The Guardian view on Mexico’s women’s strike: let the machistas tremble | Editorial

The cause of femicide and abuse is not just violent individuals, but the laws and societies that foster and allow their actions

Tens of thousands of women, perhaps many more, disappeared in Mexico on Monday. They vanished from the streets, from cafes, from shops and factories and offices. Their absence was a manifestation of their fury, a demonstration of how impoverished the country would be without them, and a symbolic representation of the women who are for ever missing from the country, having been murdered because they are women.

The homicide rate has risen sharply in recent years: more than 10 women a day are being killed. Two particularly horrific crimes have galvanised action. The first was the murder of 25-year-old Ingrid Escamilla last month, and the publication of pictures of her mutilated body by local media. The second, days later, was the abduction, torture and murder of a seven-year-old girl, Fátima Cecilia Aldrighett Antón.

But Monday’s women’s strike, and the mammoth demonstration that preceded it on Sunday, targeted not only the perpetrators, but authorities that have failed to tackle the violence. Mexico’s president, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, has shown at best indifference to the problem and at worst indignation that women are protesting against it. He has blamed femicides on the “neoliberal” policies of his predecessors, and portrayed feminist activism as part of a rightwing plot against him, suggesting that some of the campaigners want his administration to fail. Last month, when a reporter asked about femicides, he grumbled that he didn’t want the issue to overshadow his plans to raffle off the presidential plane.

The protest movement is much more than an expression of mourning for those denied their lives. It is a necessary social response to a social problem, in Mexico and around the globe (the UK too has seen a rise in female homicide victims). While the rate and patterns of violence vary immensely, nowhere is immune. “In rich and poor countries, in developed and developing regions, a total of 50,000 women per year are killed by their current and former partners, fathers, brothers, mothers, sisters and other family members because of their role and status as women,” a United Nations report found in 2018.

In Mexico and elsewhere, the problem of femicide, and the abuse of women more broadly, is not only a problem of violent men. It is also the problem of the laws and cultures that permit and reproduce them. The song A Rapist in Your Path, created by a Chilean feminist collective, has been taken up in countries from France to Kenya because when it urges “let the machistas tremble” it means not only perpetrators, but “the cops, the judges, the state, the president”. The UN report calls not only for better laws, but also better coordination between agencies. It urges countries to adopt approaches that are women-centred, rather than those that treat women as “objects of protection or sources of evidence”.

In reality, the wave of rightwing populism and authoritarianism around the world is harming women’s rights (and Amlo’s record suggests that left-leaning administrations do not always serve their interests better). In Russia, a 2017 law decriminalised domestic abuse if the incidents happened no more than once a year, and caused no lasting physical damage. Women’s rights activists said the change was followed by a sharp rise in domestic violence – often involving repeated assaults and police inaction. Yet the case of three sisters accused of murdering their abusive father has become a cause celebre and appears to have prompted something of a shift in public attitudes.

Mexico’s strike drew upon those held in Argentina, Poland, Spain and elsewhere, as well as the country’s own traditions of activism. Women are demanding that their lives be valued. Feminist campaigners face a backlash, expressed at times in physical violence as well as verbal abuse and threats. Yet we are seeing a wave of women’s protest around the world, from the #NiUnaMenos – “not one less” – movement against gender-based abuse and killings, which began in Argentina, to the #MeToo movement and onwards. The need for it is enraging. But the activism is remarkable, courageous and inspiring.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on Mexico’s new president: there is an alternative | Editorial
Editorial: Andrés Manuel López Obrador, known as Amlo, won largely because his opponents would not give up on policies that have failed to deliver growth and security


02, Jul, 2018 @5:26 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Amlo and Mexico’s murders: no quick fix | Editorial
Editorial: Poverty and aggressive anti-kingpin tactics have fuelled the violence, as the president has recognised – but there is no easy solution


05, Nov, 2019 @6:30 PM

Article image
Decades after Iceland’s ‘day off’, our women’s strike is stronger than ever | Selma James
The annual Global Women’s Strike has grown into a worldwide protest with evolving demands, says Selma James, founder of the International Wages for Housework Campaign

Selma James

08, Mar, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on women’s suffrage: still no real equality | Editorial
Editorial: Political change is important but it’s not enough on its own. More needs to be done to tackle the barriers to progress


04, Feb, 2018 @5:57 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the rise in domestic killings: figures to shock politicians to act | Editorial
Editorial: At the end of a week that saw Theresa May trash her reputation for taking domestic abuse seriously, the 32% rise in deaths must be a wake-up call


13, Sep, 2019 @5:30 PM

Article image
'Amlo made us public enemy No 1': why feminists are Mexico's voice of opposition
A president who claims to represent the dispossessed faces widespread backlash over his tacit support for a politician accused of rape

Elisabeth Malkin in Mexico City

08, Mar, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on women’s football: winning on and off the pitch | Editorial
Editorial: Broadcasting women’s football games live on the BBC would help the sport make the most of the moment


05, Jul, 2019 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on women’s rights: do not take progress for granted | Editorial
Editorial: Austerity, as the UN’s poverty expert noted, is especially harmful to women. The economic shock from Brexit is likely to widen the inequality gap


07, Dec, 2018 @6:30 PM

Article image
Mexico protests against attacks on women turn violent, as tension with president escalates
Protesters angry that López Obrador has supported politician accused of sexual assault are calling for greater protections for women

David Agren in Mexico City

09, Mar, 2021 @6:11 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on drug wars: protect the innocent | Editorial
Editorial: The jailing of a notorious cocaine smuggler will not end the drug wars. We must fight them with more regard for the victims


13, Feb, 2019 @6:30 PM