German Greens are on the rise. But the nation is divided | Anna Lehmann

The party has to address the concerns of groups beyond its urban base if it is to ultimately succeed

The Greens in Germany could hardly believe it. Leading party members were bouncing up and down when the public broadcasters sent the first, still uncertain results on the evening of the European Union elections. The green column rose to 20% and above, close to the black column of Angela Merkel’s Christian Democrats, which ended up with 22.6%. Party manager Michael Kellner was beaming as the numbers came in.

Over the course of the evening it became clear that the Green party had nearly doubled its seats in the European parliament and had overtaken the Social Democrats, the former “people’s party”. A historic victory for us, a historic disaster for them.

All over Europe, the Green parties enjoyed modest gains, but nowhere did they gain so many votes as in Germany. Last week they even came out on top in one national opinion poll, overtaking Merkel’s conservatives for the first time.

The success of the German Greens is surely linked to the weakness of the governing coalition of Christian and Social Democrats. Both parties struggle with image problems, partly connected to their leadership. The head of the Social Democrats, Andrea Nahles, has just stepped down following the party’s disastrous showing in the European elections. She was the party’s 10th leader in 15 years.

But the Green wave cannot be explained away by its rivals’ failings. For decades denounced as eco-nerds and tree-huggers, the Greens have now conquered the progressive middle class and captured the zeitgeist. Green issues such as environmental protection, climate emergency and clean energy are mainstream. Vegetarianism and organic food are popular lifestyle choices. An extremely hot summer and the diesel scandal caused by German carmaker Volkswagen made even more people wonder whether the philosophy of unlimited growth and endless use of natural resources should be questioned.

All across Europe, pupils are skipping lessons and demonstrating for their future – and the Greens are riding the wave while other political parties are simply swimming in unknown waters. A third of German voters under the age of 30 voted Green in the European elections. By comparison, 13% of the same age group voted for the Christian Democrats and 10% for the Social Democrats. It isn’t hard to predict which party will grow in the future and which parties could shrink.

But there’s another reason the Greens have gained popularity. After the summer of 2015, when hundreds of thousands of refugees migrated to Germany, the new far-right party, Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) grew stronger, fostering resentment and fear against migrants. Although some Green politicians pledged to help deportations, the party overall managed to stand up for a liberal migration policy and for being uncompromisingly pro-European. They are the antithesis of the growing nationalism, EU scepticism and anti-migration sentiment that is that is prevalent on the continent. So in a society that is deeply divided, the success of the Greens and the growth of the far right are two sides of the same coin.

The AfD won 11% of the votes in the European election. Compared with the national election in 2017, the party lost a few percent – and compared with Marine Le Pen’s National Rally in France, or Matteo Salvini’s League in Italy, its results were moderate.

But in the eastern German states, Saxony and Brandenburg, the AfD became the dominant party – apart from in Leipzig, the biggest town in Saxony, where the Greens became the strongest party for the first time in 30 years.

Twenty kilometres away from Leipzig, in the neat little village of Kieritzsch, one in two voters chose the AfD. It may have something to do with Kieritzsch being situated on the edge of an opencast mine. By 2038, coal-fired power production is meant to end in Germany and the mines will be shut down. The Greens want to speed up this process. The AfD, on the other hand, denies that climate change is manmade, and would keep the plant.

Because of their successes in big cities, the Greens are actually contributing to deeper divisions between urban and sparsely populated areas, between young and old, and between those who embrace globalisation and those who fear it.

So if they want to reconcile the different groups, the Greens have to focus on social issues as well, such as how to pay, and who will pay, for the transition from dirty to clean energy; from fossil fuel-powered cars to electric vehicles. Will it be chiefly the people in areas that today depend on coal plants and mines, or the owners of diesel cars?

When Emmanuel Macron in France proclaimed a tax on fuel he faced a nationwide movement of gilets jaunes. His experience shows that green and social questions have to be looked at together. So the Greens have to focus harder on social politics. A few weeks ago they presented their model of a basic income for all families with children. To achieve this they would have to form an alliance with the Social Democrats and the leftwing Die Linke. The Greens feel strong enough to ignore their approaches at the moment and leave all options open. That won’t work in the long run.

If the Greens fail to reconcile social and environmental matters, they risk being seen as part of a complacent elite, and will be fought by those who don’t feel represented. A fight like this, that leaves the political system as well as society wrecked, can be seen in Britain. Beware.

• Anna Lehmann is an editor on the Berlin-based daily newspaper Die Tageszeitung


Anna Lehmann

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on Greens in Europe: hopeful signs | Editorial
Editorial: An enlarged Green group in the European parliament would drive climate policy forward, and prove that the activism of recent months has been effective


21, May, 2019 @6:05 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Germany's Greens: opportunity knocks | Editorial
Editorial: Election year could deliver the best result in the party’s 40-year history, and send a message on climate targets from Europe’s most powerful state


16, Feb, 2021 @6:52 PM

Article image
Macron and Merkel are trying to safeguard Europe, not dominate it | Simon Tisdall
A new friendship treaty sees a bigger picture, writes Simon Tisdall, a foreign affairs commentator

Simon Tisdall

22, Jan, 2019 @5:07 PM

Article image
Could Angela Merkel’s successor be Europe’s saviour?| Alan Posener
Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer is a decisive pro-European who will fight to preserve the EU, says German journalist Alan Posener

Alan Posener

10, Dec, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
The EU banked on parliament rejecting no deal. Now that’s all changed | Anne McElvoy
Europe is starting to soften its stance, says Anne McElvoy, senior editor of the Economist

Anne McElvoy

30, Jul, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Don’t rely on Germany to solve Brexit, it doesn’t need to help Britain | Alan Posener
Angela Merkel has bigger worries at home, says German journalist Alan Posener

Alan Posener

17, Jan, 2019 @1:27 PM

Article image
Merkel’s exit will leave a gaping hole in centrist politics | Rafael Behr
With the rise of the far right threatening liberal democracy, Europe needs to find another stable ambassador, says Guardian columnist Rafael Behr

Rafael Behr

30, Oct, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
When it comes to Germany, there’s method in Trump’s madness | Alan Posener
The president’s opportunistic tweets have raised hackles, but no one can deny that Merkel’s coalition is in trouble, says German blogger Alan Posener

Alan Posener

19, Jun, 2018 @1:20 PM

Article image
How the refugee crisis created two myths of Angela Merkel | Daniel Trilling
The right says the German chancellor undermined EU security; Liberals say it was a triumph, writes Daniel Trilling, author of Lights in the Distance: Exile and Refuge at the Borders of Europe

Daniel Trilling

21, Sep, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
In 1989, capitalism won. Today its greatest ideological challenge is the planet | Larry Elliott
The fall of the iron curtain saw the market dominate. But the environmental has now become a significant rival, says Larry Elliott, the Guardian’s economics editor

Larry Elliott

09, Nov, 2019 @12:00 PM