With its recovery deal, is the EU finally starting to act like a unifying force? | Shahin Valléee

The huge economic boost breaks important political taboos, and suggests a willingness for more integration

It was a long time coming, but the coronavirus crisis seems to have allowed Europe to make a leap towards genuine integration. The global financial crisis in 2008 exposed the inherent fragilities and incompleteness of Europe’s monetary union, prompting a decade of agonising debate over fiscal union. Essentially, sharing a common currency without sharing a real budget was always going to be unstable and potentially dangerous .

But now European leaders seem to be finally facing up this profound architectural problem. Common debt, common expenditure and the possibility of common taxation – which all seemed out of reach over the last decade – were accepted this week unanimously after a marathon summit that lasted more than four days.

The €750bn recovery and resilience package is far from perfect. From a macroeconomic standpoint, it is too small and too slow to respond alone to the depth of the shock imparted by the epidemic and the economic shutdown. From a practical standpoint, the governance is too complex – it requires national governments to present reform programmes before they can receive funds. But from a political standpoint, by agreeing both to pool part of the economic response to the economic crisis and by authorising transfers between member states, the agreement breaks important taboos.

It is the combination of these political realities that can make this a meaningful recovery package. Reluctantly for some, gone are the days when weaker eurozone countries could only hope for European loans with austerity conditions attached. Indeed, member states whose public finances were shaky can now point to a political backing for their increased government expenditure. The European Central Bank can now feel that its sovereign debt purchase programme, which effectively mutualises debt, is unanimously sanctioned by European governments.

But the agreement also raises a number of questions. First, in order to finance this recovery fund, member states had to agree to cut some of the most important and future-oriented parts of the EU budget, in particular in research, healthcare and the green-energy transition. Luckily, the European parliament that has to approve the deal is already threatening to block it if these critical spending items are not revisited.

Second, because the compromise required unanimity there is only a very superficial control of the compliance of the spending with the EU’s climate objectives and, perhaps more importantly, there is no clear mechanism for ensuring that recipient countries abide by the essential rule of law and democratic values enshrined in European treaties. These concessions were particularly key to enlist the support of eastern European countries such as Hungary – which is effectively a one-party state – and Poland, but they create a fundamental dilemma for the EU and its cherished values.

Third, a coalition of small countries led by the Netherlands (including Denmark, Sweden, Austria and at times Finland), dubbed “the frugals”, extracted a number of important concessions such as getting rebates for their contributions to the EU budget. This is a practice that had been originally requested by the Thatcher government in the 1980s and has since become a fixture of European budgetary negotiations – but it is also a mechanism that allows them to veto disbursements if they are displeased with economic reforms undertaken in southern economies.

Finally, the critical weakness of the agreement, and what certainly makes it fall short of a real “Hamiltonian leap”, is the lack of a clear commitment to common European taxation. (Alexander Hamilton propelled the United States into a true federation by engineering the government takeover of the debts of individual states in the 18th century.) Indeed, the agreement has the merit of setting some important milestones in 2021 and 2023 for agreeing some level of “own resources” to the EU budget (a shorthand euphemism for European taxation) but it falls short of naming them clearly and of opening a real debate about a common European tax. A pan-continental corporate or carbon tax will be necessary sooner than later, unless Europeans want to entertain the illusion that this new borrowing can somehow be repaid ex-nihilo.

There is a profound irony, but maybe not a coincidence, that the EU is making strides towards integration at a time when it is severing its ties to the United Kingdom. A negotiation like this one would have certainly been derailed by the current British government. But while this agreement opens new possibilities, it also points to new fractures. For decades, it has been quietly assumed that France and Germany could call the shots alone. But the intense negotiations and compromises show that they can no longer carry the day on their own.

The growing powers of a growing coalition of small countries, willing to use their vetoes, as well as the internal divisions inside European political parties (the socialists, the European People’s party and the liberals), suggests that the institutional and constitutional overhaul that is required for the EU to stand more firmly on its feet will be long and hard.

• Shahin Vallée is a French economist, and was an adviser to Emmanuel Macron when he was economy minister


Shahin Vallée

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Italy will be Europe's canary in the coalmine for the post-Covid economy | Marchel Alexandrovich
All eyes will be on the southern European state to see if the ECB’s measures will prevent a health emergency becoming an economic one, says economist Marchel Alexandrovich

Marchel Alexandrovich

17, Mar, 2020 @7:30 AM

Article image
The shock of coronavirus could split Europe – unless nations share the burden | Moritz Schularick and Adam Tooze
European governments still seem destined to repeat the mistakes made in the financial crisis, say academics Moritz Schularick and Adam Tooze

Adam Tooze and Moritz Schularick

25, Mar, 2020 @7:51 PM

Article image
Britain is leaving the EU – just as Europe is on the up | Natalie Nougayrède
Merkel and Macron are planning for a ‘golden decade’ and won’t let Brexit negotiations derail them

Natalie Nougayrède

18, Jun, 2017 @6:52 PM

Article image
Greece may still be Europe’s sick patient, but the EU is at death’s door | Marina Prentoulis
EU-imposed austerity is finally over for Greece – and it’s time to rethink the whole European project, says political theorist Marina Prentoulis

Marina Prentoulis

21, Aug, 2018 @1:42 PM

Article image
Italy can't blame Brussels for its descent into the abyss | Phillip Inman
As much as some want to believe it, the EU has little to do with the country’s failure to put its house in order, says the Observer economics editor Philip Inman

Phillip Inman

30, May, 2018 @1:08 PM

Article image
If coronavirus sinks the eurozone, the 'frugal four' will be to blame | David Adler and Jerome Roos
The Dutch-led opposition to a ‘coronabond’ to raise funds for nations hardest-hit by the pandemic is self-defeating, say researchers David Adler and Jerome Roos

David Adler and Jerome Roos

31, Mar, 2020 @8:47 AM

Article image
Christine Lagarde will have to confront Berlin if she’s to save the euro | Yanis Varoufakis
The European Central Bank chief must call for an end to the eurozone’s suicidal fiscal rules, says Yanis Varoufakis, former finance minister of Greece

Yanis Varoufakis

15, Jul, 2019 @2:40 PM

Article image
The EU coronavirus fund will take Europe another step towards disintegration | Yanis Varoufakis
The recovery package promises deeper integration between European countries. It won’t work, says Yanis Varoufakis, co-founder of Democracy in Europe Movement

Yanis Varoufakis

24, Jul, 2020 @2:36 PM

Article image
The world's central banks are starting to experiment. But what comes next? | Adam Tooze
With the spectre of deflation looming in the wake of Covid-19, radical new policies could revolutionise the world economy, says history professor Adam Tooze

Adam Tooze

09, Sep, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
This is a deal that heaps more misery on Greeks | Vicky Pryce
The price of averting Greece’s exit from the euro, and even the European Union, is further painful austerity – surely a recipe for social turmoil

Vicky Pryce

23, Jun, 2015 @7:07 PM