The 'Zoom parliament' could inspire a more democratic Commons | Richard Power Sayeed

Remote working would open up politics to a more diverse cohort of MPs, who could be more embedded in their communities

Émile Durkheim argued that traditions, along with other social institutions, exist because they do some kind of job for society as a whole. Accordingly, in parliament, the dress codes for MPs, the ermine, the gilded this and that, the bobbing and the bowing, are all said to encourage both lawmakers and citizens to take what happens in Westminster seriously.

If you watch a standard prime minister’s questions, which for centuries has been dominated by a baying mob of former public school boys, you might get the feeling that traditions aren’t always collectively beneficial. But our new and decidedly untraditional “Zoom parliament” has transformed the Commons. While MPs are still required to wear appropriate clothing and some politicians have decorated their webcam backdrops with their own fancy accessories, remote working has largely stripped parliament of its customs and costumes. We have been confronted with the bare bones of our representative system, and the result has been overwhelmingly positive.

Wednesday’s PMQs was like never before. No facile insults were screamed. There was no sonic wall of jeering. There were only a handful of MPs in the chamber, and those joining online were muted by the clerks until it was their turn to ask a question. Consequently, with the exception of some quiet “Hear hears”, almost no one spoke until they were invited to by the Speaker, Lindsay Hoyle. This week our semi-digital Commons looked, for the first time in a long while, like the epicentre of a grownup democracy, sensible and pleasingly boring.

As for the rest of parliamentary business: select committees, ministerial statements, debates and questions from MPs are now all taking place online. Votes have been postponed for the moment, and plans for a digital system are being developed, so that the whips won’t have to force hundreds of MPs and peers, some of them potentially infectious with Covid-19, into the lobbies.

Parliament’s old guard aren’t wrong to worry that a working-from-home parliament will lack some creative spontaneity as MPs are unable to take ministers to task with off-the-cuff questions. But look at these reforms from the perspective of people for whom evenings and days spent away from home are unrealistic. The ability to work remotely may open up a career in politics to a more diverse cohort of MPs. We’ll need more reform than this – allowing MPs to take parental leave is particularly key – but more remote working is a start.

We want MPs to be able to see their families, sending a signal that a better work/life balance is key to a happier society. And we want MPs to spend time in their communities, because we need them to represent the interests of people who have too often been ignored by politics. In that case, the benefits of making parliament accessible surely outweigh the costs.

These changes have civilised the Commons and have the potential to make British politics more democratic and representative. But if all this is not to be swept away when lockdown eventually ends, then modernising MPs and Hoyle must make many aspects of the “Zoom parliament” permanent. We’ll be waiting a long time for some reforms, like an elected second chamber and a more egalitarian party system that suppresses Westminster’s bullying culture. But there’s plenty to do in the meantime.

Durkheim was wrong. Traditions exist not because they benefit society, but because they benefit those who hold power. So move the ermine to a museum and leave the gilding in a gallery.

• Richard Power Sayeed is the author of a history of New Labour and Britain in the 1990s, 1997: The Future that Never Happened

Contributor

Richard Power Sayeed

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Lockdown may be over, but you'll never take my Zoom quiz away
Online pub quizzes brought me and my friends closer together. And besides, who wants to go for a socially distanced pint, asks author Joel Golby

Joel Golby

01, Jul, 2020 @9:42 AM

Article image
Slimmed-down ‘virtual House of Commons’ to sit next week
Up to 50 MPs will be in the chamber and 120 online via Zoom, despite security worries

Peter Walker

16, Apr, 2020 @6:54 PM

Article image
Children interrupting Zoom meetings could be the reboot corporate culture needed | Catharine Lumby
Until coronavirus, the invisible labour we all do at home was absent from our workplaces

Catharine Lumby

18, Jun, 2020 @2:08 AM

Article image
The problem isn’t remote working – it’s clinging to office-based practices | Alexia Cambon
Do we need to go to offices? Work 9 to 5? At this unique moment in history, employers can rethink everything, says researcher Alexia Cambon

Alexia Cambon

21, Jun, 2021 @4:33 PM

Article image
Zoom refuseniks: why companies are banning constant video calls
This week a US bank announced Zoom-free Fridays – and they are far from the first to question the stress and fatigue that comes with 24/7 screen time

24, Mar, 2021 @3:53 PM

Article image
Covid-19 makes it clearer than ever: access to the internet should be a universal right | Tim Berners-Lee
The internet eased lockdown life for millions. But millions more still can’t get online, and that’s fundamentally unfair, says web inventor Tim Berners-Lee

Tim Berners-Lee

04, Jun, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
As parliament returns, Covid-19 shows why we need more constructive politics | Rafael Behr
A semi-digital Westminster will mean less posturing and preening by MPs. That suits the crisis we’re in, says Guardian columnist Rafael Behr

Rafael Behr

21, Apr, 2020 @4:36 PM

Article image
Covid has made 'voice notes' the perfect way to stay connected | Magdalene Abraha
During these alienating times, verbal messages helped us to communicate quickly while maintaining intimacy, says writer and publisher Magdalene Abraha

Magdalene Abraha

03, Jan, 2021 @2:57 PM

Article image
How to help tackle sexual harassment in the House of Commons | André Spicer
Parliament needs to put in place standard HR procedures, writes André Spicer, professor of organisational behaviour at the Cass Business school

André Spicer

09, Nov, 2017 @12:59 PM

Article image
Why 'Zoom medicine' is not the answer to all our ills | Josh Hall
App-happy Matt Hancock wants telemedicine to be the new norm. But many chronically ill people depend on face-to-face care, says technology writer Josh Hall

Josh Hall

13, Aug, 2020 @8:00 AM