The economy has shafted millennials: now it wants their offspring too | Joel Golby

Yes, we know you can’t afford to have children. But if the economy tanks because of the low birthrate, you’ll be to blame

Everyone likes babies, don’t they, with their little tiny toes and the fact that they don’t do anything and are constantly doing those strange dark poos. “That’s my baby,” friends will tell me, pointing to a small wad of skin and flesh that is screaming for no reason, “I love it so much I could die.”

Does the baby do any tricks, I always ask, and they shake their head, no. “We think in maybe 18 months the baby might learn to walk,” they say. “Might get a full sentence out of it at about three.” Cool, well, see you in 18 years when you can go to the pub again.

Babies are the discourse this week, with two news stories that – if you squint and look closely – are absolutely and entirely related. “British ‘baby shortage’ could lead to economic decline, says thinktank,” goes one, and there is some interesting stuff by the Social Market Foundation in there. The current birthrate of 1.58 in England and Wales is far below the 2.1 replacement level needed, meaning in 2060 there will be close to four over-65s for every 10 workers (presuming of course that the millennial generation will be allowed to retire: seeing how we have been shafted at literally every other possible life milestone beyond “living in the same era as smartphones”, I don’t really see that happening). This will open up a support gap that will inevitably lead to economic decline.

Yet, conversely, we are told, “Four in 10 young people fear having children due to climate crisis.” Which makes its own sense. Why have a baby now – love it, care for it, teach it maths over a dinner table even though it refuses to get maths: this is some very simple mathematics, Henry! – when you know one day it’s going to have to use its combat skills to fight over a gallon jug of water while the sun approaches the scorched desert planet? To me, that seems like an unsensible waste of the last 20 years of viable time we have on Earth.

Why aren’t millennials having babies? And while we’re at it, why aren’t they buying houses? Well, we have got to the point where Britain’s economic reality has finally overcome the primal, lizard-brain urge we all have to replicate ourselves. It seems like a stupid and impossible ask: hey, 34-year-olds who are still paying off your student loans and renting, can you hurry up and have a baby please? The future of the economy relies on it. And no, we won’t be doing anything to make things in any way easier while you do it. Work harder.

The Social Market Foundation made a fairly humble suggestion to overcome the birthrate problem, which is – and I’m paraphrasing: “Stop making it so insanely difficult and expensive to have and look after a child.” The National Childbirth Trust calculates the average cost of full-time nursery for a child under two at £263 a week, which even with both parents working is a hefty chunk of the average family budget. If you want to keep your child past that age, or even have another one, for some reason, those costs are only going to accrue.

I know there’s a viable environmental argument for not having children, but that doesn’t stop a lot of people still deeply wanting to have them, and it seems bizarre that we make it so difficult for those who do. The foundation estimates British working parents spend 22% of their income on full-time childcare – twice the average of other western economies; a 2019 Unicef report found the UK’s paternity leave provision was still embarrassingly low, compared with other countries’; and a survey of more than 20,000 British parents undertaken in July and August this year found just 16% of mothers had their seniority at work and income unaffected by having a child (two-thirds had reduced their hours).

Though I don’t think any parents came out of lockdown going, “Wow! Homeschooling my child while juggling the infinite Zoom calls of my job was very easy! I really enjoyed that!”, there is at least an opportunity for more flexible homeworking schedules that could accommodate childcare, now that a lot of people know how to do their jobs from home. But then, that doesn’t directly benefit commercial landlords, so bosses and decision-makers are not in favour of it. Being a parent is basically just being awake all the time and spending all of your money, and that’s before you’ve done anything like buy shoes or uniform or those Nerf Blasters they all go crazy for.

Still, at least this is a return to form: you know nature is truly healing when millennials are being blamed for not thriving in an economic reality that seems explicitly designed to destroy them. At some point – when the schoolyards are spookily empty, and nobody has paid any stamp duty for years, and every inner-city Pret has had to close due to inactivity – they’ll have to admit that “buying and consuming avocado toast” wasn’t the problem they thought it was all along. Until then: get screwing, please, millennials! The future of the economy is built on the blood of your heirs!

• Joel Golby is a writer for the Guardian and Vice and the author of Brilliant, Brilliant, Brilliant Brilliant Brilliant


Joel Golby

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Discriminating against pregnant women is not just wrong, it’s foolish | Rowan Davies
Women are still hit by the motherhood penalty at work, with lower wages and stalled careers. If men did more childcare this would change, says Rowan Davies, head of policy at Mumsnet

Rowan Davies

20, Feb, 2018 @2:04 PM

Article image
You can smell a new mother’s loneliness. Unless you’re the state | Nell Frizzell
As a new mum, I know loneliness cuts deep – and the lack of services for parent and child plays a large part in this, says the freelance writer Nell Frizzell

Nell Frizzell

03, May, 2018 @1:21 PM

Article image
Why parents should fear childcare going the way of Carillion | Helen Penn
The UK hasn’t seen the collapse of a major nursery provider yet, but other countries have, says academic and author Helen Penn

Helen Penn

14, May, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Covid-19 has turned back the clock on working women's lives | Gaby Hinsliff
Nursery closures, job losses and home schooling have all affected women this year. But there is a way forward, says Guardian columnist Gaby Hinsliff

Gaby Hinsliff

10, Dec, 2020 @2:19 PM

Article image
The depressing truth about female creativity and the pram in the hallway | Fiona Sturges
Sweeping the subject of working mothers under the carpet only implies there isn’t a problem, says freelance writer Fiona Sturges

Fiona Sturges

21, Mar, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on falling birthrates: to parent or not to parent? | Editorial
Editorial: Pronatalist policies seem beside the point when existing families’ needs are ignored


20, Sep, 2021 @5:53 PM

Article image
Summer with the kids … long and costly for parents, but also a joy | Emma Brockes
Instead of a chore, the long school holiday should be seen as a carefree time for children, says Guardian columnist Emma Brockes

Emma Brockes

21, Jun, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Separation anxiety: why breaking up with your babysitter is hard to do | Emma Brockes
We became so close over the past four years that when I let her go, we felt affection as well as relief, says Guardian columnist Emma Brockes

Emma Brockes

27, Sep, 2019 @2:41 PM

Article image
Priced out of parenthood: no wonder the birthrate is plummeting | Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett
Deciding to have a child should fill you with joy, not crippling anxiety, says Guardian columnist Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett

Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett

20, Jul, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
How Stockholm became the city of work-life balance
With flexible hours the norm, and almost two years’ parental leave for every child, Sweden’s capital boasts a happy and efficient workforce. What can other cities learn?

Richard Orange in Stockholm

22, May, 2019 @5:00 AM