John Cleese isn’t alone in equating ‘English’ with white. Sadly, that view is mainstream | Maya Goodfellow

The actor’s grumble about London reflects a wrongheaded view on immigration, unchanged since the days of empire

“Some years ago I opined that London was not really an English city any more,” is how John Cleese began a tweet on Wednesday. “Since then, virtually all my friends from abroad have confirmed my observation.” When eight long years ago he made a similar claim, he gave us the unabridged version. “I’m not sure what’s going on in Britain,” he said while appearing on an Australian TV programme. “Let me say this, I don’t know what’s going on in London because London is no longer an English city and that’s how they got the Olympics. They said: ‘We’re the most cosmopolitan city on Earth,’ but it doesn’t feel English.”

Where to start? Maybe with the most obvious point of them all: Cleese is fine with immigration if it’s him moving. It’s plausible that when he sat down to write this tweet, Cleese was in Nevis in the Caribbean. Having had enough of the England he cherishes so much, he announced last year he was planning to move there. The difference is obvious: he bemoans immigrants in London, but because of race and class he’s called an “expat” in the Caribbean.

Now, Cleese claimed his comments are not about race. But back in Australia, he gave more evidence for his argument. “I had a Californian friend come over two months ago, walk down the King’s Road and say to me: ‘Well, where are all the English people?’” Assuming they didn’t ask every single person they saw that day where they were born, how did Cleese’s Californian friend know none of them were English?

You have to wonder what does it mean for London not to be “English”? What does it mean to be an “English city”? Cleese gave us an idea in 2011: “I love being down in Bath,” he said, “because it feels like the England that I grew up in.” Who knows why Cleese feels at home there – is it because the overwhelming majority of the population of that city is white British?

But London, just like England, has always been constituted by global connections. Violent material, wealth and labour extraction from the colonies helped finance the industrial revolution and brought money flowing into the capital.

London and parts of Britain have always been diverse: Irish and Jewish migrants in the 1800s and early 1900s were considered racialised “others”; people from colonies and former colonies, who, after being educated on an English curriculum, came as citizens to work in the “mother country” were met with racism. This is perhaps not the England Cleese had in mind, but it’s the England that has long been. “There is no English history,” the academic Stuart Hall wrote, “without that other history.”

This history and what it means for England’s sense of self is ill understood. Cleese defended his comments by claiming “it’s legitimate to prefer one culture to another”, but there is no such thing as one static “culture” tied to one particular nation.

I think it's legitimate to prefer one culture to another

For example, I prefer cultures that do not tolerate female genital mutilation.

Will this will be considered racist by all those who hover, eagerly hoping that someone will offend them - on someone else's behalf, naturally https://t.co/4WbZDFjs3o

— John Cleese (@JohnCleese) May 30, 2019

But this is not just about Cleese – though that he’s an Oxbridge-educated, wealthy actor is a reminder of just how disingenuous it is for politicians to claim that it’s predominantly the “white working class” or the “left behind” who feel threatened by immigration. Fixating on the individual obscures the structural, and that’s where the real power and the real problem is. This very idea that Cleese is so wedded to – that immigration is making London less English – has been, in different ways, reproduced through the UK’s mainstream debate on immigration and race for decades, if not centuries. Only it’s been applied to the country as a whole, not just London.

The idea that national identity needs to be guarded against culturally different “others” was part of the reason 11 Labour MPs protested against the Empire Windrush docking at Tilbury in 1948. It was connected to Theresa May’s Home Office sending “go home” vans around diverse parts of the country, it’s what William Hague was referring to when he warned of the UK becoming a “foreign land”. It was also central to Tony Blair’s New Labour fixation on Britishness, on to Gordon Brown’s “British jobs for British workers” pledge and Ed Miliband’s 2015 election offer of controls on immigration. The underlying sentiment of Cleese’s comments is part of what politicians mean when they talk about listening and responding to people’s “legitimate concerns” about immigration. Here, perceived culture remains intimately connected to race.

Englishness and Britishness are, in all kinds of subtle ways, still tied to whiteness. The connection is there in the supremacist narratives of the British empire that suggest innate capability meant a country such as England “developed”. It’s detectable in the way certain immigrants and Britons – including people from eastern Europe, who are seen as part of a degraded whiteness – are more likely than others to be imagined as a threat to “British culture”. And it’s painfully obvious when you compare how some people’s Englishness is questioned (think Norman Tebbit’s “cricket test”) while other people’s is absolute.

The problem is far bigger than one comment made by one actor – it’s written into the way race, immigration and nation are understood in popular debate. And that is what we need to change.

• Maya Goodfellow is a writer and academic. Her book Hostile Environment: How Immigrants Became Scapegoats is out with Verso in Autumn.

Contributor

Maya Goodfellow

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Belgians are lazy, fat drunkards, John Cleese? Hold my beer | Emma Beddington
The grouchy Monty Python star didn’t take to the people of Hasselt on his latest tour. He could at least have been accurate in his insults, says freelance writer Emma Beddington

Emma Beddington

22, Jun, 2018 @10:38 AM

Article image
John Cleese should stop moaning. Comedy has moved on from the Pythons | Fiona Sturges
Monty Python was once the high benchmark of surrealist humour – but that was 45 years ago, says arts writer Fiona Sturges

Fiona Sturges

01, Aug, 2018 @6:12 PM

Article image
Museums are hiding their imperial pasts – which is why my tours are needed | Alice Procter
The Daily Mail doesn’t like my Uncomfortable Art Tours and their focus on slavery and colonialism, writes art historian Alice Procter

Alice Procter

23, Apr, 2018 @5:26 PM

Article image
Crude, racist textbooks have no place in today’s education system | David Lammy
Don’t teach children that Caribbean fathers are ‘largely absent’, teach them about slavery and exploitation, says Labour MP David Lammy

David Lammy

10, Oct, 2018 @10:36 AM

Article image
John Cleese criticised for saying London no longer an English city
Sadiq Khan and comedian Dom Joly among those condemning ‘racist’ and ‘hypocritical’ claims

Aamna Mohdin and Mattha Busby

29, May, 2019 @3:07 PM

Article image
Africa’s colonisation of the English language continues apace | Afua Hirsch
The British empire forced its colonies to abandon their own languages. Now they are making English their own, says Guardian columnist Afua Hirsch

Afua Hirsch

29, Jan, 2020 @6:21 PM

Article image
UK museums should be honest about being stuffed with stolen goods | Alice Procter
Institutions need to confront the issue of repatriation, says art historian Alice Procter

Alice Procter

20, Feb, 2019 @4:06 PM

Article image
Jacinda Ardern’s heartfelt apology spoke volumes about compassion | Afua Hirsch
Jacinda Ardern apologised for the murder of Grace Millane. Other nations could show humility for past wrongs, says Guardian columnist Afua Hirsch

Afua Hirsch

12, Dec, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Badenoch's empire comments speak to the enduring mentality of colonialism | Nesrine Malik
The equalities minister says she doesn’t care about Britain’s imperial impact. It’s a sign of how deep-rooted the legacy is, says Guardian columnist Nesrine Malik

Nesrine Malik

27, Sep, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Amritsar, 100 years on, remains an atrocity Britain cannot be allowed to forget | Mihir Bose
Hundreds were massacred by a British general who was later treated as a hero. There has still been no apology, says author Mihir Bose

Mihir Bose

12, Apr, 2019 @2:45 PM