It’s time for tactical voting – Brexit is too terrifying for political piety | Martin Kettle

In some areas, supporting those you might disagree with is the only way to stop Boris Johnson

“I think there are millions of us,” says David Gauke as he hands out election leaflets in Berkhamsted high street. “Politically homeless people who want reasonable and respectful politics back.” The former justice secretary and anti-Brexit rebel, who is running as an independent in South West Hertfordshire, says Tuesday’s TV debate between Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn has simply made things worse. “Many, many voters this morning have been telling me they are disheartened. They want a better choice.”

It is often said that UK general elections are won and lost in the English Midlands. But British elections are regional and multi-party now, and there are plenty of swing constituencies in the London commuter belt where disgruntled voters have seized their chance to reshape Britain’s government in the past – and may do so again this time.

Traditionally, when Labour wins a majority in parliament it wins seats in counties such as Hertfordshire, Essex and Kent. Tony Blair won five out of 11 in Hertfordshire in 1997. But in 2017, Labour did not win a single seat in the county. Only an exceptionally obdurate Labour optimist can expect Jeremy Corbyn to improve on that on 12 December.

Yet plenty of these commuter-belt seats are up for grabs in 2019. That’s especially true of the areas closer to London, where younger families have migrated from the metropolis over the years in search of better housing and a greener lifestyle while still commuting into the capital. Many also voted to remain in the EU. Among them were three seats that face important election contests: Beaconsfield, South West Hertfordshire and St Albans.

Labour has no chance of winning any of the three. Beaconsfield and South West Hertfordshire are in play because their former Tory MPs, Dominic Grieve and Gauke, thrown out of the parliamentary party by Boris Johnson for opposing a hard Brexit, are running as independents, while St Albans is a major target seat for the Liberal Democrats’ Daisy Cooper. Having spent time on the campaign trail in all three seats this week, I think it is clear that the official Tory candidates are genuinely under threat in all of them. But it is also clear that the Tories will not lose without determined and large-scale tactical voting.

Right now, there is no common pattern. Yet uncertainty about how to make tactical voting work is widespread. This partly reflects the lack of information, which several websites and campaigns are now seeking to correct. But it also reflects a deeper cultural tension between the centre left and centre right, in which it is genuinely hard to persuade adherents of one tradition to vote tactically for the other, even though the substantive differences between them are sometimes small. Even among the reasonable and respectful voters whom Gauke invokes, tribal loyalties can be tenacious.

Cooper knows this at first-hand better than most. The former campaigns director for Hacked Off was widely expected to take remain-backing St Albans for the Lib Dems in 2017 and to oust the Tory, Anne Main, a hardline leaver who narrowly survived a deselection attempt in 2009 after an expenses row. But Cooper fell short on 32%, largely because the Labour vote held up at 23%.

On the doorstep with Cooper this week as she canvassed undecideds, it was hard to believe she will fail a second time. “I’m going to vote Lib Dem because I’m a remainer,” said Caroline, a former Labour supporter. This was a constant refrain. Stopping Brexit was by far the most common topic on the doorstep. If the Tories are to lose St Albans next month, Labour voters are going to have to vote for Cooper in greater numbers than they did two years ago.

Round the M25 in the Buckinghamshire seat of Beaconsfield, Grieve’s challenge is to persuade enough of the nearly 37,000 people who supported him as a Tory in 2017 to back him as an independent. “Corbyn is the bogeyman,” Grieve told me. “There’s an anxiety about somehow letting Labour come through and win.”

Judging by his reception from commuters outside Gerrards Cross station on the coldest morning of the year so far, however, plenty have overcome any such anxiety. Support for Grieve’s anti-Brexit stand was overwhelming. “Thank you for your integrity,” “You’re a principled man,” and “I can finally vote for someone who puts the national interest first” were just some of the accolades he received in the frosty dawn. “After a session like that, I think we might just do it,” Grieve told me later, over breakfast in a local cafe. He surely can.

Grieve is helped by the fact that in Beaconsfield the Liberal Democrats have stood down and endorsed him. Up the road in South West Hertfordshire, Gauke is not so fortunate. His campaign has had to start from scratch. The word here is that the local Lib Dems were prepared to give Gauke a clear run but that Jo Swinson and the national leadership overruled them, partly on the grounds that they did not want to do too many deals with former Conservatives. In practice, though, there is no sign yet of a Lib Dem effort there, and Gauke gets a supportive reaction from shoppers in Berkhamsted. The former Labour MP for Barnsley East, Michael Dugher, who lives locally, is backing Gauke too.

These are just three Conservative-held seats. Yet they stand for many others. Voters in such seats who want to stop Johnson from getting a majority, or who yearn for Britain to remain in Europe, have to get real about their options. If Labour cannot win these seats – and at present it cannot – then it is right to vote for the opponent with the best chance. This is not a time for political piety, prissiness or pride. It’s about facing the Brexit danger – and taking the one real chance of preventing it.

• Martin Kettle is a Guardian columnist


Martin Kettle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on election 2019: it’s about Brexit above all | Editorial
Editorial: The retirement of so many centrist Tories is a reminder that theirs has now become the Brexit party in all but name


31, Oct, 2019 @6:28 PM

Article image
Tactical voting could swing this election – but we need to get it right | Zoe Williams
For people in marginal seats, there’s more data available than ever. The question is how to interpret it, says Guardian columnist Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

08, Nov, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
In this election, voter registration will be even more important than tactical voting | Lara Spirit
People not yet registered to vote could make a decisive difference, says Lara Spirit, director of Vote For Your Future

Lara Spirit

10, Nov, 2019 @1:08 PM

Article image
Tactical voting sites have spread confusion and animosity. In fact, we don’t need them | Dan Davies
They may not be biased, but their methods are clumsy – and to most, their uncertain advice is largely useless, says economic analyst Dan Davies

Dan Davies

29, Nov, 2019 @1:06 PM

Article image
Beware of dodgy tactical voting sites – they’re the last resort of outmoded centrists | Ellie Mae O’Hagan
Technocrats still think they can win without making political arguments, says politics and culture writer Ellie Mae O’Hagan

Ellie Mae O’Hagan

07, Nov, 2019 @1:03 PM

Article image
I’ve always been Labour, but tomorrow I will be voting tactically | Steve Coogan
To help stop Boris Johnson, I am putting aside a lifetime of party loyalty, says comedian and actor Steve Coogan

Steve Coogan

11, Dec, 2019 @5:30 PM

Article image
This is a Brexit election. But Boris Johnson will not get Brexit done | Martin Kettle
The Tories created this mess and can deliver only division and destabilisation, says Guardian columnist Martin Kettle

Martin Kettle

12, Dec, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
In many places voting Lib Dem is the best way to keep Boris Johnson out of No 10 | Jo Swinson
Britain needs a change of leadership to end austerity, injustice and the folly of Brexit, says Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson

Jo Swinson

11, Dec, 2019 @1:14 PM

Article image
Voting tactically? Here’s how to do it right | Dan Davies
In close races, it may not be obvious which party should get your vote to stop the Tories, says former Bank of England economist Dan Davies

Dan Davies

11, Dec, 2019 @1:29 PM

Article image
There is now a force to disrupt Brexit. MPs, it’s time to act | Matthew d’Ancona
The Independent Group has made old certainties look weaker than ever, says Guardian columnist Matthew d’Ancona

Matthew d’Ancona

24, Feb, 2019 @4:33 PM