You can expel your MP for fiddling expenses – but not violence or misogyny. Why? | Mandu Reid

As long as they avoid a custodial sentence, men who assault or harass cannot face recall from Commons. This is a scandal

• Mandu Reid is leader of the Women’s Equality party

I have never grabbed someone by the neck. Nor have I ever groped anyone, or looked at porn at work. I’ve never sent a colleague an inappropriate text message or asked someone I manage to buy sex toys for my partner. I have never been accused of rape. You would think that I wouldn’t need to clarify those things but, as a politician, I increasingly feel the need to. After all, there are more than a dozen men sitting in our House of Commons who have been accused of doing at least one of the above.

When Mark Field was caught on camera last week shoving a peaceful Greenpeace activist, Janet Barker, seizing her by the neck and roughly escorting her from a black-tie dinner there was public outcry. As a result he has been temporarily suspended from his ministerial position and police are investigating third-party reports of assault against him. I believe he should face recall by his constituents. But under current legislation that is impossible.

Nor is it possible to recall Damian Green, who admitted to lying about the thousands of pornographic images on his Commons computer and was accused of sexual harassment by a Tory party activist. Or Jared O’Mara, who made misogynistic and homophobic comments online in his 20s, including inviting the members of Girls Aloud to an orgy. Or any of the 20 other MPs, MSPs and assorted politicians who were accused of misconduct ranging from unwanted sexual advances to rape during the 2017 “Pestminster” scandal.

Those men continue to sit in our democratic institutions, voting on legislation that affects women’s lives. They work in Westminster, where one in five employees have reportedly experienced harassment. And while a few have been suspended from their parties, the public has no power to recall them from their position as elected representatives.

Under the Recall of MPs Act 2015 constituents can recall their MP if they receive a custodial sentence, if they are banned from the House of Commons for 10 sitting days (which only happens if they’ve previously been banned for a shorter period) or if they are convicted of providing a misleading expenses claim.

That means that so far this year, the public has been able to recall one MP for lying to avoid a speeding ticket and another for fiddling his expenses claim for two landscape photographs. But even if an MP admits to aggressive or violent behaviour, without a custodial sentence they are untouchable until the next election. That’s why the Women’s Equality party has written an open letter calling on parliament to amend the Recall Act 2015, to give the public the power to recall their representatives in cases where they have been found guilty of violence or harassment by the independent parliamentary commissioner for standards.

We live in a country where violence against women and girls is endemic yet rarely prosecuted. An astonishing 98.3% of rapes reported to the police in England and Wales do not lead to a conviction. Nor does assault always result in a prison sentence, with many perpetrators getting off with a fine. These problems urgently need to be addressed, but we should not have to wait for an improvement in conviction rates to ensure that MPs are held accountable for their actions.

Violent people do not belong in government. Let’s make that clear.

• Mandu Reid is leader of the Women’s Equality party


Mandu Reid

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
I reported on misogyny in parliament 29 years ago – shockingly little has changed | Jennifer Nadel
To stamp out bullying and harassment in Westminster, we need a whole shift, says Jennifer Nadel, co-founder of Compassion in Politics

Jennifer Nadel

18, Jul, 2019 @12:30 PM

Article image
All MPs should now see why grabbing someone’s knee is a problem | Caroline Lucas
Our cross-party group’s report on sexual harassment and bullying could be the start of a culture founded on dignity, writes Green party MP Caroline Lucas

Caroline Lucas

08, Feb, 2018 @1:48 PM

Article image
The law must change on upskirting. One Tory MP won’t stop us | Wera Hobhouse
I launched a bill to protect women from this degrading act. Christopher Chope will not deny them the right to feel safe, says Wera Hobhouse, the Liberal Democrat MP for Bath

Wera Hobhouse

15, Jun, 2018 @6:15 PM

Article image
We stormed the Baftas because the domestic violence bill is dangerous | Sisters Uncut
Theresa May’s bill is a distraction from the austerity cuts that have left support services crumbling and survivors in peril, writes Sisters Uncut, a feminist direct action group

Sisters Uncut

19, Feb, 2018 @11:07 AM

Article image
Is the Women’s Equality party too sensible for these extreme times? | Gaby Hinsliff
The party’s leader is right to eschew clickbait politics. But Sophie Walker must find a way to get her message across, writes Guardian columnist Gaby Hinsliff

Gaby Hinsliff

07, Sep, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
New passport checks for families are a sexist, backward step | Hannah Peaker
Mothers who have a different surname to their child will be penalised by the system – especially after Brexit, writes Women’s Equality party chief of staff Hannah Peaker

Hannah Peaker

07, Aug, 2018 @7:30 AM

Article image
The Women’s Equality party has taken on abuse in Westminster – and won | Mandu Reid
The party I lead has proved that politicians have a mandate to do right by women, says Mandu Reid, leader of the WEP

Mandu Reid

12, Dec, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Independent Group will only succeed if PR is their central policy | Catherine Mayer
If they are serious about fixing ‘broken politics’, they should join us in backing a fairer voting system, writes Women’s Equality party co-founder Catherine Mayer

Catherine Mayer

20, Feb, 2019 @12:34 PM

Article image
Overconfident men brought us Brexit. It’s not too late for women to fix it | Sophie Walker
The effects of leaving the EU will be particularly disastrous for women and the worse-off. WE has a different vision, says leader of the Women’s Equality party Sophie Walker

Sophie Walker

26, Jul, 2018 @2:46 PM

Article image
Why the May no-confidence vote was a vote against women in Westminster | Hannah Peaker
Trust in parties’ ability to hold men to account over alleged sexual misconduct has been eroded, says Hannah Peaker of the Women’s Equality party

Hannah Peaker

13, Dec, 2018 @5:59 PM