Assad can still be brought to justice – and Europe’s role is crucial | Natalie Nougayrède

Some very motivated lawyers are working hard to put Syrian war criminals in the dock, and we can all play a part

The hope must be that criminal justice will one day close in on Syria’s murderous dictator Bashar al-Assad, his henchmen and his enablers. And on that front, there’s been some good news recently: the arrests in Germany and France of three Syrian intelligence officials suspected of torture were groundbreaking. This came on top of the issuance of warrants and the filing of dozens of criminal complaints in a number of European countries, including Sweden and Austria.

It may take time, and the odds may currently look slim, but criminal investigators will eventually work their way up the chain of responsibility to incriminate Syria’s tyrant for the slaughter of his own people for almost eight straight years. Some very motivated lawyers and activists are preparing for the day when those who have perpetrated crimes against humanity in Syria will be held accountable. And it’s in Europe that those efforts are starting to yield the most notable results.

To understand why, think about the hundreds of thousands of Syrians who reached the continent after fleeing the nightmare in their homeland. Many can testify about crimes and help to document them. Members and cronies of the Assad regime have also long taken advantage of Europe as a holiday destination and a place to store assets. And several European countries, not least Germany, accept the notion of “universal jurisdiction”, which allows national courts to investigate and prosecute those responsible for mass crimes even if they were not committed on that country’s territory, by one of its nationals or against one of its nationals.

It’s true that geopolitics have gone Assad’s way since Russia and Iran intervened forcefully to prop him up. Russia made sure the UN was crippled in any attempt to stop the bloodshed or refer Syria to the international criminal court. The US has failed the Syrians by its inaction in the face of mass atrocities. Europe has too. Meanwhile, much of the talk today centres on Islamic State losing its last, shrunken stronghold, and on Trump pulling out US forces. And of course, there are vivid debates in our democracies over what to do about “our” nationals who fought alongside Isis or were lured to Syria by the deadly cult. Almost forgotten in all of this are the long-suffering Syrians themselves – the children suffocated by sarin gas and other chemical weapons, the torture chambers, the forced disappearances, the cities and neighbourhoods subjected to Scud missile attacks and barrel bombs dropped indiscriminately.

So those arrests in Germany and France mattered immensely. One Syrian refugee in Europe – who said he recognised one of the arrested men as his torturer – reacted to the news with these words: “I cried, but with a smile on my lips. It made me tremble for hours … I can now finally say that the impunity Assad’s agents have benefited from in Europe is over. The hope has now grown that Assad himself will one day stand trial.”

Prosecuting the authors of mass crimes is no panacea of course: it would have been much better to prevent them. But from the postwar Nuremberg trials to the 1990s international criminal courts set up for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, we know from survivors and the families of victims how important it is that the horror stories are told, that witnesses are heard, and that fundamental principles enshrined in human rights conventions are not ignored. We know also that something of our own integrity, as distant onlookers, is at stake. When future generations look back at an era in which an estimated half a million people were butchered and millions made homeless by one despot’s determination to cling on to power, they will ask: “What did you do?” Since 2011 Syria’s killing fields have been the vortex into which the principle of “never again”, stated so often after the second world war, has disappeared.

Seeking justice for Syrians is no doubt a marathon, but if history teaches us anything, it is that massive human rights violations must not be left unpunished – however long it takes to deliver justice – and not just because prosecutions can act as a deterrent against further slaughter. Relentlessly collecting evidence and establishing the facts are central to preventing history from being rewritten by those who will be tempted to deny such crimes ever took place. The Khmer Rouge trials in Cambodia were held two decades after the genocides. Pinochet was arrested eight years after his dictatorship ended in Chile. Slobodan Milosevic died in jail, not in a palace. Yes, these are difficult times for international justice, but if no international court can help Syrians to seek redress, then national courts can – and must.

After those arrests in Germany and France, I called Catherine Marchi-Uhel, a former French judge who heads a UN investigative mechanism set up in 2016 to prepare criminal case files on Syria. Will Assad ever be prosecuted, I wondered. The answer was “perhaps”, and not just Assad, because the UN will look into the authors of all crimes in Syria, including Isis and Syrian rebels. But Marchi-Uhel’s key message was this: international justice will find a way. “The situation will not for ever remain blocked,” she insisted. “We must have that vision.”

Her team needs more staff and resources – it needs Arabic speakers, analysts and tech experts for “digital evidence management”. So here’s a call-out: if you care, support the justice teams. They’ll reach their goal. An immense body of evidence is already available, not least because the Syrian regime has kept sinister registers of its misdeeds. Documents have been smuggled out. There is a mountain of metadata to search through to establish “the chain of custody”. And at the very top of that mountain sits Assad. Remember, he’s only 53 years old.

• Natalie Nougayrède is a Guardian columnist


Natalie Nougayrède

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on the crimes of Assad’s regime: slow, uncertain justice | Editorial
Editorial: The conviction of an intelligence official in Germany marks the end of impunity – but will more senior figures be held accountable?


25, Feb, 2021 @6:49 PM

Article image
From Syria to China, dictators are still getting away with murder | Jonathan Freedland
We can’t rely on the glacial pace of international law to provide justice, says the Guardian columnist Jonathan Freedland

Jonathan Freedland

26, Feb, 2021 @4:50 PM

Article image
If we want Vladimir Putin brought to justice, Nuremberg has much to teach us | John Kampfner
The blithe indifference of too many countries means Putin may feel safe, but history shows a determined world can prosecute evil, writes author and broadcaster John Kampfner

John Kampfner

10, Apr, 2023 @3:27 PM

Article image
I’m innocent but still in Guantánamo because Trump is denying me justice | Ahmed Rabbani
Today my lawyers will argue that crimes against humanity during the Afghan war should be investigated, says Guantánamo prisoner Ahmed Rabbani

Ahmed Rabbani

05, Dec, 2019 @12:49 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on war crimes trials: justice for Srebrenica’s victims | Editorial
Editorial: It took years to bring Bosnian Serb commander Ratko Mladić to trial. His conviction should give renewed impetus to the pursuit of other perpetrators


22, Nov, 2017 @7:31 PM

Article image
Macron and the west must not play along with Putin’s Syria endgame | Natalie Nougayrède
The French president has made a serious mistake in allowing Russia to distribute French aid, says Guardian columnist Natalie Nougayrède

Natalie Nougayrède

01, Aug, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
We are closer than ever to arresting Putin, but the US must play its part | Gordon Brown
This summer will be a crisis point for the Russian president, as demands for action intensify, says former UK prime minister Gordon Brown

Gordon Brown

23, May, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
If Idlib falls to Assad, it will not just be Syrians who pay the price | Labib al-Nahhas
The humanitarian disaster in Idlib would also create a new refugee crisis for Europe, says Labib al-Nahhas, a senior member of Syria’s political opposition

Labib al-Nahhas

28, Feb, 2020 @4:55 PM

Article image
Syria is a moral defeat for Europeans | Natalie Nougayrède
After 1945 Europe said “never again” but never again is happening before our eyes in the Middle East, says Guardian columnist Natalie Nougayrède

Natalie Nougayrède

27, Feb, 2018 @6:34 PM

Article image
Can evidence of mass killings in Syria end the inertia? Only with Putin's help | Jonathan Freedland
Jonathan Freedland: First thoughts: With little appetite for western military intervention, diplomatic channels must be unblocked

Jonathan Freedland

21, Jan, 2014 @11:27 AM