The Guardian view on the Lib Dems: missing their moment | Editorial

With Labour moving left and the Tories turning right, there ought to be room in the centre of British politics. Yet the Liberal Democrats are struggling to appear relevant

One side-effect of the ideological mania gripping the Conservatives is to put a retrospective gloss on the 2010-15 coalition government. There is not much to cherish in the legacy of the administration that set Britain on an ill-judged course of austerity. But the unleashing of a more fanatical rightwing Tory impulse since 2015 testifies, in hindsight, to the restraining, if limited, influence of the Liberal Democrats in government. That isn’t much use to Vince Cable, a coalition cabinet minister three years ago, now leading a party parked on the margins. A reconfiguration of British politics – with Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour moving leftward and a radical rightwing Tory agenda – ought, perhaps, to leave room for a third-way English party. Yet the Lib Dems haven’t expanded into the space.

Their desultory performance has many causes. To protest against New Labour governments from a liberal-left position, only to then join forces with the Conservatives, was too violent a lurch for many of the party’s natural supporters. It looked craven in pursuit of power and the brand never recovered. Britain’s electoral system doesn’t help, squeezing smaller parties. The Lib Dems find themselves defined more by what they are not (neither Labour nor Tory) than by what they are. To articulate a positive identity will be Mr Cable’s most challenging task at his party’s annual conference next week. It should be added that the task is the same one that faced his predecessors, Tim Farron and Nick Clegg. When a mission goes unaccomplished for so long the question arises as to whether it can be done at all. The Lib Dems have been written off in the past and recovered. They are a resilient bunch, but no party has an inalienable right to be relevant.

Mr Cable does grasp the seriousness of the predicament. He has proposed substantial reforms to the party’s structure: opening it up to loosely affiliated supporters, making it easier for rank-and-file members to be selected as parliamentary candidates, making the leadership available to those outside parliament. In this way Mr Cable hopes to infuse his organisation with new energy in tune with the insurgent spirit of the times. He wants the Lib Dems to be a “movement for moderates”.

That might be a contradiction in terms. Traditionally, the moderate middle-way voter has not easily been fired up for activism in the way that movement politics implies. Much of the appeal of incremental, technocratic politics is that it leaves most citizens free to get on with their lives. But Mr Cable’s contention is that the current moment is different, chiefly because of Brexit, and that the liberal centre is ready to rise up. He may be right, although there is a catch: resistance to Brexit gives the Lib Dems a distinctive position, but it also risks orienting them towards the past and nostalgia for a less febrile era. That is not the insurgent style. That may be Mr Cable’s problem. He makes a good commentator on what ails the nation, but commentary and leadership are different skills.

The Lib Dems have faced structural obstacles to success in a polarised political climate, but when Brexit is such a conspicuous shambles it should have been possible, with some campaigning zeal, for the small, unabashedly pro-European party to raise its profile. That it has failed suggests a lack of urgency and dynamism at the top. There are many explanations for the Lib Dems’ current predicament, but at their conference next week the party must not wallow in excuses. The opportunity for a revival is real, and there is a real risk that it is being squandered.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
What to make of the Lib Dems’ record? | Letters
Letters: Readers share their views on the Liberal Democrats in the week that Jo Swinson was elected as their new leader


25, Jul, 2019 @4:55 PM

Article image
Nick Clegg persuades Lib Dems to stick with austerity
Deputy prime minister wins controversial motion saying party was right to back public spending cuts to reduce deficit

Rowena Mason and Patrick Wintour

16, Sep, 2013 @12:12 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on general election 2019: A fleeting chance to stop Boris Johnson in his tracks | Editorial
Editorial: The mood may be one of despair, but this election is critical to the country’s future. The best hope lies with Labour, despite its flaws


10, Dec, 2019 @7:13 PM

Article image
Only radical action will drag the economy from the brink | Seumas Milne
Seumas Milne: Coalition ministers know austerity isn't working, but they're locked into it. Labour needs to grasp the political opportunity

Seumas Milne

21, Sep, 2011 @9:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Corbynomics: more creativity please | Editorial
Editorial: the Labour party should be congratulated for its progressive economic ideas. But as Tory MPs prepare to drop austerity and start spending, the opposition needs to be bolder


27, May, 2018 @4:00 PM

Article image
The Liberal Democrat struggle to find a way forward | Letters
Letters from Michael Meadowcroft, Jeremy Beecham, Elizabeth York, Les Summers, Terry Ward and Margaret Phelps


18, Sep, 2018 @5:23 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Lib Dem leadership contest: it’s not just about Brexit | Editorial
Editorial: Ed Davey and Jo Swinson are fighting a more polite leadership contest than the Conservatives. But they need to talk about vision too


11, Jul, 2019 @5:34 PM

Article image
Now is the perfect time for Liberal Democrats to wield the knife | Polly Toynbee

Polly Toynbee: Nick Clegg is finished. But if Vince Cable leads an anti-austerity rebellion, he can help save his party and the UK economy too

Polly Toynbee

04, Jun, 2012 @9:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on universal credit: Labour’s plan makes sense | Editorial
Editorial: The underlying problem with the flagship Tory policy is the idea that claimants need to change. Could a new government turn this on its head?


30, Sep, 2019 @6:23 PM

Article image
Lib Dems needed now more than ever | Letters
Letters: Tony Greaves says that only the Liberal Democrats can provide the radical and progressive politics that the UK badly needs; while Catherine Hand says they should never be forgiven for propping up the Tories’ savage austerity programme


08, Nov, 2018 @5:48 PM