The Guardian view on Dominic Raab: no grip, no plan, no shame | Editorial

The foreign secretary’s evasions are typical of a government that cannot take responsibility for its actions

When judging a government’s performance in a crisis, there is a distinction to be drawn between control and responsibility. No British minister could have stopped the American withdrawal from Afghanistan. But there was time for contingency planning between that unilateral US policy being declared in February 2020 and its completion last month. Dominic Raab could not control the Taliban’s advance on Kabul, but that does not excuse him from responsibility for a chaotic and incomplete evacuation.

In an appearance before a parliamentary select committee on Wednesday, the foreign secretary sought cover behind intelligence assessments predicting a slower decay of the situation in Afghanistan, with the capital not falling this year.

Mr Raab also cited “optimism bias” in the run-up to US withdrawal as a factor, which is a delicate way of admitting that Whitehall was in denial. Even so, the foreign secretary insists that plans for a dramatic deterioration of the security environment did exist, which raises an awkward question: to what extent do events of recent weeks reflect the implementation of those plans? They cannot have been very good if the result is the abandonment of so many people: hundreds of British nationals and their dependants; many thousands of Afghans who had supported allied forces; female politicians and journalists; human rights activists and anyone who worked for causes that are despised by the Taliban. The foreign secretary could not say how many; all are now in danger of brutal reprisal.

When it was put to him that other European countries have been more effective in evacuating their citizens, the foreign secretary cited the comparatively bigger scale of British involvement in Afghanistan. But that compounds the offence. A bigger presence demanded a bigger plan.

The foreign secretary would be on firmer ground if he had not been on holiday as the Taliban closed in on Kabul. To the charge of negligence Mr Raab pleads delegation. Managing vital diplomatic business is a team effort. Calls to fellow foreign ministers and liaison with UK ambassadors in the region can be handled by capable deputies.

At best, that is an explanation of how the system is supposed to work in normal times, which is a tacit admission that Mr Raab failed to recognise the scale of the emergency as it struck. Hindsight, he says, gives him cause to regret that holiday. But where was the foresight? The Foreign Office had been calling on UK nationals to leave Afghanistan from the first week of August. Given the danger of their escape being thwarted, a dutiful secretary of state might have considered staying at his desk.

It is unfair to funnel all of the blame for the government’s mishandling of the Afghan crisis on to one minister. One problem with the caseload of evacuees is an absence of coordination between the Foreign Office, the Home Office and the Ministry of Defence. A chatter of recrimination around Whitehall confirms that interdepartmental communication over Afghanistan is dysfunctional, which in turn reflects poorly on Downing Street. If Mr Raab has insufficient grip of a major international crisis, it is Boris Johnson’s duty to replace him with someone who does, or take charge himself. Sadly, the prime minister does not have much of an appetite when it comes to making tough choices or owning the consequences. For the time being, it suits him to have a weak foreign secretary in place to absorb criticism that might otherwise be directed at No 10.

But there are many thousands of vulnerable people in Afghanistan who urgently need a British government staffed with people who are capable of taking control in a crisis and of taking responsibility for their actions.

Contributor

Editorial

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on the Taliban’s advance: we still have a responsibility to Afghans | Editorial
Editorial: The human cost is accumulating with the withdrawal of US and British troops

Editorial

06, Aug, 2021 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Afghanistan: unnecessary suffering | Editorial
Editorial: A reckless western withdrawal timetable has let a people down

Editorial

16, Aug, 2021 @6:29 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Dominic Raab: out of his depth | Editorial
Editorial: The understudy prime minister is exposing many of the structural flaws that characterise Boris Johnson’s government

Editorial

22, Apr, 2020 @5:47 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Boris Johnson’s foreign policy: a lethal vacuum | Editorial
Editorial: Parochial complacency define the prime minister’s view of the world, leaving him unequal to the crisis in Afghanistan

Editorial

18, Aug, 2021 @5:45 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on British foreign policy: the lost art of diplomacy | Editorial
Editorial: Boris Johnson’s cabinet is sulking at Brussels and sycophantic in Washington. Neither approach advances Britain’s interests as it faces Brexit

Editorial

07, Aug, 2019 @5:43 PM

Article image
Dominic Raab – the foreign secretary who phones it in | Marina Hyde
Incompetent, negligent, isolated, increasingly disliked – Raab is the perfect ambassador for ‘global Britain’, says Guardian columnist Marina Hyde

Marina Hyde

20, Aug, 2021 @11:35 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on the G7 Afghanistan talks: desperate damage limitation | Editorial
Editorial: Lack of planning and coordination has left the west scrambling to do the right thing

Editorial

23, Aug, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Team Johnson: no room for compromise | Editorial
Editorial: The new prime minister promises national unity and declares himself ready to pursue a no-deal Brexit. Those are not compatible positions

Editorial

24, Jul, 2019 @6:54 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Conservative leadership: unserious contenders | Editorial
Editorial: Getting rid of Theresa May has only brought the dilemmas that defeated her much closer to her party

Editorial

26, May, 2019 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Boris Johnson’s resignation: good riddance to a national embarrassment | Editorial
Editorial: Theresa May tried to hold her party together over Brexit. Two senior resignations mean she now has to win the battle against the leaver fanatics

Editorial

09, Jul, 2018 @7:28 PM