Cummings should not be forgotten: Labour has to learn what he got right | Julian Coman

Boris Johnson’s former aide understood the class dynamics of modern England. To regain the red wall, the left must too

In the midst of bleak, autumnal lockdown, a sudden sense of liberal optimism is in the air. Joe Biden has defeated Donald Trump in the US presidential election, and Boris Johnson’s bullying grand vizier, Dominic Cummings, has been ejected from Downing Street. There are briefings that a politics of civility and decency is returning to Westminster.

Is November 2020 to be the month in which the culture wars that began in 2016 finally begin to burn out, and 2021 the year in which the successful rollout of a Covid-19 vaccine unites a formerly divided country? The former chancellor George Osborne greeted Biden’s victory by tweeting: “Whether you’re on the left or right: moderation, integrity, seriousness and the mainstream are back.” Coming from the chancellor who introduced a decade of austerity, this should give pause for thought.

The winners of last week’s No 10 power struggle appear to be plotting something akin to a Cameroonian restoration. It is no doubt true that Johnson had grown tired of the aggression and arrogance with which Cummings and his sidekick, Lee Cain, prosecuted their internal battles. Their contemptuous treatment of Conservative MPs was stoking fires of rebellion on the Tory backbenches. But the principal motive for ordering Cummings to pack his cardboard box last Friday was surely that Johnson simply agrees with his new spokeswoman, Allegra Stratton, and his fiancee, Carrie Symonds: the time has come to shift shape once more.

With the Brexit transition period coming to an end and Biden heading for the White House, a new “Boris” – or rather an updated version of an old one – is required for 2021 and beyond. The unlikely tribune of the northern working class is to be replaced by the former mayor of London, a more liberal, environmentally friendly sort of chap.

The 10-point “build back green” plan, which Johnson is expected to unveil this week from his self-isolation, will put down a marker. At the Cop26 climate summit in Glasgow next year, the prime minister will burnish his internationalist credentials. A Brexit deal, assuming one is achieved, will see the UK positioned as ally and friend to both the European Union and Biden’s United States, as Trumpian disruption and overt nationalism is discreetly ditched. Tory politics will soon begin to look a little more like it did in the world before 2016. As Osborne put it recently, it is time for Johnson to “morph again, and head for the political centre”.

There are of, course, very good reasons to be relieved that the type of politics represented by Cummings appears to be in retreat. A Labour party statement, identifying a legacy of “bullying, deception, hypocrisy and hubris”, nailed some of them. Not surprisingly, the humiliatingly abrupt manner of Cummings’ exit also unleashed a wave of euphoria among those scarred by the Brexit battles of the last four years. Yet the left should have no truck with this restoration politics. There is a deeper and different significance to last week’s events, which Labour must not miss as the champagne emojis begin to disappear from Twitter timelines.

The association of Brexit with a reassertion of the values of working-class communities, neglected for decades, led eventually to the fall of the “red wall” seats last December. For Labour, the need to prevent that collapse becoming a historic realignment is existential. The sudden end of the Cummings era signals an opportunity, but it can be grasped only by acting on what he got right.

Cummings’ rise to an extraordinary level of power and influence was achieved through a combination of two insights. The first was that past Conservative governments had given people good grounds to believe that Tory MPs cared little about those in poverty or the NHS. The second was that, in swaths of Labour-voting England, particularly in the post-industrial north and Midlands, there was a deep nostalgia for a lost politics of solidarity – which was partly why the NHS had become so totemic.

As early as 2004, during the referendum campaign on a proposed north-east assembly, Cummings was successfully mining that progressive nostalgia, and putting it to work in the interests of a nascent populist right. His slogan of that time, “More doctors, not politicians”, became the precursor to Vote Leave’s “£350m for the NHS”. Cummings rerouted a desire to bolster the fraying social fabric within communities and deployed it against the disinterested “elites” of Westminster and Brussels.

It was cynical and manipulative, but it helped Cummings and his Vote Leave faction develop an acute understanding of the class dynamics of 21st-century English politics. Which is why those Conservative commentators who fret over a possible return to the Tory “southern comfort zone” are right to be worried.

The signs are that the government’s coming pivot to “the centre” will be accompanied by a renewed emphasis on deregulation, low taxes and as small a state as can be managed, post-pandemic. Rishi Sunak, for whom Stratton worked before joining the No 10 team, is an orthodox economic liberal and a deficit hawk. Even before the Covid pandemic forced the Treasury to take on huge levels of debt, the chancellor was wary of a shock-and-awe “levelling up” investment programme for the north. There are reports that he is resisting pressure to offer generous long-term funding for a jobs-rich green recovery programme.

On the newly emboldened Conservative backbenches and in the cabinet, there will be fierce resistance to redistributive tax rises for the better off. Without them, and without a large-scale programme of state investment in the regions, red-wall constituencies may conclude they have been used and abused once again. A culture war will not cut it.

Meanwhile, Labour must resist the temptation to say “I told you so’, and learn the lessons of Vote Leave’s successes with humility. The errors of the late 90s and 2000s, which first let Cummings in, must not be repeated. Starmer has excelled in his lawyerly dissection of Johnson’s handling of the pandemic. This is his comfort zone. But with a vaccine on the horizon, a radical post-Covid vision for England beyond the south-east is needed.

Rethinking what northern nostalgia is truly about, and disentangling a residual memory of more cohesive, egalitarian times from the distortions of Brexit, would be a first step. The left should not stop thinking about Dominic Cummings just yet.

  • Julian Coman is a Guardian associate editor


Julian Coman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
If you can’t abide Jeremy Corbyn, learn from the moral of Ed Miliband | Aditya Chakrabortty
This time the stakes are even bigger, says Guardian columnist Aditya Chakrabortty

Aditya Chakrabortty

20, Aug, 2019 @5:29 PM

Article image
Dominic Cummings' war on the British civil service will undermine democracy | The civil servant
Neither the prime minister nor his enforcer want to hear the truth from civil servants like me

The civil servant

01, Aug, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Only a government of national unity can deliver us from no deal | Polly Toynbee
Let Margaret Beckett lead a ‘government’ to do what the crisis demands – call an election and a referendum, says Guardian columnist Polly Toynbee

Polly Toynbee

05, Aug, 2019 @4:36 PM

Article image
There is a path to a second referendum – and only Labour can win it | Tom Kibasi
This could be the time that, through the Brexit process, Labour finds its path to power, says the Institute for Public Policy Research director Tom Kibasi

Tom Kibasi

31, Dec, 2018 @3:47 PM

Article image
What Dominic Cummings said is true – the Tories don’t care about the NHS | Julie Ward
A no-deal Brexit will be grim for patients, says Labour MEP Julie Ward

Julie Ward

15, Aug, 2019 @9:00 AM

Article image
The only Brexit is a hard-right Tory one. Labour must back another vote | Chi Onwurah
If Labour enables Brexit, it will also enable a Tory bonfire of workers’ rights and environmental protections, says Labour MP Chi Onwurah

Chi Onwurah

07, May, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
What Labour can learn about Brexit from California: think twice | David Adler
Local left activists have realised that seceding would abandon the US to the right, says the writer David Adler

David Adler

24, Dec, 2018 @10:01 AM

Article image
After this staggering defeat for May, our country is left lost and adrift | Jonathan Freedland
A catalogue of errors led us to this point, says Guardian columnist Jonathan Freedland

Jonathan Freedland

15, Jan, 2019 @8:39 PM

Article image
Talks between Labour and the Tories on Brexit have broken down. So what next? | Tom Kibasi
With the country divided, a second referendum now seems the least worst way out, says IPPR director Tom Kibasi

Tom Kibasi

17, May, 2019 @9:52 AM

Article image
I’m Jewish and I’m voting Labour in the general election. Here’s why | Jonathan Lis
Yes, antisemitism exists in Labour. But we can tackle it and still elect a progressive government, writes Jonathan Lis of the thinktank British Influence

Jonathan Lis

22, Nov, 2019 @9:31 AM