Naga Munchetty reprimand blurs BBC’s own lines between reportage and opinion | Kenan Malik

The BBC Breakfast presenter had every right to express her anger at Donald Trump’s racist comment

‘Go back to where you come from.” It’s a standard racist taunt, one that I’ve heard since my first day in Britain. When Donald Trump used the phrase against four Democratic congresswomen in July, few could doubt his implication that they did not belong in America.

So when the BBC presenter Naga Munchetty discussed the issue with co-host Dan Walker on breakfast TV, her condemnation of the tweets as racist, and her anger at the racism she has faced, seemed both honest and stating the obvious.

Not to the BBC. Last week, its complaints unit generated a storm by ruling that while it was “legitimate” for Munchetty to have “reflected her own experience of racism”, it was wrong “to comment critically” on the president’s “motive” or the “consequences” of his words. David Jordan, the corporation’s director of editorial policy and standards, subsequently clarified that it was fine for Munchetty to have called the tweet racist, but not Trump.

There are three problems with this. First, Munchetty did not call Trump racist. She said she was “furious” that he “thinks it’s OK to skirt the lines by using language like that”. Second, other BBC journalists have called the president racist. Its New York correspondent, Nick Bryant, for instance, tweeted about Trump’s “racial demagoguery”. And, third, the BBC’s distinction is specious. If I can offer an opinion on the racial nature of a tweet, why not on the person tweeting?

There are indeed real issues about reporters blurring the line between reportage and personal viewpoint. Munchetty, however, was not reporting on the topic but expressing her opinion. Ruling her comments inappropriate not only reins in the calling out of racism but makes it more difficult to draw the line between news and opinion.

• Kenan Mailk is an Observer columnist


Kenan Malik

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Emily Maitlis: BBC 'looks out of touch' over Munchetty decision
Newsnight presenter says corporation set ‘semantic conundrum’ in Trump racism ruling

Vanessa Thorpe Arts and media correspondent

28, Sep, 2019 @3:59 PM

Article image
BBC’s Naga Munchetty reprimanded over Trump criticism
Broadcaster says discussion of president’s racist tweets broke editorial guidelines

Jim Waterson Media editor

25, Sep, 2019 @2:03 PM

Article image
A culture of truth denial is wilting US democracy and Britain is following fast | Will Hutton
GB News is chasing Fox down a path of being economical with the facts, culminating in assertions last week that a liberal elite is running the UK

Will Hutton

09, Apr, 2023 @8:00 AM

Article image
Naga Munchetty says she stands by her Trump comments
Presenter speaks for first time about being censured by BBC over racism remarks

Sam Gelder

01, Feb, 2020 @12:25 PM

Article image
Opinion is cheap and easy. The BBC’s mission is to deliver facts and evidence | Clive Myrie
The corporation is under attack for losing its edge. One of its leading voices defends its distinct role

Clive Myrie

04, Sep, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
The threats to tear down the BBC have not gone away. Watch this space | Alan Rusbridger
Amid the information chaos of Covid, the national broadcaster is more vital than ever

Alan Rusbridger

20, Dec, 2020 @8:30 AM

Article image
Bonnie Greer and Laurence Fox’s chat over coffee is what used to pass for normal conduct | Kenan Malik
When two adults meet to discuss a disagreement over racism and white privilege it’s a sign of maturity not grounds for attack

Kenan Malik

02, Feb, 2020 @8:30 AM

Article image
The BBC’s wish for a finger in every pie | Letters
Editorial standards have been diluted and there is confusion about the corporation’s role in the national life

02, Jun, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
The BBC’s fixation on ‘balance’ skews the truth | Catherine Bennett
It’s right to give different sides of a story, but as a new report says, some are backed by facts and some by lies

Catherine Bennett

03, Sep, 2016 @11:02 PM

Article image
Only bampots will girn about BBC’s poetic delight | Kevin McKenna
BBC Scotland’s poet in residence, Stuart A Paterson, promotes Scots as a living language, a useful antithesis to modern bureaucratic English

Kevin McKenna

30, Sep, 2017 @11:05 PM