Xi’s change of heart is too late to stop China’s collision with the west | Simon Tisdall

The Chinese president’s conciliatory speech rings hollow in the face of his brutal policies

Is it too late to halt the slide towards all-out confrontation between China and the western democracies? An apparently conciliatory speech last week by Xi Jinping led some observers to suggest China’s president may want to mend fences. But a change of tone in Beijing will not cut much ice in Washington unless Xi’s aggressive policies change, too.

Since coming to power in 2012, Xi has overseen a marked shift towards authoritarianism at home and increased “assertiveness” – a polite word for bullying – abroad. He has established the type of personal, almost cultish dominance over the Chinese Communist party not seen since the days of Mao Zedong.

So when Xi talks, as he did last week, about the need for arrogant CCP spokespeople and the country’s antagonistic “wolf warrior” diplomats to present a more “lovable” and “humble” image of China to the world, he is really critiquing himself and his own management style.

Yet Xi has never had to woo ordinary voters. He has purged all serious rivals. He lauds uniformity and exhibits a hatred of “difference”, as cruelly manifested in Xinjiang. He rules by fear, political cunning and brute force. Love has nothing to do with it.

Looked at another way, Xi’s speech would not have been out of place at a Militant tendency meeting circa 1976 or, for that matter, in the old Soviet politburo. Like hard-left politicians and neo-Marxists everywhere, Xi believes it’s not his policies that are at fault but a failure to explain and communicate them effectively.

China must expand its “circle of friends”, he said. “Propaganda organisations” (meaning state media) must make clear to all that the CCP wanted “nothing but the Chinese people’s happiness and good fortune”. Does he really believe people will swallow such tosh? Coming from a man dedicated to supplanting the US as global hegemon, his words suggest startling naivety about the world beyond China or else a shocking cynicism.

Extensive state-directed, under-the-radar schemes to “tell China’s story” and expand its influence are in any case already in train, according to the National Endowment for Democracy in Washington. “Over the past decade, the CCP has overseen a dramatic expansion of efforts to shape media content around the world,” it said, even as the CCP stifles critical independent coverage.

Using propaganda, disinformation and censorship, “Beijing has insinuated its content ... into foreign media markets in many subtle ways, for example, through content-sharing agreements ... Hundreds of millions of news consumers around the world routinely view, read, or listen to information created or influenced by the CCP, often without knowing its origins.”

Xi’s image-massaging and media manipulation went a drastic step further last week as Beijing suppressed coverage of the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre anniversary. Hong Kong media were told not to mention it. An annual vigil for victims was banned amid yet more arrests. The record of the CCP’s historical culpability over Tiananmen was wiped. Yet today’s crushing of Hong Kong’s freedoms is a very public crime that Xi cannot airbrush away. Lovable it ain’t.

Blatant and loveless, too, is the siege of Taiwan, where Chinese military forces regularly launch high-profile, provocative territorial incursions. Like a latter-day emperor, Xi sees reunification as the crowning achievement of his reign. The west’s shameful failure to defend Hong Kong emboldens him, and fears grow that he may soon resort to force. Taiwan could yet become America’s Falklands.

All around China’s borders, from India and South Korea to Malaysia, the Philippines and Australia, a grim story of intimidation, impunity and aggression is unfolding, as opposed to the confected, made-in-Beijing narrative of neighbourly co-existence. The list of western grievances with Xi’s China, often spilling over into undisguised anger, grows longer almost by the day. The problem now – assuming Xi really is having second thoughts – is that it may already be too late. A tipping point has been reached. Tolerance for Chinese boorishness is all but exhausted.

Xi may not be able to alter course even if he wants to. For almost a decade, he has unleashed wave after wave of what analyst Sulmaan Wasif Khan calls “belligerent, defensive nationalism” – political, economic and military. China, he wrote, “has poisoned itself through its own rhetoric ... As the US discovered in the Donald Trump years, one cannot stoke nationalistic fires without their eventually blazing beyond control.”

A reckoning is due. US president Joe Biden has stuck to his predecessor’s tough line, and is steadily reinforcing it. This coming weekend’s G7 summit will back him up. The Quad – an alliance of the US, Japan, India and Australia – is reviving. Defence spending is rising, on both sides. New weapons, including nuclear, come on stream. Britain, following other Nato powers, has sent a naval battlegroup to the South China Sea.

Punitive sanctions multiply, noisy diplomatic clashes and trade disputes escalate, mutual recriminations abound. And now, having previously dismissed it is as a Trumpian conspiracy hoax, Biden has ordered a fast-track investigation into the theory that Covid-19 leaked from a secret laboratory in Wuhan and Xi covered it up.

Biden’s action is legitimate, epidemiologically speaking. But it is also unmistakably political. Seen from Beijing, it looks like an overtly hostile act, even a trap, that potentially undoes all the efforts to portray China as a benign global superpower. For Xi and his legacy, the threat posed by the “Wuhan virus” story is existential.

Xi is making nice as the CCP prepares to mark its centenary next month. But it won’t last, because nothing has fundamentally changed. Attitudes in the west are hardening. And Xi is not afraid of a fight. However he spins it, the slide towards confrontation appears inexorable.


Simon Tisdall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
China’s reckless ambition could be the biggest threat to a Biden victory
Donald Trump accuses his rival of being soft on China. If a crisis erupted over Taiwan he is not above exploiting it electorally

Simon Tisdall

11, Oct, 2020 @5:45 AM

Article image
Joe Biden has picked a fight with tyranny. The west must hope he wins | Simon Tisdall
To counter the influence of Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, the US-led alliance has to show that freedom is worth fighting for

Simon Tisdall

04, Sep, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
It’s not only Britain. West needs honest, trustworthy leaders to deter autocrats | Simon Tisdall
A showdown is looming with Russia and China, but public confidence and belief in democratic institutions is waning, says Observer columnist Simon Tisdall

Simon Tisdall

10, Jul, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Weak, divided, incompetent... the west is unfit to challenge Xi’s bid for global hegemony
With its crackdown on Hong Kong and aggression against those who get in its way, China has no fear of making enemies

Simon Tisdall

05, Jul, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
What happens if Putin goes nuclear in Ukraine? Biden has a choice to make
Russian forces are in retreat yet Nato still holds back for fear of what a humiliated Putin might do. But now is precisely the time to step up the pressure

Simon Tisdall

17, Sep, 2022 @2:25 PM

Article image
Making waves in the Pacific: how Boris Johnson’s Global Britain went rogue
Defence pact with Australia and the US increases chance of confrontation with China and spurs nuclear proliferation

Simon Tisdall

19, Sep, 2021 @6:30 AM

Article image
How to rein in China without risking war is the issue Biden must address
The US leader has taken a tough line with president Xi Jinping, raising concerns about trade, Taiwan, Hong Kong and alleged genocide in Xinjiang

Simon Tisdall

14, Feb, 2021 @6:15 AM

Article image
Tunisia shows that democracy will struggle if it can’t deliver prosperity
Political liberty has been overturned – with majority support. That will delight authoritarians everywhere

Simon Tisdall

01, Aug, 2021 @7:30 AM

Article image
Biden races to unite allies against China knowing sooner or later an explosion will occur
US president is being much tougher than expected on Beijing, but a lack of solidarity will undermine his policy’s success

Simon Tisdall

25, Jul, 2021 @5:30 AM

Article image
The world still needs a policeman. Let’s hope the US doesn’t quit the job | Simon Tisdall
America’s record at keeping global order is deeply flawed, but the only winners from its drift towards isolationism will be Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin

Simon Tisdall

26, Mar, 2023 @7:00 AM