Muslim leaders should be questioned like anybody else | Kenan Malik

Protests about the Woman’s Hour interview with Zara Mohammed ignore the fact that Emma Barnett’s no-nonsense style is unwavering

The new leader of a high-profile organisation gets grilled by a go-get-’em journalist. Not exactly an unusual event. But Emma Barnett’s interview of Zara Mohammed, the newly elected leader of the Muslim Council of Britain (and its first female leader) on Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour has caused ripples.

A hundred public figures (including former Tory cabinet minister Sayeeda Warsi, Labour MP Diane Abbott and union leader Jo Grady) signed an open letter to the BBC deploring the “strikingly hostile” tone of the interview. “Most of Mohammed’s answers,” they note, “were interrupted, revealing an instinctive urge not to listen to the voice of a Muslim woman.” The interview was akin to the grilling of a politician “rather than authentically recognising and engaging in what this represented for British Muslim women”.

Barnett is an abrasive interviewer, openly contemptuous of waffle and given to interrupting. Personally, I can find her style irritating, and not always useful in elucidating an issue, but I also think it better to have journalists willing to challenge interviewees than take answers at face value.

Barnett has brought that style to Woman’s Hour too. One can argue over whether that’s a good thing. What is unacceptable, though, is the suggestion that Barnett should have made an exception for a Muslim woman. Her interruptions of Mohammed revealed a willingness to subject all her interviewees to the same treatment. That, surely, is what we should demand. To insist that Muslim leaders should not be subject to the same harsh questioning as anyone else is hardly an argument for equal treatment.

  • Kenan Malik is an Observer columnist


Kenan Malik

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Thought for the day: is it time to silence BBC preachers who keep women down? | Catherine Bennett
Too often, the flagship radio programme is being used as a pulpit for illiberal views

Catherine Bennett

02, Mar, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
We put our shirt on French holiday roulette and the wheel stopped on... amber | Rachel Cooke
It’s been a white-knuckle ride, but we’re finally off to France subject to our Covid ‘declaration of honour’

Rachel Cooke

07, Aug, 2021 @4:27 PM

Article image
Don’t damn critics – we do have our uses, honest | Alex Clark
We highlight hidden treasures and encourage the arts to flourish

Alex Clark

29, Jul, 2017 @11:05 PM

Article image
Don’t blame Today for the world’s ills | Letters
Sarah Sands, editor of Today, defends the flagship Radio 4 news programme against accusations that it is losing its way

08, Jul, 2018 @4:59 AM

Article image
Is the rise of the unscientific vox pop a fresh take on news or just plain laziness? | Catherine Bennett
Broadcasting random comments from ‘the people’ is no substitute for real news-gathering

Catherine Bennett

29, Sep, 2019 @6:30 AM

Article image
Prince Harry a breath of fresh air? No, a chip off the old block | Catherine Bennett
His offensive gaffe on Today about Meghan Markle’s family revealed he has much in common with his father

Catherine Bennett

31, Dec, 2017 @12:04 AM

Article image
Tories deny Lady Warsi questioned morals of Muslim MPs
Conservatives say comments by shadow cohesion minister Sayeeda Warsi were made in Urdu and have been misinterpreted

Haroon Siddique

05, May, 2010 @5:19 PM

Article image
The Observer view on Steve Hewlett
The master storyteller who touched us all with his life’s final chapter

Observer editorial

26, Feb, 2017 @12:05 AM

Article image
If we can't rely on its honesty, there really is no point to confessional journalism | Catherine Bennett
A less noted victim of the Cummings saga is writing whose virtue is meant to be candour

Catherine Bennett

06, Jun, 2020 @6:00 PM

Article image
The Observer view on Islamophobia in the Conservative party | Observer editorial
The Tories must launch an independent inquiry into anti-Muslim prejudice in the party

Observer editorial

03, Jun, 2018 @5:00 AM