The Guardian view on schools: boost children, not results | Editorial

In revealing the appalling treatment of children forced out by a top grammar school, a new report has highlighted the broader problem of ‘off-rolling’

An independent inquiry has laid bare both the callousness of policies which forced pupils out of a highly selective state school, and their downright illegality. St Olave’s, a grammar school in Orpington, south-east London, treated its students as “collateral damage”, the scathing report commissioned by Bromley council has found. The lengths to which it went to uphold and burnish its reputation for academic excellence are extraordinary and would be absurd if not so damaging to the children affected. But the case is not an anomaly; instead, it lies at the extreme end of a much more widespread problem.

The scandal emerged when the Guardian revealed that teenagers had been pushed out of the school halfway through the sixth form after failing to get top grades in end-of-year exams, leaving them distraught and struggling to find places to finish their A-levels. It was illegal to withdraw these places on academic grounds at this stage. Faced with legal action by parents and embarrassing publicity, the school reversed the policy. The headteacher was suspended and then resigned.

Wednesday’s report offers further shocking details of the school’s treatment of pupils coping with stressful circumstances including bereavement, health issues and abuse; and of how students were rejected without discussion or support. One of the peculiar aspects of the case is that St Olave’s results – as a selective school in a wealthy area – were already outstanding. High-achieving children were told they were not up to scratch. Other institutions have more basic concerns, being desperate to meet floor targets and to compete for pupils via their place in league tables. Amanda Spielman, the chief inspector of schools, has rightly highlighted the problem of “off-rolling” children to protect schools’ results, and has warned that children with special educational needs and disabilities are particularly vulnerable. Rejection is not always explicit; parents can be persuaded that their children would be better off elsewhere.

The problem is not merely that statistics fail to capture the true performance of schools. It is that measures meant to assess performance have become targets in their own right, distorting priorities. While many teachers remain dedicated to helping all students reach their potential, St Olave’s was not alone in “putting the institution above the pupils when in fact the institution is the pupils”, as the inquiry put it.

Secondly, the report testifies to an alarming lack of oversight to set things right when they go wrong – a concern also raised with regard to academies by MPs this week. The Department for Education lacks the capacity to make up for the shrinking role of local authorities. Parents complained to a succession of bodies, from the board of governors to Ofsted, without effect. Bromley council should be commended for commissioning this report; other local authorities should read it carefully. But a more fundamental reconsideration of the purpose of schools, and how we can make sure they achieve it, is needed.

Contributor

Editorial

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on educational inequality: no quick fixes | Editorial
Editorial: The disadvantaged pupils who lost out most during the pandemic will need targeted support to catch up

Editorial

06, Sep, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on educational priorities: arts not grammars | Editorial
Editorial: The UK government’s education policies are damaging and benefiting the few. It’s time for a rethink

Editorial

11, May, 2018 @4:05 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on higher education: more egalitarianism please | Editorial
Editorial: The UK government’s review into post-18 education must recognise that it is clearly a good that would benefit society if more widely available

Editorial

16, Aug, 2018 @5:45 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on schools reopening: a question of trust | Editorial
Editorial: Boris Johnson and his government have badly mishandled the crisis in education due to Covid-19. Instead of giving moral lectures, the prime minister should give teachers and parents the support they need.

Editorial

24, Aug, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
St Olave’s is not alone. Schools with dodgy practices are everywhere | Fiona Millar
The marketisation of schools has unleashed a dark side, says author Fiona Millar

Fiona Millar

12, Jul, 2018 @8:30 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on A-level algorithms: failing the test of fairness | Editorial
Editorial: The decision to link this year’s GCSE and A-level results to past performance entrenches inequalities that those unable to sit exams can do nothing about

Editorial

11, Aug, 2020 @5:05 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on record A-level results: a triumph over adversity | Editorial
Editorial: Celebrating students deserve immense credit after surviving an educational ordeal

Editorial

10, Aug, 2021 @6:18 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on religious education: teach humanism too | Editorial
Editorial: Religion is growing in importance, for good and ill. Studying it teaches us about ourselves – even if we don’t believe

Editorial

16, Feb, 2018 @4:59 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on civil service jobs: all sorts required | Editorial
Editorial: Divisions between academic and vocational education are symptomatic of our class-ridden society. Recruiting from a wider pool is a good move

Editorial

25, Nov, 2018 @6:27 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on A-levels: ministers, not pupils, have failed | Editorial
Editorial: Rigour was Michael Gove’s watchword. But the pandemic has exposed the exam system he built as brittle

Editorial

13, Aug, 2020 @6:18 PM