The BBC’s Bodyguard is becoming a ‘Netflix Original’. So who gets the credit? | Sarah Hughes

The streaming giant is so dominant, it can blur the line between shows it creates and shows it acquires

It’s the biggest ratings hit of this year so the news that Netflix has snapped up the international rights to Jed Mercurio’s Bodyguard should come as no surprise. Few dramas are as perfect for binge-watching as Mercurio’s edge-of-the-seat political thriller with its “wait did that really just happen?” plot twists. Netflix has always been particularly astute at nabbing headline-grabbing UK shows, with Peaky Blinders, The End of the F**king World and Happy Valley among the dramas to have found a second home and legions of new fans at home and around the world.

But is Netflix’s increasing dominance of the TV landscape really such a great thing? Are there potential pitfalls to the deal?

Early reports have already suggested that an international rights deal could threaten the BBC’s position as the home of any subsequent series of Bodyguard. In truth that seems unlikely – Mercurio, who created and writes the show, has been outspoken in his support for the corporation, which is also home to his hugely successful police corruption drama Line of Duty.

Yet it’s easy to see why such ideas have traction. After initially ploughing money into original content for high-budget, star-studded series such as House of Cards and The Crown, Netflix has of late begun to modify its model, turning instead to the people behind the camera. In the US, lucrative deals have been handed to Ryan Murphy and Shonda Rhimes, arguably the country’s two most high-profile showrunners, and certainly the two most associated with having their own brand of drama.

Murphy and Rhimes were offered complete creative control with their deals and will no doubt continue to create the sort of innovative programmes with which they made their names (although it’s worth noting that Netflix’s do-as-you-please model can in some cases lead to flabby series that are more filler than killer).

It’s also hard not to feel that something else will be lost on the way: while Murphy’s decision to leave Fox was largely driven by that company’s acquisition by Disney, it remains the case that his unique tone on shows from American Horror Story to Pose had revitalised the tiny Fox cable channel FX, giving them both creative kudos and a recognisable voice.

Claire Foy and Matt Smith in The Crown.
Claire Foy and Matt Smith in The Crown. Photograph: B/Netflix/Kobal/Rex Features

Similarly, Rhimes’ stories ensured that ABC was one of the few US networks to place women’s lives centre stage, and her loss from prime time will be keenly felt. It’s arguable that in the UK, Mercurio and Sally Wainwright fulfil a similar function: the strength of their writing voice is enough to drive viewers to a channel. No wonder Netflix are sniffing around.

There will be those who say this doesn’t matter. The way in which we watch TV is changing and network television is dying. In this scenario Netflix is the future, the place where one day we will all watch all our TV and resistance is futile.

They’re probably correct, and yet it’s hard not to feel frustrated when people talk about the innovative E4 series The End of the F**king World as a Netflix show, or praise them for The Good Place, which was originally made by the US network NBC. Both shows are inventive, unusual and represented a genuine commissioning risk for their original channels. Netflix shouldered none of that risk, instead sweeping in with their millions once the plaudits had come.

Again there are those who will say so what? Netflix simply provides a platform for a wider audience to grow. That’s true but it’s also slightly disingenuous. HBO once built brand loyalty on the back of a commitment to daring drama; the BBC became a byword for quality in the 80s and 90s thanks to dramas that genuinely broke the mould; Channel 4 originally made its name as the home of risk-taking TV. And yes Netflix is home to some thoughtful, clever and very successful original shows.

At the same time it blurs the line between the shows it creates and the ones it acquires, branding every new acquisition as a “Netflix Original” and using its financial muscle to dominate the market.

Does this ultimately matter? We live in a world that’s predicated on ease of access, where satisfaction is only a click or a voice command away. In this sense Netflix simply streamlines our consumption, making it easier to watch everything we want all in one place. How can that be wrong?

The simple answer is that it isn’t. Yet at the same time Bodyguard itself offers an interesting counterpoint. The reason Mercurio’s drama has dominated the national conversation is simple and obvious: we can’t binge the episodes. We have to tune in every Sunday together to find out the twists.

Put more simply, Netflix might have done a great deal in buying international rights to Bodyguard, but if Bodyguard had been a Netflix show from the beginning, the conversation about it would never have become quite so loud.

• Sarah Hughes is a Guardian TV writer


Sarah Hughes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on Bodyguard: to keep making brilliant shows, the BBC needs resources | Editorial
Editorial: It may be a golden age for TV, with masterpieces from Netflix and Amazon. But the BBC is still a vital part of the UK’s culture


19, Sep, 2018 @4:40 PM

Article image
Netflix might dominate our viewing, but cinema brings us a different sort of pleasure | Josh Appignanesi
In this golden age of binge-watching, I’m consumed by a nostalgia for what I feel is disappearing, says film-maker Josh Appignanesi

Josh Appignanesi

24, Dec, 2019 @10:00 AM

Article image
Memo to Bodyguard writers: Muslim women are more than victims or terrorists | Tasnim Nazeer
At a time when Islamophobic attacks are soaring, it’s despairing to see the BBC pander to dangerous stereotypes of hijab wearers says journalist Tasnim Nazeer

Tasnim Nazeer

24, Sep, 2018 @6:24 PM

Article image
After Tony Hall’s resignation, the BBC’s next boss will need nerves of steel | Emily Bell
The broadcaster faces an existential crisis - with challenges from government, from its digital rivals, and from its own staff, says media observer Emily Bell

Emily Bell

20, Jan, 2020 @7:08 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on His Dark Materials on the BBC: a perfect match | Editorial
Editorial: The lavish pleasures of the new TV adaptation should not blind us to the dangers that lie ahead for public service broadcasters


01, Nov, 2019 @6:25 PM

Article image
Stub it out: Netflix criticised for too many smoking scenes
Anti-smoking group finds streaming giant’s shows feature twice as many cigarettes and ‘tobacco incidents’ as traditional TV channels

Lanre Bakare

20, Mar, 2018 @1:30 PM

Article image
The Obamas have got a Netflix deal. Now every politician will want one | Matt Forde
There’s no bigger soapbox than the streaming giant. But have any other politicians got the charisma to pull it off, asks the political comedian Matt Forde

Matt Forde

24, May, 2018 @2:03 PM

Article image
Bodyguard takes on Vanity Fair in battle for Sunday night viewers
Major BBC and ITV dramas to compete at 9pm but catch-up means both could triumph

Jim Waterson

31, Aug, 2018 @1:35 PM

Article image
Why I played myself interviewing Keeley Hawes in Bodyguard | Andrew Marr
In the era of fake news should a real political journalist take part in a TV political drama? I have no worries BBC presenter Andrew Marr

Andrew Marr

30, Aug, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
What kind of a person does Netflix favourites think I am? | Lizzie O’Shea
I look at my algorithm-generated ‘Recommendations for Lizzie’, and I don’t like that person, says broadcaster Lizzie O’Shea

Lizzie O'Shea

16, Apr, 2018 @2:04 PM