Phil Spector wasn't a 'flawed genius' – he was a murderer | Arwa Mahdawi

Despite the headlines we have seen from Rolling Stone, the BBC and others, the producer was, first and foremost, a killer. We should hold him to the same standards as everyone else

Isn’t it tragic when a bit of murder mars a man’s career? Rolling Stone certainly seems to think so. “Phil Spector, the famed ‘wall of sound’ producer and architect of some of pop music’s most enduring songs, whose legacy was marred by a murder conviction, has died …” it tweeted on Sunday.

As news of Spector’s death from coronavirus complications broke, Rolling Stone wasn’t alone in seemingly prioritising the producer’s legacy over the life of Lana Clarkson, the 40-year-old woman he was convicted of shooting dead in 2003. The BBC, for example, initially tweeted: “Talented but flawed Producer Phil Spector dies aged 81.” (It then deleted the tweet.) Flawed? Are you kidding? Being messy is a flaw; being a murderer is something else entirely.

Still, at least the BBC mentioned Spector’s fatal “flaw”. CNN tweeted: “Grammy-winning music producer Phil Spector dies of natural causes,” before deleting and revising the headline. Reuters’ tweet mentioned Spector’s murder conviction, but made it seem like an inconvenient afterthought: “Influential rock producer Phil Spector, who changed pop music and was convicted of killing actress Lana Clarkson, died at the age of 81.”

Tweets and headlines don’t lend themselves to nuance; even with the best intentions, they can easily sound flippant or facile. However, the examples above aren’t just illustrations of poor phrasing. They’re a reflection of how a man’s “genius” is often viewed as more important than a woman’s humanity. Numerous studies show that the idea of genius is gendered; one 2015 study found 90% of Americans believe geniuses tend to be men. And male genius is romanticised, used to excuse all manner of bad behaviour. We don’t hold geniuses to the same standards we hold mere mortals. They’re always “complicated” or “tortured”; they’re never just “bad”.

I’m not disputing Spector’s work had an important impact on pop culture. However, the question we should all be asking ourselves is what part of his legacy matters most: the music or the murder? Does his career matter more than the life, and ambitions, he cut short? Perhaps we should use Spector’s death as an opportunity to inspect our own biases.

• Arwa Mahdawi is a Guardian columnist


Arwa Mahdawi

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Phil Spector murder victim's mother settles civil case
Donna Clarkson, mother of Lana who was shot by music producer in 2003, says she is 'relieved' legal action is over

Damien Pearse and agencies

04, Feb, 2012 @5:28 PM

Article image
Phil Spector appeal rejected by US supreme court

The music producer's conviction for the murder of Lana Clarkson in 2003 will not be overturned after court refuses to hear appeal

Sean Michaels

22, Feb, 2012 @11:21 AM

Phil Spector and the wall of charges
After four years of denials, claims and bizarre court appearances, legendary producer faces murder trial.

Dan Glaister in Los Angeles

17, Mar, 2007 @12:24 AM

Article image
Phil Spector obituary
Record producer influential in 60s pop as the creator of the ‘wall of sound’ who in 2009 was jailed for the murder of Lana Clarkson

Richard Williams

17, Jan, 2021 @7:52 PM

Phil Spector indicted for actor's murder
Record producer Phil Spector pleaded not guilty to murder yesterday and lambasted prosecutors as "Hitler-like" after he was indicted in connection with the death of an actor in his home last year.

Dan Glaister in Los Angeles

28, Sep, 2004 @10:47 AM

Richard Williams on the other side of Phil Spector
Phil Spector biographer Richard Williams remembers the producer as an insecure genius worshipped by John Lennon

Richard Williams

14, Apr, 2009 @1:05 AM

Jury selected in Phil Spector murder trial

Proceedings begin Monday: County employees, two engineers and a network TV producer will decide whether the music producer killed actress Lana Clarkson at his LA mansion.

Rosie Swash

20, Apr, 2007 @12:58 PM

Article image
Phil Spector, pop producer convicted of murder, dies aged 81
Producer who revolutionised music in 1960s with his ‘wall of sound’ dies while serving sentence

Caroline Davies

17, Jan, 2021 @4:32 PM

Article image
Music producer Phil Spector convicted of murdering actor Lana Clarkson

Lawyers say Phil Spector will appeal as Los Angeles jury passes guilty verdict after nine days of deliberations

Dan Glaister in Los Angeles and Chris McGreal

14, Apr, 2009 @7:52 AM

Article image
Phil Spector
Born Harvey Phillip Spector on December 26 1939 in the Bronx, the son of a seamstress and a steelworker.

15, Mar, 2007 @11:56 PM