The latest Iran-Saudi flare-up exposes Trump's bankrupt Middle East policy | Michael H Fuchs

End support for the war in Yemen, change the relationship with Saudi Arabia, and talk to Iran – the answers for the US are clear

The fact that the United States is up in arms over an attack with no reported casualties on an oil refinery in Saudi Arabia – while at the same time supporting Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen that has killed tens of thousands – tells us everything we need to know about how messed up US priorities in the Middle East are.

If anything, the latest round of tensions between the US, Iran and Saudi Arabia – and the debate over whether or not to retaliate militarily against Iran – illustrates the many ways US policy in the region is bankrupt, and how Trump crafts US policy based on the interests of other countries, not America.

The years-long struggle for regional influence between Iran and Saudi Arabia and their partners plays out in proxy wars that rip the region apart, such as the current humanitarian catastrophe in Yemen. The US has taken Saudi Arabia’s side in this regional conflict, in which there is no “good side”, and in the process only exacerbated the tensions and violence.

Iran is a bad actor, and the United States already takes serious steps to curb its support for terrorism, and to defend Israel. But Trump is making the threat worse by ending the Iran nuclear deal and provoking Iran. We now find ourselves in yet another edition of Trump’s deadly reality show: will he or won’t he strike?! Will he or won’t he risk the lives of American soldiers in an unnecessary war?! Or will he try to manufacture another photo-op summit that does nothing but mask the real problems?! Tune into Twitter to find out! Like everything he touches, Trump has turned America’s Iran policy into a farce, while increasing the likelihood of tragedy.

Saudi Arabia, America’s longtime supposed partner, is also a bad actor. For too long America has stomached Saudi Arabia’s support for extremist ideologies, destabilizing policies, and repression at home. But Trump takes it to an extreme by seemingly outsourcing US policy to Riyadh. After the recent attacks, Trump literally said: “We are waiting to hear from the Kingdom [of Saudi Arabia] as to who they believe was the cause of this attack, and under what terms we would proceed.”

Jared Kushner must have done a facepalm – it’s supposed to be secret when Saudi Arabia’s crown prince, Mohammed bin Salman, sends his orders over WhatsApp! Trump summed up why he always sides with Riyadh, even after the Saudi leader ordered the murder of the US journalist Jamal Khashoggi: “Saudi Arabia pays cash.”

One of the most devastating results of US policy has been the humanitarian disaster in Yemen. Because Saudi Arabia entered the war on one side, while Iran supports the other, the United States has blindly followed Saudi Arabia in fueling this conflict that is starving children and killing innocent civilians. The conflict has taken the lives of at least tens of thousands of people, and a United Nations panel recently said that all sides might be committing war crimes.

Israel – and Trump’s relationship with Benjamin Netanyahu – is at the center of this as well. Israel is a close and important ally, but Trump and Netanyahu have personalized, politicized and radicalized the US-Israeli relationship. While Trump attempts to use the relationship as a political wedge by falsely painting his opponents as enemies of Israel, Netanyahu pushes for conflict with Iran and takes steps that make peace with Palestinians all but impossible – steps that Trump openly supports. The two feed off each other and support one another’s agendas, which are bad for the relationship and bad for the region.

Since the end of the cold war, US policy in the region has been driven by numerous considerations: countering Iran, fighting terrorism, supporting stability, protecting oil markets and defending Israel. While aspects of these policies were faulty long before this administration, today things are very different. Fossil fuels are destroying life in earth. Actions taken in the name of countering Iran often feed instability. Trump has warped our partnership with Israel into blind support for a self-destructive Israeli government.

In partnering with autocrats to fight terrorism the United States has sacrificed other priorities. The Arab spring, the war in Syria, and myriad other calamities have illustrated how tyranny in the region is undermining – not supporting – stability. And now, ties between Saudi officials and businesses and the Trump family raise serious questions about whether Trump’s Middle East policies are being driven in part by efforts to line his own pockets.

Whatever happens in response to this latest flare-up, the answers for the United States are clear: end support for the war in Yemen. Fundamentally change the relationship with Saudi Arabia. Talk to Iran about the entire range of concerns. Bring the sparring sides together to reduce regional tensions. Stop giving Netanyahu a blank check and return support for Israel to the principles of supporting democracy and a two-state solution. And stop supporting autocrats and start supporting the people.

While there is growing support to completely change America’s Middle East policy – evidenced by the bills ending US support for the Yemen war that passed Congress – US policy remains stuck in a rut: Trump vetoed these congressional attempts to end support for the Yemen war and every time tensions spike, too many voices on both sides of the aisle respond with the kneejerk reaction of considering military action against Iran.

If America is going to make big changes to shore up the capacity of US leadership to tackle the biggest challenges it faces, one of the first orders of business will be to fix America’s bankrupt Middle East policy. Now would be a good time to start.

  • Michael H Fuchs is a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress, and a former deputy assistant secretary of state for east Asian and Pacific affairs


Michael H Fuchs

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Iran deal: how Trump's actions could flare violence in Middle East
US president’s decision to break with the Iran nuclear deal increases tensions in a region already mired in myriad interwoven conflicts

Oliver Holmes in Jerusalem

09, May, 2018 @4:53 PM

Article image
Middle East: Saudi Arabia weakened as Iran plans to consolidate gains
Yemen war and killing of Jamal Khashoggi have put pressure on the kingdom that shows no sign of letting up in 2019

Martin Chulov in Beirut

27, Dec, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Trump wants to sell more weapons to Saudi Arabia. Congress must stop him | Mohamad Bazzi
The administration wants to sell $8bn of weapons to Saudi Arabia and UAE – and prop up a morally indefensible war

Mohamad Bazzi

08, Jun, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Saudi execution of Shia cleric sparks outrage in Middle East
Iranian government and religious leaders say killing of Sheikh Nimr al-Nimr will have serious repercussions for royal family

Nicola Slawson

02, Jan, 2016 @10:24 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Iran and Saudi Arabia: maximum pressure, maximum risks | Editorial
Editorial: The attack on a key oil facility has increased the dangers – but US actions triggered this crisis


17, Sep, 2019 @5:32 PM

Article image
The Saudi-Iran powerplay behind the Yemen conflict | Nussaibah Younis
Riyadh’s decision to launch air strikes against Yemen risks further escalation of its rivalry with Tehran

Nussaibah Younis

29, Mar, 2015 @12:07 AM

Article image
A guide to Middle East politics in 2014
Ian Black: From Egypt to Syria, Palestine to Iraq, the hopes of the Arab spring lie in tatters. And with the latest conflict in Gaza, the Middle East is more violent, volatile and complex than ever. So where are we now?

Ian Black

04, Aug, 2014 @5:56 PM

Article image
Afghanistan tries to strike balance in escalating Iran-Saudi rivalry
The new Kabul leadership must preserve its strategic ties with the Islamic republic while pursuing better relations with Saudi Arabia, says veteran Afghan journalist

Farhad Peikar for Tehran Bureau

22, Apr, 2015 @4:00 AM

Article image
Iran denies launching drone attacks on Saudi oil facility
Foreign ministry counters accusations from US secretary of state with threats to US bases

Michael Safi

15, Sep, 2019 @10:39 PM

Article image
Saudi Arabia accuses Iran of 'direct aggression' over Yemen missile
Crown prince links Tehran to missile fired from Yemen towards Riyadh airport, as stakes raised between regional rivals

Saeed Kamali Dehghan Iran correspondent

07, Nov, 2017 @2:51 PM