The Observer view on Keir Starmer's need for a persuasive vision

Competence and clarity are key as he looks ahead to what will be a very changed Britain

It was supposed to have been the big political event of April, but the announcement of Labour’s leadership result was a low-key affair yesterday, with relatively little fanfare, overshadowed by the terrifying coronavirus crisis that has swept across Britain.

As expected, Keir Starmer, the party’s shadow Brexit secretary, was decisively endorsed by Labour members and supporters. In a sober, impressive address, he spoke of Labour’s mission in the coming weeks to save lives and protect the country through constructive opposition.

Starmer takes over not just at a time of unprecedented national crisis, but a difficult juncture for his party. His victory comes after its most disastrous election defeat since 1935, the product of a party that was mired in institutional antisemitism, divisions over Brexit and voters’ dislike of Jeremy Corbyn.

During the three-month leadership campaign, Starmer has not proved as willing as his rival Lisa Nandy to speak hard truths to members about the reasons for Labour’s defeat. But he was not the candidate endorsed by Corbyn and his election marks a welcome fresh start.

There are a number of daunting tasks on Starmer’s to-do list. The first is to get the substance and tenor of opposition right in these extraordinary times. Britain is crying out for a mature and responsible opposition that can forensically hold this government, whose response to the coronavirus pandemic has been marred by a lack of preparedness and transparency, to account. In recent weeks, frontbenchers such as the shadow health secretary, Jon Ashworth, have led the way in asking appropriately tough questions of government about some of the chaotic aspects of its response, for example in its tardy procurement of ventilators, personal protective equipment and testing capacity, without looking like they are seeking to make political capital. Starmer must press for proper parliamentary scrutiny, even while MPs are not meeting in Westminster.

Further, he must confront the toxic cultures that have polluted his party. Most importantly, he must take responsibility for rooting out antisemitism, including fully implementing the recommendations of the Equality and Human Rights Commission inquiry when it is published. The party has also proved incapable of adjudicating fairly on allegations of sexual harassment. We applaud his commitment to establishing an independent complaints process.

The country faces huge levels of uncertainty as a result of the pandemic, with little clarity about where we will be in a few weeks, let alone six months. The only known is that there will be no going back to normal. Starmer must find a way to set out a vision for a new politics that addresses the societal fragilities that have been so painfully exposed in recent weeks, while holding on to those small shoots that are already emerging from the hardships and losses that many are starting to experience.

The same questions therefore face a party that defines itself through its aspiration for a fairer, greener world – but with new challenges attached. How would a Labour government restore a healthcare system that rightly commands huge national pride, but that will be left ravaged not just by a decade of austerity but a pandemic? What is the best way of restoring dignity and fair reward to work often labelled as “low skill”, but which this crisis has shown we cannot do without, jobs we are expecting people to risk their lives to do while being paid a pittance? How would Labour close the attainment gap between children from poor and affluent backgrounds that will inevitably widen as a result of the long closure of schools? What measures are needed to reduce carbon emissions while ensuring that the richest have to adapt their lifestyles, like the rest of us? And what is the future of Brexit in a probable global recession?

These are questions that can only be convincingly answered by a party of the left. When the worst of the crisis has passed, Britain will need a progressive government more than ever. We are all relying on Starmer to get Labour there.


Observer editorial

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Keir Starmer has caught the public mood. Now he can shape the political argument | Will Hutton
As the Labour leader said, the impact of the virus has been worsened by injustice

Will Hutton

21, Feb, 2021 @8:30 AM

Article image
Keir Starmer won the party handsomely. Now he must start convincing the nation | Andrew Rawnsley

Andrew Rawnsley

05, Apr, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Keir Starmer has the ability and the character, but what does he stand for? | Andrew Rawnsley
His campaign team is ideologically diverse and he’s attracting support from across the party

Andrew Rawnsley

12, Jan, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
The Observer view on Boris Johnson hurting the country and shaming his party | Observer editorial
With his lies and hypocrisy, the prime minister has corrupted and degraded the Tory party from the highest office

Observer editorial

15, Jan, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
The Observer view on Keir Starmer’s Labour conference speech | Observer editorial
The party’s leader signalled that it is again serious about winning power and taking on the Tories

Observer editorial

03, Oct, 2021 @5:30 AM

Article image
Keir Starmer's first steps are promising, but the road ahead is long and steep | Andrew Rawnsley
He has been stronger as a prosecutor of government incompetence than he has been as an advocate of the Labour alternative

Andrew Rawnsley

21, Jun, 2020 @7:30 AM

Article image
Why should Keir Starmer step aside? His rivals have few feminist credentials | Catherine Bennett
Being a woman in itself isn’t enough to lead Labour – it’s the record and policies that count

Catherine Bennett

26, Jan, 2020 @8:30 AM

Article image
The Observer view on Labour and antisemitism | Observer leader
This is just the start of the party’s long overdue reckoning with itself

Observer editorial

01, Nov, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
The Observer view on Labour’s new Brexit policy
Labour’s newfound pragmatism over the EU, revealed by Keir Starmer in the Observer today, is a game-changer. Now the real argument over Brexit can begin

Observer editorial

26, Aug, 2017 @11:04 PM

Article image
The Observer view on the Labour leadership election | Observer editorial
The party will be a lost cause unless there is compromise and conciliation

Observer editorial

24, Sep, 2016 @11:05 PM