The Guardian view on Robert Jenrick and the planning row: Tories and their friends | Editorial

The minister admits he acted unlawfully over Richard Desmond’s case. But questions remain unanswered

Rarely are cabinet ministers so keen to put up their hands and admit they were wrong. Robert Jenrick, the housing secretary, last month took the remarkable step of acknowledging that he acted unlawfully in approving billionaire Richard Desmond’s east London property development. Strikingly, he gave permission shortly after they met at a Conservative fundraiser, 24 hours before the introduction of a community infrastructure levy, which would have cost the tycoon at least £40m, and two weeks before Mr Desmond made a £12,000 donation to the party.

In a government which likes to skate over errors, it is remarkable to see someone taking responsibility so quickly. Mr Jenrick’s admission – and agreement to the quashing of his decision – followed legal action from Tower Hamlets council, and allowed him to dismiss their demand for files on the case. Among the essential questions are why he overruled his own planning inspector, and whether any other ministers contacted him over the case. On Wednesday, after Labour tabled a motion demanding their release, he released key documents. In one, an official writes that Mr Jenrick “is/was insistent that decision issued this week ie tomorrow – as next week the viability of the scheme is impacted by a change in the London CIL regime”.

As the shadow communities secretary, Steve Reed, told MPs, the case raises concerns of cash for favours; it has echoes of the Tory controversies which helped bring New Labour to power. Mr Jenrick insists that he acted in good faith, and that he “inadvertently” sat next to Mr Desmond at the dinner. But someone drew up the seating plan which put him beside a man planning a £1bn development. Both men say that Mr Jenrick did not discuss the planning matter at the dinner – but the billionaire former pornographer showed him a promotional video about the Westferry Printworks development on the Isle of Dogs. Any politician with a sense of propriety should have recused himself from the planning decision. Though the cabinet secretary, Sir Mark Sedwill, is examining the details of the case, the Cabinet Office has denied it is conducting an investigation. It should be.

Without the hefty Conservative majority and Mr Johnson’s own relaxed attitude to personal responsibility, Mr Jenrick would surely have left by now. The pandemic still consumes public attention which might otherwise turn to the case. Nonetheless, it exacerbates the perception that there is one rule for this government and its friends and another for the rest of us.

It comes as the Conservatives seek to push through a radical overhaul of a planning system that Dominic Cummings describes as “appalling”. That chimes with their inherent ideological distaste for “red tape” and sympathy to big business; there are better ways to expand housing, the purported goal. Any reform of the system will lack credibility and public confidence while Mr Jenrick is overseeing it. Suspicion will shadow any planning decision on his watch.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Tories cannot shut the door on this property scandal | Letters
Letters: Readers react to the exchange between the housing secretary, Robert Jenrick, and the Tory donor Richard Desmond concerning a £1bn development in east London


26, Jun, 2020 @3:57 PM

Article image
No 10 distances itself from Robert Jenrick over planning row
Richard Desmond contradicts housing secretary’s version of events at party fundraiser

Peter Walker Political correspondent

22, Jun, 2020 @1:22 PM

Article image
The Robert Jenrick planning row explained
Housing secretary’s approval of £1bn development has come under increasing scrutiny

Heather Stewart and Rajeev Syal

24, Jun, 2020 @7:17 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on planning: put people before profit | Editorial
Editorial: New green homes are needed, but the prime minister’s promise to cut “red tape” is a soundbite not a solution


06, Aug, 2020 @5:57 PM

Article image
Robert Jenrick under pressure to resign after donor-row documents released
Housing secretary ‘insisted’ planning decision for £1bn development should be rushed through

Rajeev Syal and Heather Stewart

25, Jun, 2020 @8:58 AM

Article image
Affordable housing 'will diminish due to UK planning changes'
National Housing Federation criticises idea of developer levy replacing obligation to provide social housing

Ben Quinn

06, Aug, 2020 @6:06 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on political trust: voters put store by it, the PM does not | Editorial
Editorial: The prime minister wants no one in his cabinet to pay for their mistakes, a strategy that has failed


28, Jun, 2021 @6:09 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson backs Robert Jenrick despite planning row
Senior MP says questions remain over links between housing secretary and Richard Desmond

Heather Stewart and Rajeev Syal

25, Jun, 2020 @12:23 PM

Article image
Minister suggests voters could raise planning issues at Tory fundraisers
Nadhim Zahawi defends Robert Jenrick’s overruling of planning decision after lobbying at event

Peter Walker Political correspondent

25, Jun, 2020 @9:10 AM

Article image
Boris Johnson's 'mutant' planning algorithm could scar England for ever | Simon Jenkins
A Dominic Cummings-influenced white paper throws land open to uncontrolled building – but could spark a Tory revolt, says Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins

27, Nov, 2020 @8:00 AM