We know how Johnson wants to play this election. The signs are it’s not working | Owen Jones

The Tories’ funders are split, the prime minister’s performances have been dire, and the opposition is finding its cutting edge

Imagine the scene in parliament late last night: a scruffy man with a ruffled open shirt, swinging a plastic carrier bag, staggers up to the escalator near the Palace of Westminster, yelling wildly at the leader of the opposition: “Jeremy, let’s have an election!” Corbyn was on a phone call, but a bewildered phalanx of shadow ministers clocked who it was: “career psychopath” (in the words of David Cameron) Dominic Cummings, the UK’s co-prime minister. “I thought he was a drunk tourist,” reports Cat Smith, one of the shadow ministers present last night.

A drunk tourist is an apt description for Cummings: intoxicated with his own overblown reputation and sense of destiny; a man with foul-mouthed contempt for a party he’s simply passing through, subjecting it to a reign of terror in order to secure his precious Brexit project.

Whether Cummings is a clever man, or just a man who wants us to think he is clever, remains unproven. What is clear is that Cummings and Boris Johnson are gearing up to run an election on a manifesto promising what the cultural theorist Stuart Hall once described as “authoritarian populism”. Such populism, wrote Hall, “unlike classic fascism, has retained most (though not all) of the formal representative institutions in place, and ... at the same time has been able to construct itself an active popular consent”. This was Hall’s description of Thatcherism, but it is a more apt description of a Johnson regime attempting to implement what the Tory hard Brexiteers always craved: to use the 2016 referendum result to craft a national-conservative revolution.

After four years of press panic about the “Stalinist authoritarianism” of Labour, not one of its MPs has been deselected. Yet after assuming the premiership just six weeks ago, Johnson has already shut down parliament, purged 21 of his opponents, and called into question whether he’d obey the law.

The outrage at his assault on democratic norms will mean nothing to the political coalition Johnson seeks to craft in the coming election. The Brexiteers claim they want to turn Britain into a low-tax and low-regulation trading island like Singapore; but the direction Johnson and Cummings are heading in looks more like Hungary, a nation ruled by an authoritarian, anti-immigrant, antisemitic regime which the Tories have voted to defend. The trappings of democracy are maintained, but the substance is hollowed out: what its prime minister, Viktor Orbán, lauds as an “illiberal democracy”. Opponents are vilified as enemies of the people and George Soros is cast as a rootless Jewish financier wielding disproportionate and sinister power. Media opponents have been stifled.

The Tories won’t borrow the antisemitism, but a government whose leader described Muslim women as “bank robbers” and “letterboxes” will likely fuel bigotry. Migrant-bashing will be combined with law-and-order authoritarianism and targeted spending hikes on austerity-ravaged education and healthcare. Just as the Tories in the 1980s incited bigotry against gay people for political gain, it’s now reported in the Times that No 10 has “been polling ‘culture war issues’, such as transgender rights, to see whether they can be weaponised against Labour in northern working-class constituencies”.

Tax cuts will be offered across the board, but weighted towards older, affluent, high-turnout voters. For the third of the population for whom Brexit overrides all else, there will be a do-or-die commitment to prise an exit from the grip of a nefarious, disloyal political elite; for others, Brexit weariness and tedium will be exploited. Johnson won’t need to muzzle the press, of course: most will show slavish loyalty.

The onslaught against Johnson’s opponents will have grim consequences. An increasingly thuggish far right see him as their own: extremists have called a demo this weekend to “get behind our Queen & Boris”. Their support for his government has largely escaped scrutiny. Johnson may disavow their enthusiastic approval, but as was said of a Trumpian candidate in Florida last year: “The racists believe he’s a racist.”

Yet hubris may collide with nemesis. Britain’s dominant business class – the Tories’ traditional key base and source of funding – are divided, with some fearing no deal more than Corbynism. Labour can easily outflank the Tories’ spending plans, arguing that the Conservative fiscal U-turn is an acceptance that austerity has failed and that their opponents were right all along. Just as Labour should never compete with the Tories over being tough on immigration – voters will always believe the Tories more – the political debate is shifting to Corbyn’s favoured ground. Tax cuts can be matched with tangible policy commitments, whether it be on childcare or scrapping tuition fees.

The polling shows that, while most remainers are repulsed by no deal, leave supporters are lukewarm and conflicted. There are early signs – in polling and on the streets – of remainers coming back to Labour. In an election, a binary choice in most constituencies between enabling a no-deal Johnson government, or a Labour administration offering a public vote with the option of remain – perhaps an immediate referendum with the other option of “renegotiate” – could cut through.

Johnson’s dire performances this week in the House of Commons, and his bumbling bluster when under pressure in the Tory leadership campaign, have challenged the myth of his charismatic, campaigning selling point. Corbyn, meanwhile, has regained his mojo as an election campaign – where he’s in his element – approaches.

The Tory strategy may yet succeed: authoritarian populism fused with targeted spending hikes and Brexit fatigue may triumph. Labour cannot simply repeat their 2017 campaign – and Johnson’s opponents may still divide. A bleak, intolerant Britain beckons if so. But I wonder, as he parades the Commons, drunk on self-confidence, if Cummings is starting to wonder if he’s not quite as clever as he thinks.

• Owen Jones is a Guardian columnist

Contributor

Owen Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Tories have lost their ideology. Now they are merely the party of resentment | William Davies
After three decades of intellectual decline, the Conservative party stands for nothing but Brexit, says sociologist and writer William Davies

William Davies

01, Oct, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Without MPs like Amber Rudd, the Tories won’t survive | Matthew d’Ancona
Johnson’s risky tactics may be working, according to the polls. But he will come to regret his purge of the moderates, says Guardian columnist Matthew d’Ancona

Matthew d’Ancona

08, Sep, 2019 @2:11 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson’s electoral gamble risks wrecking the Tory party | Jonathan Freedland
Proroguing parliament, expelling MPs: are these moves born of panic or all part of a cunning plan, asks Guardian columnist Jonathan Freedland

Jonathan Freedland

04, Sep, 2019 @10:28 AM

Article image
Only a government of national unity can deliver us from no deal | Polly Toynbee
Let Margaret Beckett lead a ‘government’ to do what the crisis demands – call an election and a referendum, says Guardian columnist Polly Toynbee

Polly Toynbee

05, Aug, 2019 @4:36 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson's US trade deal will make Britain a paradise for disaster capitalists | George Monbiot
Chlorinated chicken is just the start. The government intends to rip down food standards, public services and public protections, says Guardian columnist George Monbiot

George Monbiot

09, Jun, 2020 @4:14 PM

Article image
Dominic Cummings' war on the British civil service will undermine democracy | The civil servant
Neither the prime minister nor his enforcer want to hear the truth from civil servants like me

The civil servant

01, Aug, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Ignore Boris Johnson’s bluster about Brexit. He wants a general election | Tom Kibasi
He knows a better Brexit deal isn’t possible, and that no deal could be blocked. He’s playing a different game entirely, says Tom Kibasi, director of the IPPR

Tom Kibasi

12, Jun, 2019 @11:57 AM

Article image
The Guardian view of Boris Johnson: neglecting the nation | Editorial
Editorial: He ignores the floods while pursuing immigration plans and an attack on the BBC, which are destructive and divisive. The prime minister does not care

Editorial

21, Feb, 2020 @6:09 PM

Article image
A December election is Labour’s least-worst option | Owen Jones
Corbyn should tell Boris Johnson he can have a vote when his woeful deal is suspended, says Guardian columnist Owen Jones

Owen Jones

25, Oct, 2019 @1:48 PM

Article image
Johnson faces political disgrace, but that will play well with some voters | Katy Balls
The prime minister’s supreme court defeat could convince many that he represents Brexit’s best chance, says Katy Balls, the Spectator’s deputy political editor

Katy Balls

25, Sep, 2019 @9:36 AM