The Guardian view on lobbying: say yes to tougher rules | Editorial

Public trust is damaged when a former PM and ministers are caught up in a cronyism scandal, and must be repaired

Ministers will wait until the final version of a report on lobbying is published before announcing which of its recommendations they plan to accept. Given the damage caused by the close involvement of a former prime minister, David Cameron, in the Greensill lobbying scandal, and the fact that ministers have now been defeated twice in court over the improper award of contracts, the delay is an unwise as it is unsurprising.

By far the best course for the prime minister would be to indicate now that he will do as Lord Evans, chair of the committee on standards in public life (and a former head of MI5), advises. The measures are hardly revolutionary. A ban on ministers and senior civil servants lobbying for five years after leaving office makes sense. So does the suggestion that the public appointments watchdog should get new powers, including the right to prevent ministers taking certain jobs. Given the pace of change in institutions, the current two-year prohibition on lobbying is too short, making it likely that ministers will end up trying to influence former colleagues. There clearly are circumstances in which a rapid move from government to a particular private-sector role would not be appropriate. The proposal for new penalties for rule-breakers is logical too: if rules are to be treated seriously, infractions must be punished.

Lord Evans’s comments on the appointment of non-executive directors to government departments are also judicious. While some ministers clearly relish the opportunity to bring in allies and experts whom they know, the pitfalls of systems that rely on patronage and cronyism are well established. They include a tendency towards groupthink and sycophancy, and a lack of diversity. Releasing lobbying details every four weeks, instead of quarterly, also seems fair. The public, and parliamentarians, should know as much as possible about who is seeking to influence their representatives.

Lobbying is part of how liberal democracy works. Civil society organisations and charities do it when they sign politicians up to campaigns and pledges. Members of the public do it when they approach MPs and others about issues that matter to them. But such contacts need to be conducted in a way that is open, transparent and accountable.

This is even more important where corporate lobbyists wielding significant economic power are concerned. It is wrong for relationships to develop between politicians and businesses that could lead to private interests being placed before the public one. It fosters cynicism and undermines public trust when a former Tory prime minister is revealed to have bombarded ministers with messages on behalf of a company in which he was closely involved. It is extremely concerning that one of the UK’s most successful civil servants, Jeremy Heywood, was also a key figure in the Greensill drama. Gone for now at least are the days when the civil service was thought to be above such goings-on.

Inevitably, the pandemic has overshadowed a great deal. But with two cabinet ministers found to have broken the law, and the reputations of a former PM and cabinet secretary badly damaged, introducing tough new rules is the least that Boris Johnson ought to do.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on David Cameron’s lobbying: a cynical defence won’t wash | Editorial
Editorial: Lobbying law needs updating because the government is run by people who know the price of everything and the value of nothing


16, May, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on David Cameron and Greensill Capital: questions to answer | Editorial
Editorial: The former prime minister’s texts for a financial firm leave him a diminished figure


29, Mar, 2021 @5:48 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Tory party funding: shine the light | Editorial
Editorial: It is time to let the sunlight on to the latest allegations of cash for access and rewards under Boris Johnson


05, Aug, 2021 @5:25 PM

Article image
Lobbying scandal reveals a civil service in decline | Letters
Letters: The apparent erosion of civil service standards worries Simon Higman and Greg Conway, while James Lindesay and Alex McMullen suggest ways of restoring faith in public servants


19, Apr, 2021 @3:42 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Tory turbulence: a problem of substance not style | Editorial
Editorial: Conservatives who now complain about Boris Johnson’s failings knew all of his weaknesses when they chose him as their leader


24, Nov, 2021 @6:43 PM

Article image
This is Tory sleaze. Don’t let Boris Johnson convince you otherwise | Jonathan Freedland
The Greensill revelations fit a pattern of Conservative cronyism. Labour should fight it hard, says Guardian columnist Jonathan Freedland

Jonathan Freedland

16, Apr, 2021 @3:27 PM

Article image
Cameron's clever defence: that he can't do a proper job after leaving office either | Marina Hyde
His plea over the Greensill scandal seems to be that he’s a standup guy made to look like a chancer by a spellchecker, says Guardian columnist Marina Hyde

Marina Hyde

14, May, 2021 @12:17 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Cameron inquiry: democracy versus chumocracy | Editorial
Editorial: The Greensill affair is undermining public trust in politics. The forthcoming investigation has a responsibility to help restore it


13, Apr, 2021 @5:57 PM

Article image
Head of UK lobbying watchdog calls for tougher disclosure rules
Exclusive: Harry Rich says transparency would be easier if lobbyists reveal which ministers they speak to

Rowena Mason Whitehall editor

26, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on online politics: transparency is essential | Editorial
Editorial: Democracy needs strengthening when parties are replaced by opaque lobby groups in an age of social media


05, Apr, 2019 @5:25 PM