Don’t blame women for our low birthrate – we need to fix our precarious society

The last time there was a panic about women not having kids, it was because we were smashing glass ceilings. Now many young people simply can’t afford to start families

Dorothy Byrne, the president of Murray Edwards College at the University of Cambridge, has warned students not to leave it too late to have a baby. It is an all-female college, of course, otherwise this would make no sense: no one would ever tell a man when to sire young, because it would be considered intrusive and unnecessary. Also, Charlie Chaplin, huh? Remember how old he was when he had his youngest? What a top dog.

This was a huge preoccupation in the 90s – that women were going to forget about having kids until it was too late. Then, as now, it was rooted in fears about the birthrate and the average age of first-time mothers. (The birthrate last year was 1.53 for each woman, down from 2 in 2000, which is striking.) It used to drive me mad, partly because it is the most incredible pain to be a fertile woman. People are constantly in your grill, telling you what decisions you should make and when, what to eat and drink, whom to shag. It is completely draining.

Mainly, though, I divined a broad-brush conservative agenda underneath it all – a message that emancipation was all very well, but it should have hard limits. When it came to the societally useful bits of a woman – her reproductive apparatus – those should remain in the control of doctors, clerics and freelancing moralisers.

Then things went quiet for a couple of decades. Perhaps it was felt that the message had landed, that most women knew their fertility window wasn’t infinite and so didn’t need to be told every single morning. Or perhaps it merely became apparent that people would make their own decisions and the thundering “well-meant” advice wasn’t cutting through.

Seeing it resurface, I can’t help thinking how different the context is. Last century, we were putting off parenthood in order to smash glass ceilings and whatnot. Now, for at least five – if not 10 – years, the evidence has been that young people are delaying starting a family until they can afford it. This precariousness, driven in large part by housing insecurity, is only getting worse. Their elders should think twice before they deliver family planning tips; they are more likely to create young radicals than young mothers.

• Zoe Williams is a Guardian columnist


Zoe Williams

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Parent trap: why the cult of the perfect mother has to end
Worldwide, mothers are overworked, underpaid, often lonely and made to feel guilty about everything from epidurals to bottle feeding. Fixing this is the unfinished work of feminism

Eliane Glaser

18, May, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
New balance: will work be more parent-friendly than ever after the pandemic?
Between home schooling and hybrid working, the last year has brought rapid and radical shifts in our working habits, good and bad. Now it is time to see whether positive change can stick

Viv Groskop

13, Jul, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
‘Let them be kids!’ Is ‘free-range’ parenting the key to healthier, happier children?
Now more than ever, children are cooped up indoors and monitored 24/7. But how can they build confidence and social skills if adults never let them out of their sight?

Emine Saner

16, Aug, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Unspeakable grief: breaking the silence around terminations for medical reasons
In the UK, at least 5,000 pregnancies a year end in termination for medical reasons, but the grief and guilt of the parents can endure for years, while they often feel unable to speak openly about their experience

Zoe Williams

09, Aug, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Amber Heard has had a baby – and proved an important point | Arwa Mahdawi
The actor is part of a growing trend for women to choose to become single mothers, a choice that represents genuine progress, writes Arwa Mahdawi

Arwa Mahdawi

07, Jul, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
A moment that changed me: Patrick Stewart on the teacher who spotted his talent – and saved him
I skipped the 11-plus and was failing at school. Then I met Cecil Dormand, the extraordinary English teacher who transformed my life for ever

Patrick Stewart

13, Oct, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
‘There is so much bad behaviour everywhere’: how to raise a good child in a terrible world
Amid Trump, #MeToo and rising hate crime, science writer Melinda Wenner Moyer decided it was time to learn how to stop her kids becoming ‘assholes’. Her research became an unusual, much-needed parenting book

Emine Saner

07, Sep, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
We need to protect breastfeeding women from voyeurs – so why did the debate get so weird? | Arwa Mahdawi
British MPs are trying to make it illegal to photograph nursing mothers without their consent. But they’re facing some very strange arguments

Arwa Mahdawi

10, Nov, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Marriage and children don’t always make women happy. Who knew? | Suzanne Moore
Should Prof Paul Dolan’s pronouncements change the way we think about life? Suzanne Moore is unconvinced

Suzanne Moore

27, May, 2019 @5:12 PM

Article image
Lilibet Diana: the baby name that represents a royal rift – and audacious hope
By combining the names of the Queen and the Princess of Wales, Harry and Meghan have highlighted two very different approaches to the monarchy. But which will define the future?

Zoe Williams

09, Jun, 2021 @5:00 AM