged care minister, Greg Hunt, has sought to criticise Labor for supposedly backflipping over the fact that they may need to recruit overseas nurses to fulfil its promise of 24/7 nursing, saying that Labor “doesn’t have the nurses or doctors for [Albanese’s] election promises … they will have to import them after his Shadow Minister ruled that out only days ago”, and describing Labor’s commitment to mandating 24/7 RNs by 2023 as posing “profound risks to care and rural services”. Coming from a minister who, as recently as October last year, was championing his own initiative to recruit 2,000 overseas doctors and nurses to help Australia cope with the Delta wave, the critique is as hypocritical as it is misguided.

The federal government’s Aged Care Workforce Action Plan 2022-2025 states it will create 33,800 new vocational and educational training places and 15,000 jobtrainer places, among a range of initiatives aimed at attracting workers to the sector. However, even if all these training places were filled, there will be a shortfall of 19,200 workers across that four year period from the projected 17,000 additional workers Ceda modelling shows will need to enter aged care every year over the next decade to deliver safe standards of care.

Hunt’s comments belie his ignorance of an obvious truth: our aged care system would collapse without overseas nurses and carers, who make up a significant and ever-increasing proportion of the workforce. The federal government’s own Aged Care Workforce Action Plan concedes as much, noting that “migration pathways are also important in the supply of aged care workers.” In 2011, 31% of aged care workers were born overseas; by 2016, this proportion had jumped to 37%. It’s now estimated that 40% of new aged care workers entering the workforce are migrants. Rather than crowing about Labor’s reliance on migrant workers, Hunt would be better to ask himself why such a significant proportion of our existing aged care workforce comes from overseas, and why these mostly female workers are so overworked and underpaid.

It’s critically important that Australia develops a sustainable aged care workforce and that more local nurses and carers are incentivised to enter the sector, but this outcome won’t be achieved by attacking Labor for relying on migrant workers who play such an important role within it today and will make their contributions in the future. It will only be achieved by meaningful reforms which address the underlying challenges in recruiting and retaining aged care workers. The aged care workforce issues are not insurmountable – but it remains to be seen whether the political apathy is.

• Sarah Holland-Batt is an advocate for aged care reform, commenting and writing on policy issues for a range of mastheads. She is a professor of creative writing at QUT, and the Judy Harris writer in residence at the University of Sydney’s Charles Perkins Centre. Her most recent book is The Jaguar (UQP, 2022)


Sarah Holland-Batt

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Labor promised aged care reform. The clock is ticking for genuine change | Sarah Russell
Until the royal commission’s recommendations are acted on, the government is merely tinkering

Sarah Russell

01, Mar, 2023 @10:47 PM

Article image
States to push back against federal plan to outsource aged care assessment
Calls grow to postpone the change until after the royal commission, as Coalition denies workforce will be privatised

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

27, Feb, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Calls for extension to Australia’s compulsory aged care vaccinations as Friday deadline approaches
90.8% of staff have received a single dose, but Health Services Union says sector can’t afford to lose even 5% of its workforce

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

12, Sep, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Unboosted aged care residents dominate Covid deaths as Morrison government misses rollout deadline
Industry groups say state governments eased restrictions too quickly after more than 400 aged care residents died in January

Elias Visontay

31, Jan, 2022 @4:30 PM

Article image
Morrison shrugs off censure of aged care minister Richard Colbeck over Covid conduct
Senate censures Colbeck for failing to recall basic ‘and tragic facts’ about residents but PM defends him, saying majority of sector unaffected during pandemic

Katharine Murphy Political editor

03, Sep, 2020 @7:45 AM

Article image
Labor calls for immediate aged care funding boost following scathing report
Health minister Greg Hunt promises ‘significant package’ for aged care but won’t commit to figure

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

03, Nov, 2019 @4:20 AM

Article image
Scott Morrison’s low standing with female voters could cost him the election | Peter Lewis
We have a contest that will be decided by uncommitted female voters who are unconvinced by the prime minister’s leadership

Peter Lewis

20, Apr, 2022 @2:29 AM

Article image
Undecided? Jaded with Australia’s major parties? Here are five stark differences between them this election | Paul Daley
I dedicate little attention to the daily campaign grind – but the contrasts between Labor and the Coalition are black and white

Paul Daley

04, May, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Richard Colbeck can no longer pass the buck on the failure to protect Australians in aged care homes | Sarah Russell
Sooner or later, he will need to take responsibility for all the heartbreaking tragedies that have occurred on his watch

Sarah Russell

02, Jun, 2021 @4:04 AM

Article image
Fact check: is aged care coping ‘extremely well’ with Omicron as Morrison government claims?
Experts respond to Coalition frontbenchers’ comments on the Covid death toll and booster rollout in nursing homes

Melissa Davey Medical editor

08, Feb, 2022 @1:31 AM