The Guardian view on levelling up: not Johnson’s idea but Thatcher’s | Editorial

After Covid-19, the prime minister risks being exposed for what he is: a shameless bluffer who says what he wants to, without considering the truth

In the British cult comedy movie Monty Python’s Life of Brian there is a row between members of the People’s Front of Judea over “what have the Romans ever done for us?”. While the characters initially castigate the imperium, it quickly dawns on them that the Romans have done quite a few good things: such as aqueducts, sanitation, roads. The question for voters at the next election will be what Boris Johnson’s government has done for them and what Labour is going to do if it gets elected. Mr Johnson’s election promises were immodest: he was going to “level up the country” after securing Brexit. Expectations were set very high. It’s not clear that the prime minister can meet them.

“Levelling up” contains hope and grievance. The phrase suggests it’s time to stop treating poorer areas less well than richer ones. Mr Johnson claimed he would “level up” Britain and “answer the plea of the forgotten people and the left-behind towns”. He wants to tap into an egalitarian zeitgeist. In fact, he is echoing Margaret Thatcher whose 1976 Tory party said it “believe(s) in levelling up, in enhancing opportunities, not in levelling down, which dries up the springs of enterprise and endeavour … ”. This is what Mr Johnson means but cannot say because polling suggests a widespread distrust of business and capitalism.

Instead, the Conservatives cloak their true intent in the language of empowering government, tackling inequality and the devolution of power. But judge ministers by their acts, not their words. Whitehall moves jobs out to the regions but its key executive staff remain in London. The government’s school funding formula has moved funds from deprived to wealthier areas. People are losing control over the things that matter to them. Ministers want to run the English NHS. This is a terrible idea.

Mr Johnson’s plans will have little impact on regional inequality. His priority is to reward those who vote Conservative and squash those who don’t. A decade of Tory austerity has cut council budgets by £15bn, with Labour-controlled authorities hit hard. This is far more than the £9bn pledged in Downing Street-driven beauty contests that, via a levelling-up fund and a towns fund, seem to do little more than reward areas that elect Conservative MPs. It’s so rotten that Hartlepool landed £25m just weeks after it elected a Tory MP for the first time. Pledging is easier than delivering. Labour says only 5% of the money committed so far has been paid out. Corrosive pork-barrel politics has not stopped councils from going bankrupt. This is also a mechanism to bypass political opponents in the nations outside England. Cash is allocated on the basis of “needs”, but the assessment of what constitutes “need” is decided in London without consultation with the devolved governments.

Mr Johnson does not say what he means because it would be unpopular. Instead he’s relying on the fact that parliamentary checks and balances can be ignored with little consequence. Using the state machinery “to buy votes” is bad for Britain. It might also be popular while no one notices the gap between reality and rhetoric. That will be harder to sustain as policies materialise which prioritise corporations over people. No amount of spin justifies Mr Johnson’s claim that drowning mature students in debt to pay for adult education will be “rocket fuel” for the levelling-up agenda.

Covid-19 is the kind of crash that opens voters’ eyes. Mr Johnson’s planning reforms contributed to his stunning byelection loss last month. Electors rightly thought they undermined local authorities and gave too much power to private developers. Mr Johnson risks being exposed for what he is: a shameless bluffer who says what he wants to, without considering the truth. For Britain’s sake, it couldn’t happen soon enough.

Contributor

Editorial

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on calls for a second lockdown: yes, prime minister | Editorial
Editorial: It is impossible to have confidence in the government’s decision to overrule scientific advice

Editorial

13, Oct, 2020 @6:44 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Covid failures: PM eroded trust when he needed it most | Editorial
Editorial: Boris Johnson’s inept handling of the pandemic has risked undermining his claim to level up the country’s poorest regions and forced him to ask local leaders for help

Editorial

12, Oct, 2020 @6:31 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on political trust: voters put store by it, the PM does not | Editorial
Editorial: The prime minister wants no one in his cabinet to pay for their mistakes, a strategy that has failed

Editorial

28, Jun, 2021 @6:09 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the floods: global heating and British soaking | Editorial
Editorial: The drama and loss of recent days should focus minds on the urgent necessity of climate adaptation

Editorial

12, Nov, 2019 @6:26 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Boris Johnson’s ‘levelling up’: there’s no quick fix | Editorial
Editorial: The flaw at the heart of the prime minister’s policies is that Britain’s unequal economy is a product of Conservative thinking which remains fundamentally unchanged

Editorial

11, Feb, 2020 @6:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on a Brexit deal: this is going to hurt | Editorial
Editorial: Brexit reveals the government’s ideological commitment to take the country back to where Margaret Thatcher left it

Editorial

07, Dec, 2020 @7:20 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on delayed elections: make democracy a priority | Editorial
Editorial: By loosening restrictions on shopping while saying nothing about voting in England, ministers are sending the wrong signal

Editorial

21, Jun, 2020 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on local elections: national lessons for Brexit | Editorial
Editorial: The failure of Britain’s gridlocked politics has found expression in the rise of smaller parties and large swathes of the country where no one party can run local governments. This will further disrupt our broken politics

Editorial

03, May, 2019 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on rail cuts: levelling down not up | Editorial
Editorial: Boris Johnson is losing his nerve about capital infrastructure. It is a reality check about his airy promises

Editorial

18, Nov, 2021 @7:15 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Liberal Democrats: seeing and shaping politics | Editorial
Editorial: Clearly the death of Liberal England has been prematurely foretold, but more will be needed to turn a stunning byelection win into a successful revival

Editorial

18, Jun, 2021 @5:11 PM