Texas schools are being told to teach ‘opposing views’ of the Holocaust. Why? | Francine Prose

The question of what specific books and topics can and can’t be taught is linked to a disturbing new law in Texas

I’ve been trying to imagine what Gina Peddy could have been thinking when, on 8 October, she informed a group of Southlake, Texas, elementary school teachers that, if their classroom libraries included books about the Holocaust, students should also be steered toward books with “opposing views”.

The executive director for curriculum and instruction for the Carroll Independent school district, Peddy later explained that she was simply helping her staff comply with Texas House Bill 3979. Signed into law on 1 September by Governor Greg Abbott, the ruling prohibits educators from discussing controversial historical, social or political issues. If these subjects do arise, HB 3979 mandates that teachers “explore such issues from diverse and contending perspectives without giving deference to any one perspective”.

Peddy’s speech was secretly recorded by one of the training session attendees. On the tape, one can hear the bewildered protests that greeted her directive. When a teacher demanded to know how one is supposed to “oppose” the Holocaust, Peddy replied: “Believe me. That’s come up.”

If only someone had recorded the conversations in which that subject “came up”. Did any of the participants observe that the only “diverse perspective” on the Holocaust is Holocaust denial: the odious contention that Hitler didn’t arrange the murder of 6 million Jews and hundreds of thousands of Roma, homosexuals, Poles and political prisoners; that Auschwitz and Treblinka were fabrications designed to discredit the Nazi’s quest for racial purity? Did anyone suggest that, under the new guidelines, it would now be illegal to teach The Diary of Anne Frank without citing the loathsome broadsides that have questioned the diary’s authenticity, among them Ditlieb Felderer’s 1979 Anne Frank’s Diary, A Hoax, which calls the iconic journal “the first pedophile pornographic work to come out after World War II”.

Traditionally, Holocaust denial has been fueled by the rawest and most egregious sort of antisemitism. There’s no way of knowing if that particular brand of bigotry was a factor in this case, but my hunch is that Peddy was talking about the Holocaust partly as a way of not talking about the other “controversial” topics that are the true focus of HB 3979: racism and LGBTQ+ rights.

One can’t help wondering if the response would have been quite so widespread and intense if Peddy had suggested that books on race relations be countered by other books addressing the toll – the very existence – of systemic racism. In fact, Rickie Farah, a fourth-grade teacher in the Southlake district, was recently reprimanded by the school board trustees for making Tiffany Jewell’s This Book is Anti-Racist available to her students; her case attracted minimal attention beyond the local press.

The question of what specific books and topics can and can’t be taught is only part of what’s so disturbing about HB 3979 and Peddy’s advice to the teachers. What’s troubling is the idea that legislators, rather than educators, should determine and impose limitations on a school curriculum. The problem is the way in which Peddy – and, presumably, others – have interpreted the new law to mean that teachers and their pupils should ignore the evidence of history, that students shouldn’t be encouraged to distinguish between what actually happened and what didn’t, and that a range of hot-button subjects are not merely inappropriate but forbidden to mention in a classroom setting.

If teachers are obliged to tell their classes that there is “another point of view” about whether the Holocaust occurred, must American history lessons now also include books asserting that the United States was never a slave-holding nation or that racism ended with the Emancipation Proclamation? If the discussion surrounding a novel or story leads a class to conclude that LGBTQ+ people are entitled to basic human rights, must the class be asked to seriously consider the opposing view: that those rights should be denied to anyone who differs from the heterosexual norm?

Education is a dialectical process. Lively classroom debates are an essential learning tool, a way of teaching kids to weigh evidence, to process information, to consider options, to make informed decisions. But HB 3979 aims to prohibit teachers from discussing some of the most important and relevant matters that concern us all. It discourages students from trying to find answers to the questions that will help determine what kind of adults they grow up to be, what kind of country and world they will live in.

We are already seeing the consequences of an underfunded, unequal and deteriorating educational system. Students who don’t learn about history are doomed to repeat its mistakes. Children who are prohibited from discussing the most critical issues of the day will gravitate into progressively more atomized and irreconcilable factions, unable to participate in the free and open exchange of ideas on which our democracy depends. Kids who don’t learn, early on, how to distinguish truth from fantasy will become adults who are prey to the self-serving and inaccurate claims of demagogic leaders. They will fall victim to every loony conspiracy theory that makes its way on to social media and make decisions that work against their own, and their society’s, best interests.

Persuading students that lies – about history, about social forces, about science, about the world around them – are as valid as demonstrable truths will turn us into a nation of con artists and their hapless marks, a country of liars and of people who have never been taught how to tell when they are being lied to.

  • Francine Prose is a novelist. Her latest book, The Vixen, was published in June


Francine Prose

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Texas school official says classrooms with books on Holocaust must offer ‘opposing’ views
In recording obtained by NBC News, curriculum director describes ‘political mess’ after passage of state law

Dani Anguiano in Los Angeles

15, Oct, 2021 @2:27 AM

Article image
Texas schools resist Republican request for records on classroom books
Austin and Dallas districts say they won’t respond to lawmaker’s letter targeting 850 books, many on race and LGBTQ+ issues

Gloria Oladipo

13, Nov, 2021 @5:13 PM

Article image
Republicans threaten our children’s freedom as well as their basic safety | Robert Reich
Attacks on mask mandates expose children to Covid. Attacks on the teaching of history expose them to dangerous ignorance

Robert Reich

29, Aug, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Mexican heritage textbook for Texas schools full of 'offensive stereotypes'
Ruben Cortez and a committee found Mexican American studies textbook for use in public schools has 141 errors of fact, interpretation and omission

Tom Dart In Houston

07, Sep, 2016 @6:07 PM

Article image
One way to teach students more safely this fall? Move lessons outdoors | Jaime Cunningham
It’s easier to do social distancing outside – and there’s considerable evidence that students learn better in fresh air

Jaime Cunningham

14, Aug, 2020 @12:28 PM

Article image
'It’s time to catch up’: how ideological sex education fails Texas students
Republican-controlled state board of education reinforces curriculum that flies in the face of a 21st-century reality and proves dangerous for kids

Alexandra Villarreal

22, Oct, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Texas board of education vote is critical for conservatives – and US schools
Board has become a battleground as members seek to stamp their values on textbooks, and now an extreme conservative is on the brink of a key position

Tom Dart in Houston

24, May, 2016 @1:04 PM

Article image
Florida and Texas schools defy governors’ mask mandate bans as cases soar
Biden administration considering reimbursing school officials who lose their pay if DeSantis follows through on his threat

Guardian staff and agencies

11, Aug, 2021 @2:57 PM

Article image
Politics is killing mothers in Texas | Jessica Valenti
The state’s maternal death rate is the highest in the developed world. Those denying women reproductive healthcare on ideological grounds are to blame

Jessica Valenti

23, Aug, 2016 @3:05 PM

Article image
America is not prepared for schools opening this fall. This will be bad | Siva Vaidhyanathan
We’re just weeks from schools opening, and they aren’t ready. Parents, children, teachers – everyone will be affected

Siva Vaidhyanathan

13, Jul, 2020 @9:30 AM