The Observer’s view on China’s reaction to pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong | Observer editorial

The only way forward is to stop posturing and begin a dialogue

In Hong Kong, China’s leaders are confronted by an old truth, familiar to more securely established governments, that with power comes responsibility. There is no doubt Beijing has the brute strength to crush pro-democracy protests in Britain’s former colony. Equally, there is no doubt it would be irresponsible and self-defeating to do so.

Satellite images of motorised units of China’s People’s Armed police holding drills across the border in Shenzhen last week have heightened a sense of foreboding among demonstrators, who have nevertheless been on the streets again this weekend. This threatening build-up is accompanied by shrill warnings of grave consequences from officials and state media.

China’s intensifying propaganda offensive is apparently intended to pre-emptively convince a watching world that any action it may take to quell the unrest would be justified. Maybe it hopes to convince itself, too. For weeks, Chinese media ignored the Hong Kong turmoil. Now, everybody in China knows what is happening – and what is at stake.

Perhaps for this latter reason, a fake narrative has been confected, intended to mislead public opinion. It is claimed, falsely, that the demonstrators are a violent, subversive minority, that they are “terrorists” and that they take orders from foreign “black hands”, meaning the US, Britain and Taiwan. These are the chimeras of a paranoid state.

This sense of rising insecurity at the top, coupled with evident uncertainty over what to do, was inadvertently confirmed last week by Liu Xiaoming, China’s unusually undiplomatic ambassador to Britain. He warned that China had the power to stop the protests and would not indefinitely “sit on its hands and watch”.

But Liu offered no suggestions about a peaceful way forward. Instead, he took a lazy swipe at unnamed British politicians who, he said, cling to a “colonial mindset”. This was an instructive choice of words, given that China’s high-handed behaviour in Hong Kong since 1997 carries more than a whiff of that same objectionable colonialism.

The stakes are indeed high. In question now, by some estimates, is the authority of China’s president for life, Xi Jinping. Under renewed scrutiny, thanks to the pro-democracy focus of the protests, is the unelected, arguably illegitimate nature of the Communist regime and its increasingly illiberal hold on Hong Kong.

The implications for China as a whole, where social unrest is more common than is often supposed and where an economic slowdown is causing hardship, are surely not lost on Xi and his fellow cadres. Donald Trump’s inane intervention, linking a “humane” solution to a US trade deal, further confuses the issue.

Lest it be forgotten, China fiercely opposed the limited democratic reforms championed by Chris Patten, Hong Kong’s last governor. Since taking over, Beijing has gradually tightened its political grip. In 2003, it provoked large-scale protests by trying to enforce a treason and subversion law. Its unbending resistance to pressure for greater democratic choice brought more trouble in 2007 and 2014. There has also been a spate of highly publicised cases of apparent human rights abuses.

Concerns about an extradition law proposed by the chief executive, Carrie Lam, have brought these unresolved issues back to the surface, reinvigorating a broader movement to defend Hong Kong’s freedoms. Meanwhile, harsh police tactics have produced just demands for an independent inquiry and the release of people arrested since June.

It should be clear to cooler heads in Beijing that this post-1997 legacy of rising discontent and disenchantment, and the party’s failure to deal with it, lies behind the current turmoil. If they are honest, they will admit, too, that while there is sympathy for the demonstrators in western capitals, the idea of a wicked foreign conspiracy is mere fantasy.

This problem is of China’s own making – and it is China’s to resolve. Typically, authoritarian governments like Beijing’s, lacking a democratic mandate, cannot tolerate opposition for fear it will expose their innate weakness. A similar state versus people stand-off has paralysed Moscow in recent weeks.

China must overcome its fears. The only sensible, mature way forward is to forswear the use of force, stop shouting and begin an open-ended, unconditional dialogue with its critics. It’s what strong, responsible leaders do.


Observer editorial

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Observer view on China’s rule over Hong Kong | Observer editorial
However much it offends our sensibilities, what can the west really do about Xi Jinping’s warped version of democracy?

Observer editorial

03, Jul, 2022 @5:30 AM

Article image
The Observer view on Britain’s feeble response to China’s assault on human rights | Observer editorial
Xi Jinping’s repressive policy on dissent in the former colony is starting to resemble a vendetta as Jimmy Lai faces a new trial

Observer editorial

27, Nov, 2022 @6:30 AM

Article image
It’s as if Hong Kong is now unmoored, so fast have the old ways unravelled | Louisa Lim and Ilaria Maria Sala
By refusing to address protesters, Carrie Lam is guilty of fuelling rising violent unrest

Louisa Lim and Ilaria Maria Sala

28, Jul, 2019 @5:16 AM

Article image
The Observer view on China’s human rights abuses in Hong Kong | Observer editorial
Western leaders must stand up against Beijing’s assault on democractic freedoms and demand the release of imprisoned journalists

Observer editorial

20, Jun, 2021 @5:30 AM

Article image
The Observer view on Trump's continued goading of China | Observer editorial
Donald Trump has used the pandemic to provoke a wider confrontation but Beijing should not be regarded as an enemy

Observer editorial

17, May, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Observer view on Britain’s future in an uncertain and perilous world | Observer editorial
Johnson will struggle to get Brexit done, let alone lead the country in an increasingly volatile age

Observer editorial

28, Dec, 2019 @9:00 PM

Article image
The Observer view on the real threat behind China’s spy balloon | Observer editorial
Washington and Beijing need to resume talks quickly before the hawks bring the world to war

Observer editorial

05, Feb, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
I covered Hong Kong for decades. Now I am forced to flee China’s ‘white terror’ | Steve Vines
After 35 years, the Observer’s former correspondent is leaving as what was once a haven of liberty and peace is transformed into a police state

Steve Vines

08, Aug, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Are global ambitions driving Xi’s approach to Korea? No, it’s about keeping the party on top | Steve Tsang
Beijing is not yet seeking to usurp the US in the area, but is acting to preserve the standing of the ruling elite

Steve Tsang

02, Sep, 2017 @11:04 PM

Article image
The Observer view on how the west should deal with rising China | Observer editorial
Xi Jinping’s expansionist policies abroad and dictatorship at home make pressing the need for new geopolitical strategy

Observer editorial

03, Jan, 2021 @6:00 AM