Nostalgia is on the rise in Europe – and it needn’t be a bad thing | Julian Baggini

We can’t return to the past, no matter what populist politicians promise. But we can learn from it to build a better future

There’s a lot of truth in the old joke that nostalgia ain’t what it used to be. The word itself has a sense that has been largely lost. Its original 17th-century coinage was as a kind of mental illness, a homesickness suffered by soldiers on foreign campaigns. Only lately did it morph into a warm, indulgent enjoyment of how things used to be.

Now nostalgia seems to be changing once again, turning into a different kind of pathology, one that infects not individuals but society. Bertelsmann Stiftung, a German foundation, has conducted a poll in Europe’s five largest nations and found that two thirds of Europeans believe that the world used to be a better place. These nostalgic Europeans are generally more rightwing and much more critical of immigration. The report claims that their discontent is being exploited by populists to “fuel dissatisfaction with the political system and distrust of mainstream political elites”.

Nostalgia should not become the property of reactionary xenophobes. Ironically, it’s a feeling with more potential than has yet been realised.

The best kind of nostalgia combines warm feelings towards what once was with sadness that it is, and can be, no more. To focus only on the bitter or the sweet in this is unbalanced. To only lament is to fail to appreciate the goodness that once was; to only enjoy is to deny the irretrievability of the past.

The kind of nostalgia that Bertelsmann Stiftung deplores fails to maintain this delicate tension. Populist politics tells people that their sadness is not necessary because the present can be as the past once was. The steel towns can be brought back to life, the streets can be largely free of those with different accents or skin colours, pensions can continue to be paid as they once were, even as the proportion of people above working age soars. The past is not irretrievable, it is simply being kept out of reach by rootless, mercenary elites who found it got in their way.

Remainers are not immune to this kind of nostalgia. Those who think all we need is a second referendum and we’ll get back all we have lost fail to appreciate the fundamental changes that made the Brexit vote possible. An EU with a future cannot be an EU unchanged from its past. Nor can the kind of domestic politics that created disdain for “Westminster elites” remain business as usual without stirring rebellion.

People’s March, London, 20 October 2018
‘Those who think all we need is a second referendum and we’ll get back all we have lost fail to appreciate the fundamental changes that made the Brexit vote possible.’ Photograph: RMV/REX/Shutterstock

A better kind of reflective nostalgia, however, can enable a lament for the past to help us build a different future. This requires us to distinguish what cannot be revived from what lies beaten but breathing.

For example, those of us who are already beginning to feel nostalgic when we pass though the passport lane for EU citizens need to remember that the institution has always been deeply flawed. What made it still precious was its role in bringing the historically bellicose nations of Europe closer together. Why not feel nostalgic if the emotions that stirs in turn stir us to try to get hearts and minds back focused on that invaluable goal of continental cooperation?

People who have fought for a better future always have to convince others that how things are is not how they always must be. One of the most powerful ways of proving this point is to show that things were different, and can be so again. Take the problem of our divided society and our increasingly polarised politics. There can be no return to the postwar consensus or a two-party system based on neat class lines. Indeed, good riddance to both, which are well past their best-by dates. But the civility of political debate and the understanding that whoever forms a government governs for all are not beyond salvation. We can be nostalgic for those without wanting to turn back the clock.

That’s why it’s wrong to dismiss nostalgia as pointless, insisting that the present is better in every way or that only the future matters. The future is as ephemeral as the past, which it soon becomes with frightening speed anyway. A person only capable of looking forward is as defective as one who can only look back. The idea that we should do neither but simply live in the moment is naive: human relationships and solidarity depend on us having shared pasts and futures.

We live in time, where past, present and future all have a significance. When nostalgia is tempered by an acceptance that change is unavoidable, it can help us both to appreciate what we once had and see more clearly what could still be. Used wisely, nostalgia doesn’t trap us in the past but helps point us to a better tomorrow.

• Julian Baggini, a British philosopher and author, runs the website Microphilosophy


Julian Baggini

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Why freedom of movement is causing divisions – across Europe | Ines Wagner
The EU must crack down on exploitation of ‘posted workers’, says academic Ines Wagner

Ines Wagner

16, Jan, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
Macron’s overblown vision for Europe shows how much it needs Britain | Simon Tisdall
The French president’s statist, scattergun and top-down solution to the EU’s problems won’t gladden remainers’ hearts, says foreign affairs commentator Simon Tisdall

Simon Tisdall

05, Mar, 2019 @5:53 PM

Article image
Macron and Merkel are trying to safeguard Europe, not dominate it | Simon Tisdall
A new friendship treaty sees a bigger picture, writes Simon Tisdall, a foreign affairs commentator

Simon Tisdall

22, Jan, 2019 @5:07 PM

Article image
Stopping Brexit is the right thing to do. But it will still hurt | Rafael Behr
Remainers need to make the case for staying in the EU after all. Because leaving is not worth the economic harm it will cause, says the Guardian columnist Rafael Behr

Rafael Behr

19, Mar, 2018 @5:55 PM

Article image
Brexit will ruin the lives of British citizens in Europe. We deserve a vote | Jane Golding
Our rights, as well as those of EU citizens in the UK, cannot be thrown away without our say, writes British in Europe chair Jane Golding

Jane Golding

14, Aug, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
Guess who helped the rise of Europe’s mini-Trumps? Brexit-poisoned Britain | Guy Verhofstadt
‘Strongmen’ such as Viktor Orbán abuse basic rule of law and threaten European democracy. And Britain has stayed silent, says Guy Verhofstadt

Guy Verhofstadt

28, Jun, 2018 @2:21 PM

Article image
As novichok unites Europe, Brexit seems more absurd | Natalie Nougayrède
Though Britain’s EU partners have shown solidarity, they note with sadness the loss of influence that makes the country vulnerable, says Guardian columnist Natalie Nougayrède

Natalie Nougayrède

27, Mar, 2018 @5:32 PM

Article image
Brexit is not an end to Britain’s liaison with Europe. It’s just a new beginning | Dan Snow
History shows us the lunar pull of Europe is irresistible, says historian Dan Snow

Dan Snow

01, Jan, 2019 @10:02 AM

Article image
I’m a care worker. The £30k immigration rule would decimate the sector | Karolina Gerlich
Under these post-Brexit plans, hard-working Europeans like me will not be welcome, says Karolina Gerlich

Karolina Gerlich

19, Dec, 2018 @3:16 PM

Article image
This deal could have been struck in 2021 – but the last thing Brexiters wanted was to get Brexit done | Fintan O'Toole
The leave ultras rely on their Eurosceptic grievances – no wonder Boris Johnson created the disastrous protocol, says Irish Times columnist Fintan O’Toole

Fintan O’Toole

28, Feb, 2023 @9:51 AM