One way to teach students more safely this fall? Move lessons outdoors | Jaime Cunningham

It’s easier to do social distancing outside – and there’s considerable evidence that students learn better in fresh air

We need to send our children back to school this fall – safely. School districts across the United States are currently being led by indecisive administrators who are grappling with budget cuts while scrambling to figure out how to coordinate complicated schedules for socially distanced classes coupled with online learning. There has to be a simpler way.

School districts nationwide should be seriously considering outdoor classrooms as part of their plan. It is now understood that Covid-19 transmits less easily outdoors than inside. Learning outside would allow more children to return to school, providing the crucial social interaction and in-person instruction which is missing in remote learning, while making it easier to maintain social distancing.

This method has worked before in the face of infectious disease epidemics. During the Spanish flu pandemic of 1918, the Boston-area prep school Rivers was able to stay mostly open when many other schools shut. Rivers had been founded three years earlier by an educator who embraced the concept of open-air schools, based on the suggestions of physicians that they could offer some protection against contagious diseases. When the school did a comparison of absence due to illness, the school reported fewer sick days overall during the 1918-1919 school year than it did the previous academic year, before the global flu pandemic.

In the fall of 1908, the city of Boston ran an open-air school for children who had tuberculosis (TB). By March of 1909, 23 of the students had recovered while the remaining 20 showed improved health. In Chicago, during the winter of 1909, children with mild TB attended school in a classroom where all the doors, windows and heat were removed and students wore layers of warm clothing.

One of the highest-ranking public health officials in the United States agrees with the health benefits of being outside. When asked about the idea of outdoor classrooms in an interview, Dr Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (Niaid), responded: “Outdoors is always better than indoors when it comes to Covid or any other respiratory infection.” And, in their guidance for reopening schools, the American Academy of Pediatrics encourages schools to use outdoor spaces whenever possible.

Still not convinced? Learning outside may also help kids concentrate better and absorb more information. A study at an urban Swedish high school looked at an intervention project where half the students in a class had several lessons taught outdoors while the other half attended lessons entirely indoors. When researchers followed up five months later they found that the pupils who attended classes outside had more motivation, an appreciation for teamwork-oriented activities and better long-term retention of information. Another study, of third-graders from mainly lower-income homes, examined classroom engagement following a lesson outside in nature versus learning the same lesson after all-day indoor instruction. The classes held in nature showed significantly better student engagement, and teachers reported that disruptions were cut in half.

One US college has caught on. In Houston, Rice University purchased several open-sided circus tents to build classrooms which will be used to hold classes this fall. A similar model could be replicated in public schools.

Many districts are still offering the choice of exclusive online learning. Having this option is essential for families and teachers who don’t feel safe. For students who founder in a remote learning environment, however, going back to school is critical for their development. Outdoor classrooms could be the solution for them.

  • Jaime Cunningham is a freelance journalist and a vice-president of the PTA at her child’s Manhattan public elementary school. She was previously a researcher-reporter for Newsweek

Jaime Cunningham

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
America is not prepared for schools opening this fall. This will be bad | Siva Vaidhyanathan
We’re just weeks from schools opening, and they aren’t ready. Parents, children, teachers – everyone will be affected

Siva Vaidhyanathan

13, Jul, 2020 @9:30 AM

Article image
The world's richest countries are hoarding vaccines. This is morally indefensible | Fatima Bhutto
Why does South Africa have to pay twice as much for vaccines as European countries do? Why has the entire continent of Africa - home to 1.3 billion people – been allocated just 300 million doses?

Fatima Bhutto

17, Mar, 2021 @10:19 AM

Article image
Don't let free speech be a casualty of coronavirus. We need it more than ever | Cas Mudde
Despots like Hungary’s Viktor Orbán are banning speech to ‘fight’ Covid-19. But more democratic countries are too

Cas Mudde

06, Apr, 2020 @3:27 PM

Article image
Obesity is a major risk factor for dying of Covid-19. We need to take it more seriously | Kermit Jones
Health officials need to emphasize the relation between obesity and Covid-19, and we need to treat it like other chronic diseases

Kermit Jones

15, Jun, 2020 @8:45 AM

Article image
There is now clear data on Covid-19 and children: it should be safe to reopen English schools | Matthew Snape
New research suggests that children are at minimal risk, says academic Matthew Snape

Matthew Snape

18, Aug, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Intergalactic lessons: five creative ways to teach about space
Create your own big bang in the classroom with our lesson ideas, including making edible meterorites and studying real lunar rocks

Sarah Marsh

01, Jun, 2015 @4:00 PM

Article image
The science of resilience: how to teach students to persevere
Neurologist and teacher Judy Willis shares three simple techniques to help teachers build resilience in their students

Judy Willis

12, Jan, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Why are doctors not listening to Covid-19 patients like me? | Fiona Lowenstein
The narrative is that Covid-19 patients are either hospitalized near death, or ride out a ‘mild’ Covid flu at home. The reality is more complex

Fiona Lowenstein

20, Jul, 2020 @10:17 AM

Article image
For true herd immunity, we must vaccinate immigrants as a priority | Laura Spinney
The US hasn’t learned from past pandemics. The health of naturalized Americans is intertwined with that of immigrants

Laura Spinney

14, Jan, 2021 @11:32 AM

Article image
Coronavirus: minister threatens headteacher over pre-Christmas online lessons
Letter shows government prepared to use Coronavirus Act to force English secondaries to stay open

Donna Ferguson

12, Dec, 2020 @10:35 AM