The Guardian view on Hilary Mantel: bringing new life to novels | Editorial

The reception of her Thomas Cromwell trilogy shows that the past is not dead – and fiction has a bright future

Who could have imagined, in the early 2000s when rumours of the novel’s death – or imminent replacement by the tablet – were rife, that on a rainy night in 2020 hundreds of readers would queue to get their hands on the 900-page third part in a fictional trilogy about 16th-century England? For her fans, the publication of Hilary Mantel’s 12th novel, The Mirror and the Light, on World Book Day is a glorious prospect.

We know the bones of the story that will unfold from this brick of a book, about the further rise (following two previous volumes) and eventual fall of Henry VIII’s adviser Thomas Cromwell, who had his head chopped off at Tower Hill on 28 July 1540. But Mantel’s conjuring of the vanished world of the Tudors has been likened by critics to a kind of magic. The Guardian’s reviewer, Alexandra Harris, described the novel’s narrative voice as “a spirit or angel”.

The terrain Mantel entered 15 years ago is a period when the modern state and church were in the process of being born. That she should have found herself so deeply immersed in this crucial episode, at a moment when England and the UK are once again in a state of internal and external flux, only adds to an already resonant undertaking. The palaces, paintings and tales of Henry VIII and his daughter Elizabeth I are among the most familiar chapters in our nation’s history. But the kings, queens and cardinals in popular tellings of this past are often little more than stock characters. Mantel does not diverge from the record of facts, names and places. She pays scrupulous homage to academic historians, and the “unseen army” of curators and archivists. But where there are gaps, she invents, building an imagined world around her central argument about the pivotal role of her main character, the self-made Cromwell, who rose from nowhere to become Henry VIII’s right-hand man, and one of the most powerful people on earth.

She describes this raw material as “the central ground of Englishness”, and you do not have to take her interpretation of events literally to believe that this act of re-engagement, by readers as well as writer, means something. The trilogy has struck a chord, with a Booker prize each for Wolf Hall and Bring Up the Bodies, 1.5m copies sold, a stage play and a television adaptation starring Mark Rylance and Claire Foy. Booksellers expect The Mirror and the Light to be their book of the year.

There is something uplifting, for literature and history lovers, in witnessing the past brought back to life with such a bang. There are no doubt pangs of envy too. Writers, libraries and high-street bookshops are all struggling against online competition and cuts. Research released last week showed that under-18s today read less than ever before. The handheld screen, with its moving images, is a formidable competitor. Yet the novel remains in remarkably lively form. Mantel is exceptional, but far from alone. All power to her for once again raising the bar.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on Easter week: time to be creative
Days have never felt so indistinguishable. We should think outside the box as we approach the bank holiday


05, Apr, 2020 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on a book glut: to the victor go the spoils? | Editorial
Editorial: Many publishers are enjoying record sales – but not all. We must take care that those with the biggest names and deepest pockets are not the only beneficiaries


23, Aug, 2020 @5:25 PM

The Writing Life: Hilary Mantel

Hilary Mantel talks about where she finds her characters in an extract from the British Library CD The Writing Life

25, Mar, 2011 @12:24 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on historical fiction: reimagining, not reproducing | Editorial
Editorial: A once-disparaged genre has found new life thanks to Hilary Mantel and others. But what do we want from it?


21, Jul, 2017 @5:16 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on graphic novels: expanding the literary horizon | Editorial
Editorial: Nick Drnaso’s Sabrina presents the judges with an enviable problem of their own making – how to judge it against novels without pictures


27, Jul, 2018 @4:16 PM

Article image
Hilary Mantel was right – some academics dislike novelists. But why? | Rebecca Rideal
Hostility between academics and popular historians has a lengthy history of its own. Yet it doesn’t make sense – nonfiction and fiction nurture each other

Rebecca Rideal

29, May, 2017 @1:57 PM

Wolf Hall by Hilary Mantel – review

Hilary Mantel's depiction of the omnicompetent Thomas Cromwell grips Christopher Tayler

Christopher Tayler

01, May, 2009 @11:01 PM

Article image
The strange and brilliant fiction of Hilary Mantel
Mantel was writing novels for decades before her literary stardom – all of which display her dark wit and stylistic skill. What are her major works beyond the Cromwell bestsellers? As the BBC’s Wolf Hall hits our screens, John Mullan uncovers her career

John Mullan

17, Jan, 2015 @8:30 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on book therapy: an old idea finds new life | Editorial
Editorial: A generous act by the creator of the detective Vera reminds us that reading can help people in the hardest times


04, Sep, 2020 @4:57 PM

Guardian Books podcast: Hilary Mantel on Wolf Hall and Bring Up the Bodies

Hilary Mantel talks to John Mullan about her Man Booker prizewinning novels on the life of Thomas Cromwell, Wolf Hall and Bring Up The Bodies. She also answers questions from the audience at a special Book Club in the Drapers Hall in the City of London, on the site of Cromwell's former home

Presented by John Mullan and produced by Tim Maby

21, Dec, 2012 @3:48 PM