Republicans threaten our children’s freedom as well as their basic safety | Robert Reich

Attacks on mask mandates expose children to Covid. Attacks on the teaching of history expose them to dangerous ignorance

My granddaughter will go to school next week. So may your child or grandchild. For many, it will be their first time back in classrooms in a year and a half.

What do we want for these young people? At least three things.

First and most obviously, to learn the verbal, mathematical and other thinking tools they’ll need to successfully navigate the world.

But that’s not all. We also want them to become responsible citizens. This means, among other things, becoming aware of the noble aspects of our history as well as the shameful aspects, so they grow into adults who can intelligently participate in our democracy.

Yet some Republican lawmakers don’t want our children to have the whole picture.

Over the last few months, some 26 states have curbed how teachers discuss America’s racist past. Some of these restrictions impose penalties on teachers and administrators who violate them, including the loss of licenses and fines. Many curbs take effect next week.

These legislators prefer that our children learn only the sanitized, vanilla version of America, as if ignorance will make them better citizens.

Why should learning the truth be a politically partisan issue?

The third thing we want for our children and grandchildren heading back to school is even more basic. We want them to be safe.

Yet even as the number of American children hospitalized with Covid-19 has hit a record high, some Republican lawmakers don’t want them to wear masks in school to protect themselves and others.

The governors of Texas and Florida, where Covid is surging, have sought to prohibit school districts from requiring masks. Lawmakers in Kentucky, also experiencing a surge, have repudiated a statewide school mask mandate.

Why should the simple precaution of wearing a mask be a politically partisan issue?

Paradoxically, many of these same Republican lawmakers want people to have easy access to guns, even though school shootings have become tragically predictable.

Between last March and the end of the school year in June – despite most elementary, middle and high schools being partially or entirely closed due to the pandemic – there were 14 school shootings, the highest total over that period since at least 1999.

Since the massacre 22 years ago at Columbine high school near Denver, more than a quarter of a million children have been exposed to gun violence during school hours.

How can lawmakers justify preventing children from masking up against Covid while allowing almost anyone to buy a gun?

The answer to all of this, I think, is a warped sense of the meaning of freedom.

These lawmakers – and many of the people they represent – equate “freedom” with being allowed to go without a mask and to own a gun, while also being ignorant of the shameful aspects of America.

To them, personal freedom means taking no responsibility.

Yet this definition of freedom is precisely the opposite lesson our children and grandchildren need. To be truly free is to learn to be responsible for knowing the truth even if it’s sometimes painful, and responsible for the health and safety of others even if it’s sometimes inconvenient.

The duty to help our children become responsible adults falls mainly on us as parents and grandparents. But our children also need schools that teach and practice the same lessons.

America’s children shouldn’t be held hostage to a partisan political brawl. It’s time we focused solely on their learning and their safety.


Robert Reich

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Leading Republicans' states among worst hit by jobless benefits cuts

Analysis shows rolling cuts to unemployment benefits will severely hurt constituencies of prominent GOP leaders

Paul Lewis in Washington and Kenan Davis in New York

04, Jan, 2014 @7:47 PM

Article image
Texas Republican hypocrisy over federal aid is nothing new – ask Flyin' Ted Cruz | Lloyd Green
After Hurricane Sandy, the senator opposed relief for New York and New Jersey. It’s one rule for Texas, another for the rest of us

Lloyd Green

22, Feb, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Trump stays on immigration offensive as Democrats seek answers on reunions
President seeks to blame separations on Obama and Bush while Democrats question mechanism for bringing families back together

David Smith in Washington and Jessica Glenza in New York

23, Jun, 2018 @9:57 PM

Article image
Why Republicans won’t agree to Biden’s big plans and why he should ignore them | Robert Reich
The new president can achieve huge and vital reform and relief without the party of Trump – and they know it

Robert Reich

31, Jan, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Republicans have taken up the politics of bigotry, putting US democracy at risk | Robert Reich
There is no ‘surge’ of migrants at the border and there is no huge voter fraud problem – there is only hard-right attack

Robert Reich

28, Mar, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Rand Paul as president? Not likely | Ana Marie Cox

Ana Marie Cox: Senator Paul is making all the running on the Republicans' libertarian right. Suppose he ran all the way to the White House

Ana Marie Cox

27, Sep, 2013 @12:45 PM

Article image
It’s not all about the culture war – Democrats helped shaft the working class | Robert Reich
Results in Virginia and New Jersey do not make Republican dog-whistle politics the future. The left must do more to help

Robert Reich

07, Nov, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
The first 100 days of Biden were also the first 100 without Trump – that’s telling | Robert Reich
The new president is benefiting not just from bold proposals and actions but from his predecessor’s catastrophic record

Robert Reich

02, May, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
While Delta spreads, Republicans deflect and resort to Trump demagoguery | Robert Reich
The blame game must stop. The best way to contain deaths and hospitalizations from Covid is to get more Americans vaccinated

Robert Reich

08, Aug, 2021 @12:36 PM

Article image
If Republicans lose the healthcare fight, it's the beginning of the end | Corey Robin
The right has had its spells in the wilderness, where they’ve been exiled from power. If they lose this bill, it will put them on that road to despair

Corey Robin

28, Jun, 2017 @4:17 PM