Elon Musk may be a pain, but that doesn’t mean his ideas are crazy | John Naughton

Could Tesla owners one day farm out their cars as self-driving taxis?

You don’t have to be a psychiatrist to wonder if Elon Musk, the founder of Tesla, is off his rocker. I mean to say, how many leaders of US public companies get into trouble with the US Securities and Exchange Commission for falsely claiming that they have secured funding to take their company private at $420 a share – and then get sued and fined $40m? Or can you imagine another CEO who deals with Wall Street analysts by swatting away questions about his company’s capital requirements as if they were flies. “Excuse me. Next. Next,” he replied to one guy who was pressing him on the subject. “Boring, bonehead questions are not cool. Next?”

The view from Wall Street is that Musk is too volatile to be in charge of a big and potentially important public company. The charitable view is less judgemental: it is that, while he may have a short fuse, he’s also a gifted, visionary disrupter. But even those who take this tolerant view were taken aback when he declared at a recent public event that he could see “one million robo-taxis on the roads by 2020”.

By robo-taxis he means self-driving Tesla cars. Given that Tesla has had such difficulty ramping up production of its Model S “affordable” sedans, the prediction sounded, well, nuts. But, on the grounds that one can never be sure with Musk, it seemed worth exploring further before calling for the men in white coats.

Some interesting facts emerge from even a cursory search. First, while Tesla doesn’t have the manufacturing skills of Ford or Toyota, it managed to deliver 90,000 vehicles in the final quarter of 2018. Second, it turns out that in the high-end US market, Tesla is outselling BMW, Mercedes and Lexus. And there are interesting developments in the European market too. One industry source claims that in February the Tesla Model 3 outsold the Mercedes C-Class, BMW 3-Series and the Audi A4. But this merely confirms that Tesla has finally learned to produce cars at volume, and that affluent customers are prepared to buy them.

So what’s with this “robo-taxis” business? The key to it, according to Jean-Louis Gassée, a former Apple CEO and a seasoned observer of the tech industry, is that while Teslas might look like normal cars, in fact they represent a radically different conception of what an automobile should be. Although most cars nowadays have lots of electronics in them, their software is just an outsourced add-on to the hardware. In Teslas it’s the other way round: the hardware is the servant of the software. In those terms, the difference between an Audi A4, say, and the Tesla Model 3 is analogous to the difference between a Nokia feature-phone and an iPhone X.

What this means is that the nature and performance of a Tesla can be radically altered by a wireless software update. In 2017, for example, an update extended the range of Teslas in Florida to enable their owners to escape Hurricane Irma. But that’s small beer compared with the autopilot system that’s been available since 2014. Initially conceived as an advanced driver-assistance system, it has morphed into a system for a self-driving car. And it has been doing that in “shadow mode” by monitoring and logging every aspect of each Tesla’s journey – which means Tesla has terabytes of training data for its machine-learning systems.

What Musk foresees is a moment where Tesla owners can flick a switch that will turn their car into an autonomous vehicle that can function as a taxi (and therefore a revenue-earner) when it’s not needed. “The average Tesla car is parked for 22 hours per day,” he said. “Starting next year, owners will be able to flip a switch inside the Tesla app, and send out their car to pick up and drop off passengers autonomously, earning an estimated 65 cents per mile in fares.” Owners might be able to earn $30,000 in gross revenue a year from their cars, or more than $300,000 in revenue over the 11-year lifespan of their car.

This is an intriguing idea, but a lot has to happen on regulatory and other fronts before it becomes a reality – even in the US. It certainly won’t happen by 2020. Nor will there be a million Teslas on the road by then. Still, it’s not implausible in the longer term. Musk may be a pain in the ass, but he thinks out of the box. Besides, why should all the profits from self-driving cars go to the few corporations that will own and operate them?

What I’m reading

Talk really is cheap
“China only makes $8.46 from an iPhone – and that’s why Trump’s trade war is futile.” So runs the headline on a fascinating piece by Jason Dedrick, Greg Linden and Kenneth L Kraemer on the Conversation website.

The limits of consent
Go to Maciej Cegłowski’s Idle Words blog to read his bracing testimony to the US Senate on tech companies’ appropriation of our privacy.

That’s the way to do it

Read Hua Hsu’s lovely New Yorker essay on Umberto Eco’s classic manual How to Write a Thesis.


John Naughton

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The car is dead, long live the car, thanks to Tesla | John Naughton
Established carmakers may scoff at Elon Musk’s firm, but like Apple and the iPhone, it heralds a massive shake-up of the auto industry

John Naughton

06, Aug, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Elon Musk’s dream ideas
From superfast trains to colonising Mars – a selection of Elon Musk’s extraordinary ideas

Samuel Stolton

18, Feb, 2018 @6:59 AM

Article image
Jeff Bezos’s vision of life among the stars won’t mend a broken world
The Amazon founder returned to Earth last week with a pledge to help save the planet, but technology alone is not the answer

John Naughton

24, Jul, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Is Richard Branson’s high-speed train in a pneumatic tube pie in the sky?
First airlines, then spaceships. Now the Virgin boss wants to build Hyperloop One – a high-speed, pneumatic maglev railway. But engineering experts doubt that it will ever leave the station

Nic Fleming

22, Oct, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why a silicon chip shortage has left carmakers in the slow lane | John Naughton
A global dearth of these vital components, and a reliance on just-in-time manufacturing, has put the motor industry in a tricky spot

John Naughton

05, Jun, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Hertz’s supercharged Tesla deal could haul us into the electric vehicle age | John Naughton
The firm’s agreement to buy 100,000 cars from Elon Musk’s company could change people’s minds about EVs for good

John Naughton

30, Oct, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
The crucial flaw of self-driving cars? They will always need human involvement | John Naughton
The introduction of new technology into everyday life will always take longer than you think

John Naughton

15, Jul, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
The first self-driving car fatality proves nothing | John Naughton
The death of a driver using the Tesla Autopilot function doesn’t show that the technology is unsafe

John Naughton

17, Jul, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
The social app Clubhouse is an invitation to trouble | John Naughton
The startup’s invitation-only model gives it a sheen of exclusivity, but privacy horrors lurk behind the buzz

John Naughton

20, Feb, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
Apple has a blip and the world wobbles. Why? | John Naughton
Apple has published its latest quarterly figures and the doomsayers are again questioning its future. They should look at the facts

John Naughton

30, Oct, 2016 @8:00 AM