How many more images of Covid disaster does it take to jolt rich countries into action? | Nesrine Malik

The crisis in India forced the west to respond. But without an ambitious global plan, other nations may suffer similar fates

As the number of Covid-19 cases rose dramatically in Europe and the US during the early part of last year, something strange seemed to be happening in the global south. South Africa’s entire death toll was less than 100 at the same time that Britain was losing more than 1,000 lives a day. India’s death rate during this period was so low that it was termed a “mystery”. More confident conclusions were drawn about Africa’s fate; some thought it had been spared the worst of Covid-19 because it took decisive action early on in the pandemic, while others said the continent had been saved by its warm climate, its low elderly population and its “good community health systems”. There was even brief excitement about the curative potential of homegrown sweet wormwood, a plant that the president of Madagascar claimed was a treatment for Covid-19.

Most of this reasoning was speculative. But by the late summer of 2020, two clear trends were emerging. While parts of western Europe were enduring a devastating first wave of Covid-19 cases, Africa and south Asia were experiencing a slow-moving, sometimes stalling rate of infection and a comparatively low death toll. Those trends are now being reversed.

With vaccination programmes gaining momentum in the global north, the pandemic in western countries finally appears to be waning. The opposite is happening in low-income countries. Most can expect no access to either vaccine technology or donations in the near future. Healthcare facilities are overstretched and under-resourced, and data collection is limited, meaning death statistics are unreliable. Most of the world’s population outside rich countries are confronting an extended Covid crisis. Indeed, for several countries there is no way of estimating when the pandemic will be over. Instead, what lies ahead is an open-ended stretch of uncertainty, as populations try, and inevitably fail, to coexist with this virus.

For every measure that placed Africa and south Asia in a good position at the start of the pandemic, there is another that undermines it. There are indeed strong community health systems in parts of west Africa, a legacy of the Ebola crisis. Those networks can raise awareness, but without the ability to test for Covid-19, they are unable to get a clear idea of infection rates. The same applies to mortality figures. In rural areas, many people don’t have access to large hospitals, and some deaths aren’t formally recorded. The fear of social stigma that a Covid-19 diagnosis can carry means some people bury their deceased relatives in haste, without getting a diagnosis or alerting family and social networks.

Instead of reliable data, those of us with family and friends in low-income countries have hushed, anecdotal evidence that does not correspond to official accounts. We measure waves by keeping track of what we hear; we learn to recognise the signs. Whenever relatives tell us of a quick illness or a hushed-up death, the deceased person is added to an informal mental tally of Covid-19 cases.

Successfully defeating the virus depends on having solid numbers and a dashboard of data. Without those, scientists are fighting this disease in the dark, as Michelle Gayer, director of emergency health at the International Rescue Committee, recently told the business publication Quartz. When a virus is allowed to quietly spread and scientists don’t have the data to map its trajectory, it’s difficult to tell what’s actually happening until a traumatic spike in death rates sheds light on the number of cases. This is the current reality in India, and while I don’t wish to be a doom-monger, it seems likely this will soon be the case in other countries too.

A brief survey of a few of the largest African countries by population shows how volatile the situation still is. South Africa and Ethiopia remain on the UK’s red list and are in varying stages of lockdown while their governments cobble together vaccine programmes. Kenya has wobbled out of another lockdown but maintains a strict curfew and remains on the red list. Egypt has truncated the school year and appears to be heading for the peak of its third wave. The main coping strategies available to these countries are sisyphean cycles of lockdowns and easing. These buy governments time and reduce the pressure on limited healthcare facilities, but they ravage the economy in the process. In poorer countries where state support is limited, lockdowns can be as deadly as the virus itself, because they remove people’s ability to make a living.

The outcome is not only sporadic flare-ups or confined challenges, but an entire population trapped by and condemned to live with the virus. The best-case scenario is that governments are able to contain a high peak of cases through lockdowns, while lives and livelihoods are lost to economic restrictions. The worst is the kind of explosion we are seeing in India. Some observers estimate that the virus will kill more people in 2021 than it did in 2020.

Which brings us to what can and should be done. That the pandemic is not playing out in poorer countries with the same virulence we saw in western countries does not mean there aren’t slow and deadly fires smouldering, which could yet grow into an inferno. There is a delay built into our responses to Covid-19, both at home and abroad. As western governments learned from the first wave, by the time the heavy death tolls are upon us, it is already too late. By the time the world had seen the images from India showing mass cremations, the country was already embroiled in a crisis. Those images prompted Joe Biden to reverse his position and pledge to send a “whole series of help”. I’d wager that if the world had been exposed to similar images from other countries, it would have become untenable for the west to maintain vaccine apartheid.

But we shouldn’t have to wait for images like those to spur action. What is required is something far more ambitious than vaccine donations. The world needs a global logistical exercise, a sort of Marshall plan that would provide financial support, expert manpower and medical technology. In the US, Democratic senators, progressives, NGOs and an alliance of 175 former world leaders and Nobel laureates have come together to apply pressure on Biden to waive intellectual-property protections on vaccines. As the virus recedes in the west, now is the time to apply this kind of pressure on leaders to deliver the south from its almost certain fate. By the time the real numbers of deaths and infections in poorer countries become clear, it will be far too late for many people.

• Nesrine Malik is a Guardian columnist


Nesrine Malik

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on Covid-19 worldwide: on the march
Infections are accelerating in largely untouched countries and those which hoped they had come through the worst. But there is hope


12, Jul, 2020 @5:04 PM

Article image
This virus is ravaging rich countries. What happens when it hits the poor ones? | Nesrine Malik
Horror over the west’s failure to contain Covid-19 will pale by comparison if it sweeps the developing world, says Guardian columnist Nesrine Malik

Nesrine Malik

23, Mar, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
A new Covid variant is no surprise when rich countries are hoarding vaccines | Gordon Brown
Western countries are destroying surplus vaccines while the poorest nations go without. This must change, says Gordon Brown, the WHO’s ambassador for global health financing

Gordon Brown

26, Nov, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
Modi's Covid-19 policies make clear that in India some lives matter more than others | Jayati Ghosh
Draconian government responses to the pandemic have merely served to widen India’s divides, says economist Jayati Ghosh

Jayati Ghosh

29, Jul, 2020 @12:09 PM

Article image
In rich countries, vaccines are making Covid-19 a manageable health issue | Devi Sridhar
For the UK the pandemic’s end is in sight, but less fortunate parts of the world urgently need help, says academic Devi Sridhar

Devi Sridhar

31, May, 2021 @12:54 PM

Article image
Covid jingoism will not protect the west from the threat of Omicron | Nesrine Malik
It has been proved time and again that there’s more to tackling the pandemic than shutting out the rest of the world, says Guardian columnist Nesrine Malik

Nesrine Malik

06, Dec, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Covid and the world: the pandemic’s impact is growing | Editorial
Editorial: Cases are soaring in many countries, and the social and political effects are becoming clearer


18, Jul, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
The UK and the US need to learn from countries that better handled Covid-19 | Laura Spinney
Vietnam’s 2003 Sars epidemic and Senegal’s 2014 Ebola outbreak informed their fast and effective responses, says science writer Laura Spinney

Laura Spinney

29, Dec, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
‘Will we die of hunger?’: how Covid-19 lockdowns imperil street children
For millions of young people, coronavirus restrictions have made access to food, water and shelter even more precarious

Jo Griffin

15, Apr, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
The latest figures are a wake-up call: the global Covid-19 crisis isn't close to over | Adam Tooze
A coordinated response to the crisis in the Americas, India and Africa must be led by countries that have suppressed the virus, says Adam Tooze, a professor of history at Columbia University

Adam Tooze

30, Jun, 2020 @7:00 AM