Jo Swinson says Labour and the Tories are the same on Brexit. That’s just not true | Chaminda Jayanetti

There are plenty of reasons not to vote for Corbyn. But his current Brexit policy is close to what the Lib Dems pledged in 2017

Once upon a time, words had meanings. Take “merge”, for example – to “blend gradually into something else so as to become indistinguishable from it”, according to the Oxford English Dictionary.

Apparently it means something else to the Liberal Democrats. How else to explain Jo Swinson’s inexplicable claim this week that Labour and the Tories “merge into one” on Brexit? Are Labour and the Tories indistinguishable on the subject?

Labour promises a second referendum with remain on the ballot. The Tories do not. Labour is promising to negotiate a relatively soft Brexit deal as the other option in the referendum vote. The Tories are pledging a hard Brexit. The one constant in Labour’s shifting Brexit stance since 2016 has been opposition to no deal. The Tories are leaving no deal firmly on the table, keeping alive the possibility of an EU crash-out at the end of 2020.

Swinson is not a disengaged voter, or a hyperbolic keyboard warrior. She is a party leader. She knows Labour and the Tories are not the same. When she says they “merge into one” on Brexit, she is lying.

She won’t be the only one, of course, during what is already shaping up to be a wretchedly mendacious election. But what particularly rankles about Swinson’s dishonesty is that Labour has more or less adopted the Lib Dems’ own policy from 2017. Two years ago, her party’s manifesto stated: “When the terms of our future relationship with the EU have been negotiated (over the next two years on the government’s timetable), we will put that deal to a vote of the British people in a referendum, with the alternative option of staying in the EU on the ballot paper.”

The only difference between that and Labour’s policy now is that Tim Farron’s manifesto was explicit that there was no Brexit deal as good as remaining. Labour remains ambiguous, with Jeremy Corbyn refusing to say whether he’d back leave or remain once a new “Labour Brexit” deal has been negotiated. Labour is neither pro- nor anti-Brexit in that sense, though its MPs are mostly pro-remain.

Does this ambiguity matter? Arguably not. Labour’s uncertainty relates to its stance in a referendum, not on a referendum. How many people in 2020 are going to decide their vote on Brexit based on what Corbyn thinks? David Cameron had far more support among Tory voters in 2016 than Corbyn did, yet most Tory voters backed leave.

It’s clear that Labour has nobody to blame but itself for continuity remainers’ lack of trust in it. Corbyn called for article 50 to be invoked the day after the referendum. After successfully facing both ways on Brexit during the 2017 election, the party hierarchy got drunk on its own hubris in the following years, convinced it had found the winning formula to keep its electoral coalition on board.

But as remainers coalesced around demands for a people’s vote, especially before the 2019 European elections, Labour found itself disastrously behind the curve, allowing the Lib Dems to rise from the dead. Labour took remain voters for granted as if they had nowhere else to go. They went.

Yet though Labour’s 2017 manifesto committed to delivering Brexit, its 2019 manifesto will not. Labour will offer people’s vote campaigners what they asked for. The idea that this is the behaviour of a pro-Brexit party will be news to actual Brexiters.

There are plenty of logical reasons not to vote Labour at this election – antisemitism, national security, the leadership’s tendency to respond to any problem by seeking more control for itself. But the Lib Dems, in their desperation to cast Labour as a pro-Brexit party, have created a fake news factory. Labour may be unfit for office – but it is not the same as the Tories on Brexit.

• Chaminda Jayanetti is a journalist who covers politics and public services


Chaminda Jayanetti

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Lib Dems hate Labour more than they hate Brexit | Owen Jones
Jo Swinson’s aggressive campaign to split the remain vote is a gift to Boris Johnson, says Guardian columnist Owen Jones

Owen Jones

14, Nov, 2019 @10:29 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on the 2019 election result: a new political landscape | Editorial
Editorial: Boris Johnson has redrawn the map and Labour and the Lib Dems are in disarray. Brexit will pass and Scottish independence will move to the centre of the stage


13, Dec, 2019 @5:32 PM

Article image
If Jo Swinson is serious about stopping a no-deal Brexit, she must support Corbyn | Jonathan Lis
The Labour leader’s solution may not be perfect, but could well be the most viable, says Jonathan Lis of the thinktank British Influence

Jonathan Lis

15, Aug, 2019 @4:25 PM

Article image
Jo Swinson says she won’t back Corbyn. But ultimately she’ll have to | Vernon Bogdanor
If there is a hung parliament, the Lib Dems will end up backing Labour. They know their supporters want a second referendum, says professor of government Vernon Bogdanor

Vernon Bogdanor

02, Dec, 2019 @5:54 PM

Article image
It’s time for Labour to bite the bullet and embrace an election | Owen Jones
If the party picks up Johnson’s gauntlet, it must pitch itself as the antidote to an arrogant Tory establishment, says Guardian columnist Owen Jones

Owen Jones

23, Oct, 2019 @6:29 PM

Article image
By dismissing Corbyn’s overtures, the Lib Dems are showing their true colours | Owen Jones
Jo Swinson was happier propping up David Cameron for five years than the Labour leader for five weeks, says Guardian columnist Owen Jones

Owen Jones

16, Aug, 2019 @12:43 PM

Article image
Unite to Remain could hurt the anti-Brexit cause. That’s why I’m no longer a Green candidate | Tom Meadowcroft
As a prospective Green party MP, I would have taken crucial votes from Labour, says Tom Meadowcroft

Tom Meadowcroft

19, Nov, 2019 @10:00 AM

Article image
Corbyn’s failed Brexit strategy sealed Labour’s fate | Caroline Flint
The Tories can now lay claim to be Britain’s party of the working class. Labour now either faces the hard truths or deludes itself, says former Labour MP Caroline Flint

Caroline Flint

15, Dec, 2019 @6:55 PM

Article image
Brexit? This election is about something much bigger than that | Ash Sarkar
This is about whether we have a future. After nine years of biting austerity, there has to be an alternative, says academic and activist Ash Sarkar

Ash Sarkar

28, Nov, 2019 @1:22 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson is uniting leave. Labour must now unite remain | Jonathan Freedland
The PM is determined to achieve Brexit. The opposition must mirror his clarity, says Guardian columnist Jonathan Freedland

Jonathan Freedland

26, Jul, 2019 @5:29 PM